The effects of DonorNet 2007 on kidney distribution equity and efficiency

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

In 2007, UNOS released DonorNet 2007 ® (DN07) in hope of improving allocation equity and efficiency. We hypothesized that hard-to-place organs might be less efficiently handled through this regimented process. We analyzed associations between DN07 and center-level equity, number of refusals per organ and cold ischemia time (CIT). A total of 8244 kidney transplants between 1/2006 and 12/2006 (pre-DN07) were compared with 6029 transplants between 5/2007 and 2/2008 (post-DN07). Distribution equity was assessed by the Gini coefficient, changes in the number of refusals and CIT by negative binomial regression and discard rates by logistic regression. We estimated quantile-specific differences in CIT by bootstrapping. We found no significant change in center-level distribution equity after DN07. Number of refusals per organ increased by 20% (adjusted rate ratio 1.121.20 1.28, p <0.001) at the patient level and 11% (ARR 1.071.11 1.16, p <0.001) at the center level. Regression models of CIT showed no global change in CIT associated with DN07, but those kidneys with the longest CIT pre-DN07 had statistically significantly longer CIT post-DN07. The discard rate also increased significantly (ARR 1.061.11 1.17, p <0.001). DN07 has not improved equity or efficiency in allocation of deceased donor kidneys, and may be harming the allocation of hard-to-place kidneys.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1550-1557
Number of pages8
JournalAmerican Journal of Transplantation
Volume9
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 2009

Fingerprint

Cold Ischemia
Kidney
Transplants
Logistic Models
Tissue Donors

Keywords

  • Cold ischemia time
  • Deceased donor transplantation
  • DonorNet 2007
  • Equity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Transplantation
  • Immunology and Allergy
  • Pharmacology (medical)

Cite this

The effects of DonorNet 2007 on kidney distribution equity and efficiency. / Massie, Allan B; Zeger, Scott; Montgomery, R. A.; Segev, Dorry.

In: American Journal of Transplantation, Vol. 9, No. 7, 07.2009, p. 1550-1557.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b75863820d1e496caa606d5448d6cd76,
title = "The effects of DonorNet 2007 on kidney distribution equity and efficiency",
abstract = "In 2007, UNOS released DonorNet 2007 {\circledR} (DN07) in hope of improving allocation equity and efficiency. We hypothesized that hard-to-place organs might be less efficiently handled through this regimented process. We analyzed associations between DN07 and center-level equity, number of refusals per organ and cold ischemia time (CIT). A total of 8244 kidney transplants between 1/2006 and 12/2006 (pre-DN07) were compared with 6029 transplants between 5/2007 and 2/2008 (post-DN07). Distribution equity was assessed by the Gini coefficient, changes in the number of refusals and CIT by negative binomial regression and discard rates by logistic regression. We estimated quantile-specific differences in CIT by bootstrapping. We found no significant change in center-level distribution equity after DN07. Number of refusals per organ increased by 20{\%} (adjusted rate ratio 1.121.20 1.28, p <0.001) at the patient level and 11{\%} (ARR 1.071.11 1.16, p <0.001) at the center level. Regression models of CIT showed no global change in CIT associated with DN07, but those kidneys with the longest CIT pre-DN07 had statistically significantly longer CIT post-DN07. The discard rate also increased significantly (ARR 1.061.11 1.17, p <0.001). DN07 has not improved equity or efficiency in allocation of deceased donor kidneys, and may be harming the allocation of hard-to-place kidneys.",
keywords = "Cold ischemia time, Deceased donor transplantation, DonorNet 2007, Equity",
author = "Massie, {Allan B} and Scott Zeger and Montgomery, {R. A.} and Dorry Segev",
year = "2009",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02670.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "9",
pages = "1550--1557",
journal = "American Journal of Transplantation",
issn = "1600-6135",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The effects of DonorNet 2007 on kidney distribution equity and efficiency

AU - Massie, Allan B

AU - Zeger, Scott

AU - Montgomery, R. A.

AU - Segev, Dorry

PY - 2009/7

Y1 - 2009/7

N2 - In 2007, UNOS released DonorNet 2007 ® (DN07) in hope of improving allocation equity and efficiency. We hypothesized that hard-to-place organs might be less efficiently handled through this regimented process. We analyzed associations between DN07 and center-level equity, number of refusals per organ and cold ischemia time (CIT). A total of 8244 kidney transplants between 1/2006 and 12/2006 (pre-DN07) were compared with 6029 transplants between 5/2007 and 2/2008 (post-DN07). Distribution equity was assessed by the Gini coefficient, changes in the number of refusals and CIT by negative binomial regression and discard rates by logistic regression. We estimated quantile-specific differences in CIT by bootstrapping. We found no significant change in center-level distribution equity after DN07. Number of refusals per organ increased by 20% (adjusted rate ratio 1.121.20 1.28, p <0.001) at the patient level and 11% (ARR 1.071.11 1.16, p <0.001) at the center level. Regression models of CIT showed no global change in CIT associated with DN07, but those kidneys with the longest CIT pre-DN07 had statistically significantly longer CIT post-DN07. The discard rate also increased significantly (ARR 1.061.11 1.17, p <0.001). DN07 has not improved equity or efficiency in allocation of deceased donor kidneys, and may be harming the allocation of hard-to-place kidneys.

AB - In 2007, UNOS released DonorNet 2007 ® (DN07) in hope of improving allocation equity and efficiency. We hypothesized that hard-to-place organs might be less efficiently handled through this regimented process. We analyzed associations between DN07 and center-level equity, number of refusals per organ and cold ischemia time (CIT). A total of 8244 kidney transplants between 1/2006 and 12/2006 (pre-DN07) were compared with 6029 transplants between 5/2007 and 2/2008 (post-DN07). Distribution equity was assessed by the Gini coefficient, changes in the number of refusals and CIT by negative binomial regression and discard rates by logistic regression. We estimated quantile-specific differences in CIT by bootstrapping. We found no significant change in center-level distribution equity after DN07. Number of refusals per organ increased by 20% (adjusted rate ratio 1.121.20 1.28, p <0.001) at the patient level and 11% (ARR 1.071.11 1.16, p <0.001) at the center level. Regression models of CIT showed no global change in CIT associated with DN07, but those kidneys with the longest CIT pre-DN07 had statistically significantly longer CIT post-DN07. The discard rate also increased significantly (ARR 1.061.11 1.17, p <0.001). DN07 has not improved equity or efficiency in allocation of deceased donor kidneys, and may be harming the allocation of hard-to-place kidneys.

KW - Cold ischemia time

KW - Deceased donor transplantation

KW - DonorNet 2007

KW - Equity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=67649641274&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=67649641274&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02670.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1600-6143.2009.02670.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 19459793

AN - SCOPUS:67649641274

VL - 9

SP - 1550

EP - 1557

JO - American Journal of Transplantation

JF - American Journal of Transplantation

SN - 1600-6135

IS - 7

ER -