Simple Inclusion of Complex Diagnostic Algorithms in Infectious Disease Models for Economic Evaluation

Peter J. Dodd, Jeff J. Pennington, Liza Bronner Murrison, David Wesley Dowdy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Introduction. Cost-effectiveness models for infectious disease interventions often require transmission models that capture the indirect benefits from averted subsequent infections. Compartmental models based on ordinary differential equations are commonly used in this context. Decision trees are frequently used in cost-effectiveness modeling and are well suited to describing diagnostic algorithms. However, complex decision trees are laborious to specify as compartmental models and cumbersome to adapt, limiting the detail of algorithms typically included in transmission models. Methods. We consider an approximation replacing a decision tree with a single holding state for systems where the time scale of the diagnostic algorithm is shorter than time scales associated with disease progression or transmission. We describe recursive algorithms for calculating the outcomes and mean costs and delays associated with decision trees, as well as design strategies for computational implementation. We assess the performance of the approximation in a simple model of transmission/diagnosis and its role in simplifying a model of tuberculosis diagnostics. Results. When diagnostic delays were short relative to recovery rates, our approximation provided a good account of infection dynamics and the cumulative costs of diagnosis and treatment. Proportional errors were below 5% so long as the longest delay in our 2-step algorithm was under 20% of the recovery time scale. Specifying new diagnostic algorithms in our tuberculosis model was reduced from several tens to just a few lines of code. Discussion. For conditions characterized by a diagnostic process that is neither instantaneous nor protracted (relative to transmission dynamics), this novel approach retains the advantages of decision trees while embedding them in more complex models of disease transmission. Concise specification and code reuse increase transparency and reduce potential for error.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)930-941
Number of pages12
JournalMedical Decision Making
Volume38
Issue number8
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2018

Fingerprint

Decision Trees
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Communicable Diseases
Tuberculosis
Infection
Health Care Costs
Disease Progression
Costs and Cost Analysis

Keywords

  • computational techniques
  • cost-effectiveness
  • decision trees
  • diagnostic algorithms
  • infectious diseases
  • transmission models

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Policy

Cite this

Simple Inclusion of Complex Diagnostic Algorithms in Infectious Disease Models for Economic Evaluation. / Dodd, Peter J.; Pennington, Jeff J.; Bronner Murrison, Liza; Dowdy, David Wesley.

In: Medical Decision Making, Vol. 38, No. 8, 01.11.2018, p. 930-941.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dodd, Peter J. ; Pennington, Jeff J. ; Bronner Murrison, Liza ; Dowdy, David Wesley. / Simple Inclusion of Complex Diagnostic Algorithms in Infectious Disease Models for Economic Evaluation. In: Medical Decision Making. 2018 ; Vol. 38, No. 8. pp. 930-941.
@article{583e1ec4e92c4f18a8c1dcd2d5c8fee3,
title = "Simple Inclusion of Complex Diagnostic Algorithms in Infectious Disease Models for Economic Evaluation",
abstract = "Introduction. Cost-effectiveness models for infectious disease interventions often require transmission models that capture the indirect benefits from averted subsequent infections. Compartmental models based on ordinary differential equations are commonly used in this context. Decision trees are frequently used in cost-effectiveness modeling and are well suited to describing diagnostic algorithms. However, complex decision trees are laborious to specify as compartmental models and cumbersome to adapt, limiting the detail of algorithms typically included in transmission models. Methods. We consider an approximation replacing a decision tree with a single holding state for systems where the time scale of the diagnostic algorithm is shorter than time scales associated with disease progression or transmission. We describe recursive algorithms for calculating the outcomes and mean costs and delays associated with decision trees, as well as design strategies for computational implementation. We assess the performance of the approximation in a simple model of transmission/diagnosis and its role in simplifying a model of tuberculosis diagnostics. Results. When diagnostic delays were short relative to recovery rates, our approximation provided a good account of infection dynamics and the cumulative costs of diagnosis and treatment. Proportional errors were below 5{\%} so long as the longest delay in our 2-step algorithm was under 20{\%} of the recovery time scale. Specifying new diagnostic algorithms in our tuberculosis model was reduced from several tens to just a few lines of code. Discussion. For conditions characterized by a diagnostic process that is neither instantaneous nor protracted (relative to transmission dynamics), this novel approach retains the advantages of decision trees while embedding them in more complex models of disease transmission. Concise specification and code reuse increase transparency and reduce potential for error.",
keywords = "computational techniques, cost-effectiveness, decision trees, diagnostic algorithms, infectious diseases, transmission models",
author = "Dodd, {Peter J.} and Pennington, {Jeff J.} and {Bronner Murrison}, Liza and Dowdy, {David Wesley}",
year = "2018",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/0272989X18807438",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "38",
pages = "930--941",
journal = "Medical Decision Making",
issn = "0272-989X",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Simple Inclusion of Complex Diagnostic Algorithms in Infectious Disease Models for Economic Evaluation

AU - Dodd, Peter J.

AU - Pennington, Jeff J.

AU - Bronner Murrison, Liza

AU - Dowdy, David Wesley

PY - 2018/11/1

Y1 - 2018/11/1

N2 - Introduction. Cost-effectiveness models for infectious disease interventions often require transmission models that capture the indirect benefits from averted subsequent infections. Compartmental models based on ordinary differential equations are commonly used in this context. Decision trees are frequently used in cost-effectiveness modeling and are well suited to describing diagnostic algorithms. However, complex decision trees are laborious to specify as compartmental models and cumbersome to adapt, limiting the detail of algorithms typically included in transmission models. Methods. We consider an approximation replacing a decision tree with a single holding state for systems where the time scale of the diagnostic algorithm is shorter than time scales associated with disease progression or transmission. We describe recursive algorithms for calculating the outcomes and mean costs and delays associated with decision trees, as well as design strategies for computational implementation. We assess the performance of the approximation in a simple model of transmission/diagnosis and its role in simplifying a model of tuberculosis diagnostics. Results. When diagnostic delays were short relative to recovery rates, our approximation provided a good account of infection dynamics and the cumulative costs of diagnosis and treatment. Proportional errors were below 5% so long as the longest delay in our 2-step algorithm was under 20% of the recovery time scale. Specifying new diagnostic algorithms in our tuberculosis model was reduced from several tens to just a few lines of code. Discussion. For conditions characterized by a diagnostic process that is neither instantaneous nor protracted (relative to transmission dynamics), this novel approach retains the advantages of decision trees while embedding them in more complex models of disease transmission. Concise specification and code reuse increase transparency and reduce potential for error.

AB - Introduction. Cost-effectiveness models for infectious disease interventions often require transmission models that capture the indirect benefits from averted subsequent infections. Compartmental models based on ordinary differential equations are commonly used in this context. Decision trees are frequently used in cost-effectiveness modeling and are well suited to describing diagnostic algorithms. However, complex decision trees are laborious to specify as compartmental models and cumbersome to adapt, limiting the detail of algorithms typically included in transmission models. Methods. We consider an approximation replacing a decision tree with a single holding state for systems where the time scale of the diagnostic algorithm is shorter than time scales associated with disease progression or transmission. We describe recursive algorithms for calculating the outcomes and mean costs and delays associated with decision trees, as well as design strategies for computational implementation. We assess the performance of the approximation in a simple model of transmission/diagnosis and its role in simplifying a model of tuberculosis diagnostics. Results. When diagnostic delays were short relative to recovery rates, our approximation provided a good account of infection dynamics and the cumulative costs of diagnosis and treatment. Proportional errors were below 5% so long as the longest delay in our 2-step algorithm was under 20% of the recovery time scale. Specifying new diagnostic algorithms in our tuberculosis model was reduced from several tens to just a few lines of code. Discussion. For conditions characterized by a diagnostic process that is neither instantaneous nor protracted (relative to transmission dynamics), this novel approach retains the advantages of decision trees while embedding them in more complex models of disease transmission. Concise specification and code reuse increase transparency and reduce potential for error.

KW - computational techniques

KW - cost-effectiveness

KW - decision trees

KW - diagnostic algorithms

KW - infectious diseases

KW - transmission models

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85056380536&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85056380536&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0272989X18807438

DO - 10.1177/0272989X18807438

M3 - Article

C2 - 30403578

AN - SCOPUS:85056380536

VL - 38

SP - 930

EP - 941

JO - Medical Decision Making

JF - Medical Decision Making

SN - 0272-989X

IS - 8

ER -