The effect of case management on the costs of health care for enrollees in Medicare Plus Choice Plans: A randomized trial

OBJECTIVE: To measure the effects of case management on an older population's costs of health care. DESIGN: A 1-year randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Multiple sites of care in San Francisco, California. PARTICIPANTS: Patients aged 65 or older of primary care physicians in a large provider organization bearing financial risk for their care (n = 6409). INTERVENTION: Screening for high risk and provision of social work-based case management. OUTCOME MEASURES: Volume and cost of hospital, physician, case management, and other health-related services. RESULTS: The experimental group used more case management services than the control group (0.09 vs 0.02 months per person, P < .001). The experimental group's average total payments for health care were slightly lower ($3148 vs $3277, P = .40). CONCLUSIONS: This study provides no statistically significant evidence that social work-oriented case management reduces the use or the cost of health care for high-risk older people. Other potentially favorable effects of this type of case management need to be evaluated, as do the effects of other types of case management.