Right-left confusion in the adult: A verbal labeling effect

Directional judgments are typically slower when relative location is described by the words "east" and "west" or "right" and "left" than when described by the words "north" and "south" or "up" and "down." A series of experiments are reported that disentangle verbal from perceptual encoding explanations for right-left difficulty. Overall, our results support a verbal encoding explanation for right-left confusion in the adult. Experiments 1-3 demonstrate that in a response-differentiation task, it is response to the labels "north," "east," "south," and "west" that is responsible for right-left confusion. In addition, Experiments 4-6 demonstrate that right-left difficulty in a mirror image discrimination task is contingent on the use of directional labels. (The data also suggest that it may be more difficult to deal with "up," "down," "left," and "right" than with "north," "south," "east," and "west") The data are interpreted as inconsistent with a bilateral symmetry explanation for right-left confusion.