Supervision and autonomy of ophthalmology residents in the outpatient clinic in the United States II: A survey of senior residents

Eric L Singman, Michael Boland, Jing Tian, Laura K. Green, Divya Srikumaran, Andrew J. Barkmeier, Andrew J. Hendershot, Andrew Thliveris, Daniel B. Moore, Darrell Wudunn, David J. Goldman, Evan L. Waxman, Gary Domeracki, Gary L. Legault, Jeff Pettey, John J. Chen, Joshua H. Olson, Jules Winokur, Marcus Colyer, Martin MayersMichael J. Wilkinson, Michael S. Lee, Misha Syed, Mitchell Drucker, Mitchell P. Weikert, Parisa Taravati, Peter Veldman, Pratap Challa, Preston H. Blomquist, R. Michael Siatkowski, Robert Granadier, Shane Havens, Susan M. Culican, Tara A. Uhler, Thomas J. Whittaker

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Abstract

Background: A balance between autonomy and supervision can be difficult to obtain in medical education. In this study, we sought to determine whether the presence and level of supervision of ophthalmology resident outpatient clinic correlates with metrics of resident success, professionalism and stress. Methods: A survey was emailed to all US ophthalmology program directors requesting it be forwarded to PGY4 residents. Questions included whether their program provided a resident-hosted outpatient clinic, and if so, whether residents were mandated to discuss every patient with faculty. Residents were assigned to three categories based on this question (0: no clinic, 1: mandated faculty input, 2: discretionary faculty input). Success metrics included numbers of manuscripts submitted, OKAP scores and success in obtaining fellowships. Professionalism metrics included rating comfort obtaining informed consent, breaking bad news, managing time in clinic, and confidence in providing care in various settings. Residents affirming participation in a continuity clinic also provided perceptions of the level of supervision and how the clinic affected stress. Results: Category 1 residents perceived somewhat too much supervision, while category 2 residents felt that they had somewhat insufficient supervision. The majority of residents in either category did not feel that the continuity clinic affected their overall stress, although those who reported a change in stress usually indicated that the presence of the clinic increased stress. There were no other statistically significant differences between the responses from any category. Conclusions: The presence of a resident-hosted continuity clinic neither adds nor detracts from the success or sense of professionalism of ophthalmology residents. However, when such a clinic is present, the degree of supervision appears to correlate inversely with resident perception of autonomy. These results suggest that the decision of a training program to offer a clinic hosted by residents offering comprehensive continuity care can be informed primarily by faculty and trainee philosophy and personal preferences without comprising education quality, clinical efficiency, residents' perception of stress or their success in fellowship matching.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number202
JournalBMC medical education
Volume19
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 13 2019

Fingerprint

outpatient clinic
supervision
autonomy
resident
continuity
trainee

Keywords

  • Autonomy
  • Burnout
  • Clinic
  • Education
  • Ophthalmology
  • Outpatient
  • Professionalism
  • Resident
  • Stress
  • Supervision

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

Supervision and autonomy of ophthalmology residents in the outpatient clinic in the United States II : A survey of senior residents. / Singman, Eric L; Boland, Michael; Tian, Jing; Green, Laura K.; Srikumaran, Divya; Barkmeier, Andrew J.; Hendershot, Andrew J.; Thliveris, Andrew; Moore, Daniel B.; Wudunn, Darrell; Goldman, David J.; Waxman, Evan L.; Domeracki, Gary; Legault, Gary L.; Pettey, Jeff; Chen, John J.; Olson, Joshua H.; Winokur, Jules; Colyer, Marcus; Mayers, Martin; Wilkinson, Michael J.; Lee, Michael S.; Syed, Misha; Drucker, Mitchell; Weikert, Mitchell P.; Taravati, Parisa; Veldman, Peter; Challa, Pratap; Blomquist, Preston H.; Siatkowski, R. Michael; Granadier, Robert; Havens, Shane; Culican, Susan M.; Uhler, Tara A.; Whittaker, Thomas J.

In: BMC medical education, Vol. 19, No. 1, 202, 13.06.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Singman, EL, Boland, M, Tian, J, Green, LK, Srikumaran, D, Barkmeier, AJ, Hendershot, AJ, Thliveris, A, Moore, DB, Wudunn, D, Goldman, DJ, Waxman, EL, Domeracki, G, Legault, GL, Pettey, J, Chen, JJ, Olson, JH, Winokur, J, Colyer, M, Mayers, M, Wilkinson, MJ, Lee, MS, Syed, M, Drucker, M, Weikert, MP, Taravati, P, Veldman, P, Challa, P, Blomquist, PH, Siatkowski, RM, Granadier, R, Havens, S, Culican, SM, Uhler, TA & Whittaker, TJ 2019, 'Supervision and autonomy of ophthalmology residents in the outpatient clinic in the United States II: A survey of senior residents', BMC medical education, vol. 19, no. 1, 202. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-019-1620-0
Singman, Eric L ; Boland, Michael ; Tian, Jing ; Green, Laura K. ; Srikumaran, Divya ; Barkmeier, Andrew J. ; Hendershot, Andrew J. ; Thliveris, Andrew ; Moore, Daniel B. ; Wudunn, Darrell ; Goldman, David J. ; Waxman, Evan L. ; Domeracki, Gary ; Legault, Gary L. ; Pettey, Jeff ; Chen, John J. ; Olson, Joshua H. ; Winokur, Jules ; Colyer, Marcus ; Mayers, Martin ; Wilkinson, Michael J. ; Lee, Michael S. ; Syed, Misha ; Drucker, Mitchell ; Weikert, Mitchell P. ; Taravati, Parisa ; Veldman, Peter ; Challa, Pratap ; Blomquist, Preston H. ; Siatkowski, R. Michael ; Granadier, Robert ; Havens, Shane ; Culican, Susan M. ; Uhler, Tara A. ; Whittaker, Thomas J. / Supervision and autonomy of ophthalmology residents in the outpatient clinic in the United States II : A survey of senior residents. In: BMC medical education. 2019 ; Vol. 19, No. 1.
@article{cded2d7ff5a74fee8b1be497b4293b00,
title = "Supervision and autonomy of ophthalmology residents in the outpatient clinic in the United States II: A survey of senior residents",
abstract = "Background: A balance between autonomy and supervision can be difficult to obtain in medical education. In this study, we sought to determine whether the presence and level of supervision of ophthalmology resident outpatient clinic correlates with metrics of resident success, professionalism and stress. Methods: A survey was emailed to all US ophthalmology program directors requesting it be forwarded to PGY4 residents. Questions included whether their program provided a resident-hosted outpatient clinic, and if so, whether residents were mandated to discuss every patient with faculty. Residents were assigned to three categories based on this question (0: no clinic, 1: mandated faculty input, 2: discretionary faculty input). Success metrics included numbers of manuscripts submitted, OKAP scores and success in obtaining fellowships. Professionalism metrics included rating comfort obtaining informed consent, breaking bad news, managing time in clinic, and confidence in providing care in various settings. Residents affirming participation in a continuity clinic also provided perceptions of the level of supervision and how the clinic affected stress. Results: Category 1 residents perceived somewhat too much supervision, while category 2 residents felt that they had somewhat insufficient supervision. The majority of residents in either category did not feel that the continuity clinic affected their overall stress, although those who reported a change in stress usually indicated that the presence of the clinic increased stress. There were no other statistically significant differences between the responses from any category. Conclusions: The presence of a resident-hosted continuity clinic neither adds nor detracts from the success or sense of professionalism of ophthalmology residents. However, when such a clinic is present, the degree of supervision appears to correlate inversely with resident perception of autonomy. These results suggest that the decision of a training program to offer a clinic hosted by residents offering comprehensive continuity care can be informed primarily by faculty and trainee philosophy and personal preferences without comprising education quality, clinical efficiency, residents' perception of stress or their success in fellowship matching.",
keywords = "Autonomy, Burnout, Clinic, Education, Ophthalmology, Outpatient, Professionalism, Resident, Stress, Supervision",
author = "Singman, {Eric L} and Michael Boland and Jing Tian and Green, {Laura K.} and Divya Srikumaran and Barkmeier, {Andrew J.} and Hendershot, {Andrew J.} and Andrew Thliveris and Moore, {Daniel B.} and Darrell Wudunn and Goldman, {David J.} and Waxman, {Evan L.} and Gary Domeracki and Legault, {Gary L.} and Jeff Pettey and Chen, {John J.} and Olson, {Joshua H.} and Jules Winokur and Marcus Colyer and Martin Mayers and Wilkinson, {Michael J.} and Lee, {Michael S.} and Misha Syed and Mitchell Drucker and Weikert, {Mitchell P.} and Parisa Taravati and Peter Veldman and Pratap Challa and Blomquist, {Preston H.} and Siatkowski, {R. Michael} and Robert Granadier and Shane Havens and Culican, {Susan M.} and Uhler, {Tara A.} and Whittaker, {Thomas J.}",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "13",
doi = "10.1186/s12909-019-1620-0",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "19",
journal = "BMC Medical Education",
issn = "1472-6920",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Supervision and autonomy of ophthalmology residents in the outpatient clinic in the United States II

T2 - A survey of senior residents

AU - Singman, Eric L

AU - Boland, Michael

AU - Tian, Jing

AU - Green, Laura K.

AU - Srikumaran, Divya

AU - Barkmeier, Andrew J.

AU - Hendershot, Andrew J.

AU - Thliveris, Andrew

AU - Moore, Daniel B.

AU - Wudunn, Darrell

AU - Goldman, David J.

AU - Waxman, Evan L.

AU - Domeracki, Gary

AU - Legault, Gary L.

AU - Pettey, Jeff

AU - Chen, John J.

AU - Olson, Joshua H.

AU - Winokur, Jules

AU - Colyer, Marcus

AU - Mayers, Martin

AU - Wilkinson, Michael J.

AU - Lee, Michael S.

AU - Syed, Misha

AU - Drucker, Mitchell

AU - Weikert, Mitchell P.

AU - Taravati, Parisa

AU - Veldman, Peter

AU - Challa, Pratap

AU - Blomquist, Preston H.

AU - Siatkowski, R. Michael

AU - Granadier, Robert

AU - Havens, Shane

AU - Culican, Susan M.

AU - Uhler, Tara A.

AU - Whittaker, Thomas J.

PY - 2019/6/13

Y1 - 2019/6/13

N2 - Background: A balance between autonomy and supervision can be difficult to obtain in medical education. In this study, we sought to determine whether the presence and level of supervision of ophthalmology resident outpatient clinic correlates with metrics of resident success, professionalism and stress. Methods: A survey was emailed to all US ophthalmology program directors requesting it be forwarded to PGY4 residents. Questions included whether their program provided a resident-hosted outpatient clinic, and if so, whether residents were mandated to discuss every patient with faculty. Residents were assigned to three categories based on this question (0: no clinic, 1: mandated faculty input, 2: discretionary faculty input). Success metrics included numbers of manuscripts submitted, OKAP scores and success in obtaining fellowships. Professionalism metrics included rating comfort obtaining informed consent, breaking bad news, managing time in clinic, and confidence in providing care in various settings. Residents affirming participation in a continuity clinic also provided perceptions of the level of supervision and how the clinic affected stress. Results: Category 1 residents perceived somewhat too much supervision, while category 2 residents felt that they had somewhat insufficient supervision. The majority of residents in either category did not feel that the continuity clinic affected their overall stress, although those who reported a change in stress usually indicated that the presence of the clinic increased stress. There were no other statistically significant differences between the responses from any category. Conclusions: The presence of a resident-hosted continuity clinic neither adds nor detracts from the success or sense of professionalism of ophthalmology residents. However, when such a clinic is present, the degree of supervision appears to correlate inversely with resident perception of autonomy. These results suggest that the decision of a training program to offer a clinic hosted by residents offering comprehensive continuity care can be informed primarily by faculty and trainee philosophy and personal preferences without comprising education quality, clinical efficiency, residents' perception of stress or their success in fellowship matching.

AB - Background: A balance between autonomy and supervision can be difficult to obtain in medical education. In this study, we sought to determine whether the presence and level of supervision of ophthalmology resident outpatient clinic correlates with metrics of resident success, professionalism and stress. Methods: A survey was emailed to all US ophthalmology program directors requesting it be forwarded to PGY4 residents. Questions included whether their program provided a resident-hosted outpatient clinic, and if so, whether residents were mandated to discuss every patient with faculty. Residents were assigned to three categories based on this question (0: no clinic, 1: mandated faculty input, 2: discretionary faculty input). Success metrics included numbers of manuscripts submitted, OKAP scores and success in obtaining fellowships. Professionalism metrics included rating comfort obtaining informed consent, breaking bad news, managing time in clinic, and confidence in providing care in various settings. Residents affirming participation in a continuity clinic also provided perceptions of the level of supervision and how the clinic affected stress. Results: Category 1 residents perceived somewhat too much supervision, while category 2 residents felt that they had somewhat insufficient supervision. The majority of residents in either category did not feel that the continuity clinic affected their overall stress, although those who reported a change in stress usually indicated that the presence of the clinic increased stress. There were no other statistically significant differences between the responses from any category. Conclusions: The presence of a resident-hosted continuity clinic neither adds nor detracts from the success or sense of professionalism of ophthalmology residents. However, when such a clinic is present, the degree of supervision appears to correlate inversely with resident perception of autonomy. These results suggest that the decision of a training program to offer a clinic hosted by residents offering comprehensive continuity care can be informed primarily by faculty and trainee philosophy and personal preferences without comprising education quality, clinical efficiency, residents' perception of stress or their success in fellowship matching.

KW - Autonomy

KW - Burnout

KW - Clinic

KW - Education

KW - Ophthalmology

KW - Outpatient

KW - Professionalism

KW - Resident

KW - Stress

KW - Supervision

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85067233753&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85067233753&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/s12909-019-1620-0

DO - 10.1186/s12909-019-1620-0

M3 - Review article

C2 - 31196084

AN - SCOPUS:85067233753

VL - 19

JO - BMC Medical Education

JF - BMC Medical Education

SN - 1472-6920

IS - 1

M1 - 202

ER -