Surgery: The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies

Norbert Gleicher, Edmond Confino, Randle Corfman, Carolyn Coulam, Alan Decherney, Gilbert Haas, Eugene Katz, Earle Robinson, Ilan Tur-kaspa, Michael Vermesh

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Transvaginal tubal catheterization procedures have been suggested as an alternative to microsurgery and in-vitro fertilization (IVF) in the treatment of women with proximal tubal occlusion. A transcervical balloon tuboplasty (TBT) catheter was specifically developed and tested in a prospective multicentre trial. A total of 151 women with confirmed bilateral or unilateral tubal occlusion were studied. The primary study population included 106 women who, after exclusion of patients for protocol violations, represented those females who were treated for complete tubal occlusion with TBT. TBT is an ambulatory, minimally invasive catheter procedure, performed under paracervical block or mild sedation, which utilizes a co-axial balloon catheter under fluoroscopic guidance. Re-canalization, pregnancy and re-occlusion rates following the procedure were documented. A total of 28 patients demonstrating uni- or bilateral tubal patency after either hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography represented the control population. TBT established tubal patency of at least one Fallopian tube in 95/106 patients (90%) and in 167/205 obstructed oviducts (82%). Clinical pregnancies occurred in 37/106 females (35%), with a life table adjusted rate of 37%. Patients without distal disease had significantly higher pregnancy rates than those with bipolar tubal disease (49% versus 12%, life table adjusted rate; P = 0.0002) but pregnancy rates were independent of underlying aetiology for tubal disease. Pregnancy rates in control patients who did not reach TBT because of tubal patency after hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography were significantly lower than in those successfully treated with TBT (P = 0.027), and occurred only for four cycles after hysterosalpingography and with approximately a 1 year delay after selective salpingography. On long-term follow-up 70% of TBT-treated females had either conceived or at least maintained unilateral tubal patency (life table adjusted rate). This study establishes procedures which utilize the vaginal/cervical approach, and especially the TBT, as primary procedures of choice in the treatment of selected patients with proximal tubal disease. It has potential medical as well as economic advantages over competing surgical procedures and over IVF.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1264-1271
Number of pages8
JournalHuman Reproduction
Volume8
Issue number8
StatePublished - Aug 1993
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Hysterosalpingography
Balloon
Balloons
Surgery
Technology
Tubal Sterilization
Pregnancy
Life Tables
Alternatives
Pregnancy Rate
Life Table
Occlusion
Catheters
Fertilization in Vitro
In Vitro Fertilization
Obstetrical Anesthesia
Oviducts
Microsurgery
Fallopian Tubes
Catheterization

Keywords

  • Balloon tuboplasty
  • Tubal catheterization
  • Tubal obstruction

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty
  • Applied Mathematics
  • Physiology (medical)
  • Reproductive Medicine
  • Obstetrics and Gynecology
  • Rehabilitation
  • Developmental Biology
  • Physiology

Cite this

Gleicher, N., Confino, E., Corfman, R., Coulam, C., Decherney, A., Haas, G., ... Vermesh, M. (1993). Surgery: The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies. Human Reproduction, 8(8), 1264-1271.

Surgery : The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies. / Gleicher, Norbert; Confino, Edmond; Corfman, Randle; Coulam, Carolyn; Decherney, Alan; Haas, Gilbert; Katz, Eugene; Robinson, Earle; Tur-kaspa, Ilan; Vermesh, Michael.

In: Human Reproduction, Vol. 8, No. 8, 08.1993, p. 1264-1271.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gleicher, N, Confino, E, Corfman, R, Coulam, C, Decherney, A, Haas, G, Katz, E, Robinson, E, Tur-kaspa, I & Vermesh, M 1993, 'Surgery: The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies', Human Reproduction, vol. 8, no. 8, pp. 1264-1271.
Gleicher N, Confino E, Corfman R, Coulam C, Decherney A, Haas G et al. Surgery: The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies. Human Reproduction. 1993 Aug;8(8):1264-1271.
Gleicher, Norbert ; Confino, Edmond ; Corfman, Randle ; Coulam, Carolyn ; Decherney, Alan ; Haas, Gilbert ; Katz, Eugene ; Robinson, Earle ; Tur-kaspa, Ilan ; Vermesh, Michael. / Surgery : The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies. In: Human Reproduction. 1993 ; Vol. 8, No. 8. pp. 1264-1271.
@article{601f0b96c26f4f53ac4ae24a9464e3a6,
title = "Surgery: The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies",
abstract = "Transvaginal tubal catheterization procedures have been suggested as an alternative to microsurgery and in-vitro fertilization (IVF) in the treatment of women with proximal tubal occlusion. A transcervical balloon tuboplasty (TBT) catheter was specifically developed and tested in a prospective multicentre trial. A total of 151 women with confirmed bilateral or unilateral tubal occlusion were studied. The primary study population included 106 women who, after exclusion of patients for protocol violations, represented those females who were treated for complete tubal occlusion with TBT. TBT is an ambulatory, minimally invasive catheter procedure, performed under paracervical block or mild sedation, which utilizes a co-axial balloon catheter under fluoroscopic guidance. Re-canalization, pregnancy and re-occlusion rates following the procedure were documented. A total of 28 patients demonstrating uni- or bilateral tubal patency after either hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography represented the control population. TBT established tubal patency of at least one Fallopian tube in 95/106 patients (90{\%}) and in 167/205 obstructed oviducts (82{\%}). Clinical pregnancies occurred in 37/106 females (35{\%}), with a life table adjusted rate of 37{\%}. Patients without distal disease had significantly higher pregnancy rates than those with bipolar tubal disease (49{\%} versus 12{\%}, life table adjusted rate; P = 0.0002) but pregnancy rates were independent of underlying aetiology for tubal disease. Pregnancy rates in control patients who did not reach TBT because of tubal patency after hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography were significantly lower than in those successfully treated with TBT (P = 0.027), and occurred only for four cycles after hysterosalpingography and with approximately a 1 year delay after selective salpingography. On long-term follow-up 70{\%} of TBT-treated females had either conceived or at least maintained unilateral tubal patency (life table adjusted rate). This study establishes procedures which utilize the vaginal/cervical approach, and especially the TBT, as primary procedures of choice in the treatment of selected patients with proximal tubal disease. It has potential medical as well as economic advantages over competing surgical procedures and over IVF.",
keywords = "Balloon tuboplasty, Tubal catheterization, Tubal obstruction",
author = "Norbert Gleicher and Edmond Confino and Randle Corfman and Carolyn Coulam and Alan Decherney and Gilbert Haas and Eugene Katz and Earle Robinson and Ilan Tur-kaspa and Michael Vermesh",
year = "1993",
month = "8",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "8",
pages = "1264--1271",
journal = "Human Reproduction",
issn = "0268-1161",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Surgery

T2 - The multicentre transcervical balloon tuboplasty study: Conclusions and comparison to alternative technologies

AU - Gleicher, Norbert

AU - Confino, Edmond

AU - Corfman, Randle

AU - Coulam, Carolyn

AU - Decherney, Alan

AU - Haas, Gilbert

AU - Katz, Eugene

AU - Robinson, Earle

AU - Tur-kaspa, Ilan

AU - Vermesh, Michael

PY - 1993/8

Y1 - 1993/8

N2 - Transvaginal tubal catheterization procedures have been suggested as an alternative to microsurgery and in-vitro fertilization (IVF) in the treatment of women with proximal tubal occlusion. A transcervical balloon tuboplasty (TBT) catheter was specifically developed and tested in a prospective multicentre trial. A total of 151 women with confirmed bilateral or unilateral tubal occlusion were studied. The primary study population included 106 women who, after exclusion of patients for protocol violations, represented those females who were treated for complete tubal occlusion with TBT. TBT is an ambulatory, minimally invasive catheter procedure, performed under paracervical block or mild sedation, which utilizes a co-axial balloon catheter under fluoroscopic guidance. Re-canalization, pregnancy and re-occlusion rates following the procedure were documented. A total of 28 patients demonstrating uni- or bilateral tubal patency after either hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography represented the control population. TBT established tubal patency of at least one Fallopian tube in 95/106 patients (90%) and in 167/205 obstructed oviducts (82%). Clinical pregnancies occurred in 37/106 females (35%), with a life table adjusted rate of 37%. Patients without distal disease had significantly higher pregnancy rates than those with bipolar tubal disease (49% versus 12%, life table adjusted rate; P = 0.0002) but pregnancy rates were independent of underlying aetiology for tubal disease. Pregnancy rates in control patients who did not reach TBT because of tubal patency after hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography were significantly lower than in those successfully treated with TBT (P = 0.027), and occurred only for four cycles after hysterosalpingography and with approximately a 1 year delay after selective salpingography. On long-term follow-up 70% of TBT-treated females had either conceived or at least maintained unilateral tubal patency (life table adjusted rate). This study establishes procedures which utilize the vaginal/cervical approach, and especially the TBT, as primary procedures of choice in the treatment of selected patients with proximal tubal disease. It has potential medical as well as economic advantages over competing surgical procedures and over IVF.

AB - Transvaginal tubal catheterization procedures have been suggested as an alternative to microsurgery and in-vitro fertilization (IVF) in the treatment of women with proximal tubal occlusion. A transcervical balloon tuboplasty (TBT) catheter was specifically developed and tested in a prospective multicentre trial. A total of 151 women with confirmed bilateral or unilateral tubal occlusion were studied. The primary study population included 106 women who, after exclusion of patients for protocol violations, represented those females who were treated for complete tubal occlusion with TBT. TBT is an ambulatory, minimally invasive catheter procedure, performed under paracervical block or mild sedation, which utilizes a co-axial balloon catheter under fluoroscopic guidance. Re-canalization, pregnancy and re-occlusion rates following the procedure were documented. A total of 28 patients demonstrating uni- or bilateral tubal patency after either hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography represented the control population. TBT established tubal patency of at least one Fallopian tube in 95/106 patients (90%) and in 167/205 obstructed oviducts (82%). Clinical pregnancies occurred in 37/106 females (35%), with a life table adjusted rate of 37%. Patients without distal disease had significantly higher pregnancy rates than those with bipolar tubal disease (49% versus 12%, life table adjusted rate; P = 0.0002) but pregnancy rates were independent of underlying aetiology for tubal disease. Pregnancy rates in control patients who did not reach TBT because of tubal patency after hysterosalpingography and/or selective salpingography were significantly lower than in those successfully treated with TBT (P = 0.027), and occurred only for four cycles after hysterosalpingography and with approximately a 1 year delay after selective salpingography. On long-term follow-up 70% of TBT-treated females had either conceived or at least maintained unilateral tubal patency (life table adjusted rate). This study establishes procedures which utilize the vaginal/cervical approach, and especially the TBT, as primary procedures of choice in the treatment of selected patients with proximal tubal disease. It has potential medical as well as economic advantages over competing surgical procedures and over IVF.

KW - Balloon tuboplasty

KW - Tubal catheterization

KW - Tubal obstruction

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0027292781&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0027292781&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 8408524

AN - SCOPUS:0027292781

VL - 8

SP - 1264

EP - 1271

JO - Human Reproduction

JF - Human Reproduction

SN - 0268-1161

IS - 8

ER -