Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency

Lucian Panait, Jose M. Larios, Robert A. Brenes, Tiffany T. Fancher, Michael S. Ajemian, Stanley J. Dudrick, Juan Sanchez

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Manual skill proficiency is not currently employed in selecting residents for general surgery training programs. The study objective was to assess whether the technical skill levels of applicants to a general surgery residency program are higher than those of internal medicine residents. Material and Methods: Forty-two applicants to a community general surgery program underwent manual skill testing on interview day. Four laparoscopic tasks on a virtual reality (VR) simulator (LapSim, Goteborg, Sweden) were tested. Performance scores were computer-generated. Participants' previous experience with other manual dexterity activities was assessed via a questionnaire. Applicants' self-perception of their surgical skills was correlated with their skill dexterity scores on the simulator. Candidates' simulator scores were also compared with those of a group of internal medicine interns (n = 9) and a group of mid-level surgical residents, PGY 2-3 (n = 7). Results: Simulator scores of the applicants were significantly lower than those of mid-level surgical residents in all VR tasks (P < 0.05). The internal medicine interns scored higher that the surgery candidates in three of four simulator tasks. Participation in other manual dexterity activities was not associated with increased dexterity scores. Conclusion: This study suggests that surgical dexterity levels do not correlate with the self-assessed skill levels or with previous experience with other manual dexterity activities. Moreover, there appears to be no self-selection of applicants for surgery residency based on actual surgical skills. Selection criteria for surgical training, which incorporate technical proficiency skills, may potentially better discriminate those applicants with an aptitude for a surgical specialty.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)189-194
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Surgical Research
Volume170
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 2011
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Internship and Residency
Internal Medicine
Surgical Specialties
Aptitude
Sweden
Self Concept
Patient Selection
Interviews
Education

Keywords

  • general surgery residency applicants
  • surgical skill testing
  • virtual reality

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Panait, L., Larios, J. M., Brenes, R. A., Fancher, T. T., Ajemian, M. S., Dudrick, S. J., & Sanchez, J. (2011). Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency. Journal of Surgical Research, 170(2), 189-194. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2011.04.006

Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency. / Panait, Lucian; Larios, Jose M.; Brenes, Robert A.; Fancher, Tiffany T.; Ajemian, Michael S.; Dudrick, Stanley J.; Sanchez, Juan.

In: Journal of Surgical Research, Vol. 170, No. 2, 10.2011, p. 189-194.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Panait, L, Larios, JM, Brenes, RA, Fancher, TT, Ajemian, MS, Dudrick, SJ & Sanchez, J 2011, 'Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency', Journal of Surgical Research, vol. 170, no. 2, pp. 189-194. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2011.04.006
Panait L, Larios JM, Brenes RA, Fancher TT, Ajemian MS, Dudrick SJ et al. Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency. Journal of Surgical Research. 2011 Oct;170(2):189-194. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2011.04.006
Panait, Lucian ; Larios, Jose M. ; Brenes, Robert A. ; Fancher, Tiffany T. ; Ajemian, Michael S. ; Dudrick, Stanley J. ; Sanchez, Juan. / Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency. In: Journal of Surgical Research. 2011 ; Vol. 170, No. 2. pp. 189-194.
@article{22ed226b3515471eae37975604cd249b,
title = "Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency",
abstract = "Background: Manual skill proficiency is not currently employed in selecting residents for general surgery training programs. The study objective was to assess whether the technical skill levels of applicants to a general surgery residency program are higher than those of internal medicine residents. Material and Methods: Forty-two applicants to a community general surgery program underwent manual skill testing on interview day. Four laparoscopic tasks on a virtual reality (VR) simulator (LapSim, Goteborg, Sweden) were tested. Performance scores were computer-generated. Participants' previous experience with other manual dexterity activities was assessed via a questionnaire. Applicants' self-perception of their surgical skills was correlated with their skill dexterity scores on the simulator. Candidates' simulator scores were also compared with those of a group of internal medicine interns (n = 9) and a group of mid-level surgical residents, PGY 2-3 (n = 7). Results: Simulator scores of the applicants were significantly lower than those of mid-level surgical residents in all VR tasks (P < 0.05). The internal medicine interns scored higher that the surgery candidates in three of four simulator tasks. Participation in other manual dexterity activities was not associated with increased dexterity scores. Conclusion: This study suggests that surgical dexterity levels do not correlate with the self-assessed skill levels or with previous experience with other manual dexterity activities. Moreover, there appears to be no self-selection of applicants for surgery residency based on actual surgical skills. Selection criteria for surgical training, which incorporate technical proficiency skills, may potentially better discriminate those applicants with an aptitude for a surgical specialty.",
keywords = "general surgery residency applicants, surgical skill testing, virtual reality",
author = "Lucian Panait and Larios, {Jose M.} and Brenes, {Robert A.} and Fancher, {Tiffany T.} and Ajemian, {Michael S.} and Dudrick, {Stanley J.} and Juan Sanchez",
year = "2011",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1016/j.jss.2011.04.006",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "170",
pages = "189--194",
journal = "Journal of Surgical Research",
issn = "0022-4804",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Surgical skills assessment of applicants to general surgery residency

AU - Panait, Lucian

AU - Larios, Jose M.

AU - Brenes, Robert A.

AU - Fancher, Tiffany T.

AU - Ajemian, Michael S.

AU - Dudrick, Stanley J.

AU - Sanchez, Juan

PY - 2011/10

Y1 - 2011/10

N2 - Background: Manual skill proficiency is not currently employed in selecting residents for general surgery training programs. The study objective was to assess whether the technical skill levels of applicants to a general surgery residency program are higher than those of internal medicine residents. Material and Methods: Forty-two applicants to a community general surgery program underwent manual skill testing on interview day. Four laparoscopic tasks on a virtual reality (VR) simulator (LapSim, Goteborg, Sweden) were tested. Performance scores were computer-generated. Participants' previous experience with other manual dexterity activities was assessed via a questionnaire. Applicants' self-perception of their surgical skills was correlated with their skill dexterity scores on the simulator. Candidates' simulator scores were also compared with those of a group of internal medicine interns (n = 9) and a group of mid-level surgical residents, PGY 2-3 (n = 7). Results: Simulator scores of the applicants were significantly lower than those of mid-level surgical residents in all VR tasks (P < 0.05). The internal medicine interns scored higher that the surgery candidates in three of four simulator tasks. Participation in other manual dexterity activities was not associated with increased dexterity scores. Conclusion: This study suggests that surgical dexterity levels do not correlate with the self-assessed skill levels or with previous experience with other manual dexterity activities. Moreover, there appears to be no self-selection of applicants for surgery residency based on actual surgical skills. Selection criteria for surgical training, which incorporate technical proficiency skills, may potentially better discriminate those applicants with an aptitude for a surgical specialty.

AB - Background: Manual skill proficiency is not currently employed in selecting residents for general surgery training programs. The study objective was to assess whether the technical skill levels of applicants to a general surgery residency program are higher than those of internal medicine residents. Material and Methods: Forty-two applicants to a community general surgery program underwent manual skill testing on interview day. Four laparoscopic tasks on a virtual reality (VR) simulator (LapSim, Goteborg, Sweden) were tested. Performance scores were computer-generated. Participants' previous experience with other manual dexterity activities was assessed via a questionnaire. Applicants' self-perception of their surgical skills was correlated with their skill dexterity scores on the simulator. Candidates' simulator scores were also compared with those of a group of internal medicine interns (n = 9) and a group of mid-level surgical residents, PGY 2-3 (n = 7). Results: Simulator scores of the applicants were significantly lower than those of mid-level surgical residents in all VR tasks (P < 0.05). The internal medicine interns scored higher that the surgery candidates in three of four simulator tasks. Participation in other manual dexterity activities was not associated with increased dexterity scores. Conclusion: This study suggests that surgical dexterity levels do not correlate with the self-assessed skill levels or with previous experience with other manual dexterity activities. Moreover, there appears to be no self-selection of applicants for surgery residency based on actual surgical skills. Selection criteria for surgical training, which incorporate technical proficiency skills, may potentially better discriminate those applicants with an aptitude for a surgical specialty.

KW - general surgery residency applicants

KW - surgical skill testing

KW - virtual reality

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=80052816689&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=80052816689&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jss.2011.04.006

DO - 10.1016/j.jss.2011.04.006

M3 - Article

C2 - 21612796

AN - SCOPUS:80052816689

VL - 170

SP - 189

EP - 194

JO - Journal of Surgical Research

JF - Journal of Surgical Research

SN - 0022-4804

IS - 2

ER -