Reproducibility and optimization of in vivo human diffusion-weighted MRS of the corpus callosum at 3T and 7T

Emily T. Wood, Ayse Ece Ercan, Francesca Branzoli, Andrew Webb, Pascal Sati, Daniel S. Reich, Itamar Ronen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Diffusion-weighted MRS (DWS) of brain metabolites enables the study of cell-specific alterations in tissue microstructure by probing the diffusion of intracellular metabolites. In particular, the diffusion properties of neuronal N-acetylaspartate (NAA), typically co-measured with N-acetylaspartyl glutamate (NAAG) (NAA+NAAG=tNAA), have been shown to be sensitive to intraneuronal/axonal damage in pathologies such as stroke and multiple sclerosis. Lacking, so far, are empirical assessments of the reproducibility of DWS measures across time and subjects, as well as a systematic investigation of the optimal acquisition parameters for DWS experiments, both of which are sorely needed for clinical applications of the method. In this study, we acquired comprehensive single-volume DWS datasets of the human corpus callosum at 3T and 7T. We investigated the inter- and intra-subject variability of empirical and modeled diffusion properties of tNAA [Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA), respectively]. Subsequently, we used a jackknife-like resampling approach to explore the variance of these properties in partial data subsets reflecting different total scan durations. The coefficients of variation (CV) and repeatability coefficients (CR) for Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA) were calculated for both 3T and 7T, with overall lower variability in the 7T results. Although this work is limited to the estimation of the diffusion properties in the corpus callosum, we show that a careful choice of diffusion-weighting conditions at both field strengths allows the accurate measurement of tNAA diffusion properties in clinically relevant experimental time. Based on the resampling results, we suggest optimized acquisition schemes of 13-min duration at 3T and 10-min duration at 7T, whilst retaining low variability (CV≈8%) for the tNAA diffusion measures. Power calculations for the estimation of Dmodel(tNAA) and Davg(tNAA) based on the suggested schemes show that less than 21 subjects per group are sufficient for the detection of a 10% effect between two groups in case-control studies.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)976-987
Number of pages12
JournalNMR in Biomedicine
Volume28
Issue number8
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 1 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Corpus Callosum
Metabolites
Glutamic Acid
Pathology
Multiple Sclerosis
Case-Control Studies
Brain
Stroke
Tissue

Keywords

  • Diffusion-weighted MRS
  • Inter-subject variability
  • Intra-subject variability
  • Power calculations
  • White matter

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Spectroscopy
  • Molecular Medicine
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Wood, E. T., Ercan, A. E., Branzoli, F., Webb, A., Sati, P., Reich, D. S., & Ronen, I. (2015). Reproducibility and optimization of in vivo human diffusion-weighted MRS of the corpus callosum at 3T and 7T. NMR in Biomedicine, 28(8), 976-987. https://doi.org/10.1002/nbm.3340

Reproducibility and optimization of in vivo human diffusion-weighted MRS of the corpus callosum at 3T and 7T. / Wood, Emily T.; Ercan, Ayse Ece; Branzoli, Francesca; Webb, Andrew; Sati, Pascal; Reich, Daniel S.; Ronen, Itamar.

In: NMR in Biomedicine, Vol. 28, No. 8, 01.08.2015, p. 976-987.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Wood, ET, Ercan, AE, Branzoli, F, Webb, A, Sati, P, Reich, DS & Ronen, I 2015, 'Reproducibility and optimization of in vivo human diffusion-weighted MRS of the corpus callosum at 3T and 7T', NMR in Biomedicine, vol. 28, no. 8, pp. 976-987. https://doi.org/10.1002/nbm.3340
Wood, Emily T. ; Ercan, Ayse Ece ; Branzoli, Francesca ; Webb, Andrew ; Sati, Pascal ; Reich, Daniel S. ; Ronen, Itamar. / Reproducibility and optimization of in vivo human diffusion-weighted MRS of the corpus callosum at 3T and 7T. In: NMR in Biomedicine. 2015 ; Vol. 28, No. 8. pp. 976-987.
@article{fa9246c116684f789940a6cfe9df1f83,
title = "Reproducibility and optimization of in vivo human diffusion-weighted MRS of the corpus callosum at 3T and 7T",
abstract = "Diffusion-weighted MRS (DWS) of brain metabolites enables the study of cell-specific alterations in tissue microstructure by probing the diffusion of intracellular metabolites. In particular, the diffusion properties of neuronal N-acetylaspartate (NAA), typically co-measured with N-acetylaspartyl glutamate (NAAG) (NAA+NAAG=tNAA), have been shown to be sensitive to intraneuronal/axonal damage in pathologies such as stroke and multiple sclerosis. Lacking, so far, are empirical assessments of the reproducibility of DWS measures across time and subjects, as well as a systematic investigation of the optimal acquisition parameters for DWS experiments, both of which are sorely needed for clinical applications of the method. In this study, we acquired comprehensive single-volume DWS datasets of the human corpus callosum at 3T and 7T. We investigated the inter- and intra-subject variability of empirical and modeled diffusion properties of tNAA [Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA), respectively]. Subsequently, we used a jackknife-like resampling approach to explore the variance of these properties in partial data subsets reflecting different total scan durations. The coefficients of variation (CV) and repeatability coefficients (CR) for Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA) were calculated for both 3T and 7T, with overall lower variability in the 7T results. Although this work is limited to the estimation of the diffusion properties in the corpus callosum, we show that a careful choice of diffusion-weighting conditions at both field strengths allows the accurate measurement of tNAA diffusion properties in clinically relevant experimental time. Based on the resampling results, we suggest optimized acquisition schemes of 13-min duration at 3T and 10-min duration at 7T, whilst retaining low variability (CV≈8{\%}) for the tNAA diffusion measures. Power calculations for the estimation of Dmodel(tNAA) and Davg(tNAA) based on the suggested schemes show that less than 21 subjects per group are sufficient for the detection of a 10{\%} effect between two groups in case-control studies.",
keywords = "Diffusion-weighted MRS, Inter-subject variability, Intra-subject variability, Power calculations, White matter",
author = "Wood, {Emily T.} and Ercan, {Ayse Ece} and Francesca Branzoli and Andrew Webb and Pascal Sati and Reich, {Daniel S.} and Itamar Ronen",
year = "2015",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/nbm.3340",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "28",
pages = "976--987",
journal = "NMR in Biomedicine",
issn = "0952-3480",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reproducibility and optimization of in vivo human diffusion-weighted MRS of the corpus callosum at 3T and 7T

AU - Wood, Emily T.

AU - Ercan, Ayse Ece

AU - Branzoli, Francesca

AU - Webb, Andrew

AU - Sati, Pascal

AU - Reich, Daniel S.

AU - Ronen, Itamar

PY - 2015/8/1

Y1 - 2015/8/1

N2 - Diffusion-weighted MRS (DWS) of brain metabolites enables the study of cell-specific alterations in tissue microstructure by probing the diffusion of intracellular metabolites. In particular, the diffusion properties of neuronal N-acetylaspartate (NAA), typically co-measured with N-acetylaspartyl glutamate (NAAG) (NAA+NAAG=tNAA), have been shown to be sensitive to intraneuronal/axonal damage in pathologies such as stroke and multiple sclerosis. Lacking, so far, are empirical assessments of the reproducibility of DWS measures across time and subjects, as well as a systematic investigation of the optimal acquisition parameters for DWS experiments, both of which are sorely needed for clinical applications of the method. In this study, we acquired comprehensive single-volume DWS datasets of the human corpus callosum at 3T and 7T. We investigated the inter- and intra-subject variability of empirical and modeled diffusion properties of tNAA [Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA), respectively]. Subsequently, we used a jackknife-like resampling approach to explore the variance of these properties in partial data subsets reflecting different total scan durations. The coefficients of variation (CV) and repeatability coefficients (CR) for Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA) were calculated for both 3T and 7T, with overall lower variability in the 7T results. Although this work is limited to the estimation of the diffusion properties in the corpus callosum, we show that a careful choice of diffusion-weighting conditions at both field strengths allows the accurate measurement of tNAA diffusion properties in clinically relevant experimental time. Based on the resampling results, we suggest optimized acquisition schemes of 13-min duration at 3T and 10-min duration at 7T, whilst retaining low variability (CV≈8%) for the tNAA diffusion measures. Power calculations for the estimation of Dmodel(tNAA) and Davg(tNAA) based on the suggested schemes show that less than 21 subjects per group are sufficient for the detection of a 10% effect between two groups in case-control studies.

AB - Diffusion-weighted MRS (DWS) of brain metabolites enables the study of cell-specific alterations in tissue microstructure by probing the diffusion of intracellular metabolites. In particular, the diffusion properties of neuronal N-acetylaspartate (NAA), typically co-measured with N-acetylaspartyl glutamate (NAAG) (NAA+NAAG=tNAA), have been shown to be sensitive to intraneuronal/axonal damage in pathologies such as stroke and multiple sclerosis. Lacking, so far, are empirical assessments of the reproducibility of DWS measures across time and subjects, as well as a systematic investigation of the optimal acquisition parameters for DWS experiments, both of which are sorely needed for clinical applications of the method. In this study, we acquired comprehensive single-volume DWS datasets of the human corpus callosum at 3T and 7T. We investigated the inter- and intra-subject variability of empirical and modeled diffusion properties of tNAA [Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA), respectively]. Subsequently, we used a jackknife-like resampling approach to explore the variance of these properties in partial data subsets reflecting different total scan durations. The coefficients of variation (CV) and repeatability coefficients (CR) for Davg(tNAA) and Dmodel(tNAA) were calculated for both 3T and 7T, with overall lower variability in the 7T results. Although this work is limited to the estimation of the diffusion properties in the corpus callosum, we show that a careful choice of diffusion-weighting conditions at both field strengths allows the accurate measurement of tNAA diffusion properties in clinically relevant experimental time. Based on the resampling results, we suggest optimized acquisition schemes of 13-min duration at 3T and 10-min duration at 7T, whilst retaining low variability (CV≈8%) for the tNAA diffusion measures. Power calculations for the estimation of Dmodel(tNAA) and Davg(tNAA) based on the suggested schemes show that less than 21 subjects per group are sufficient for the detection of a 10% effect between two groups in case-control studies.

KW - Diffusion-weighted MRS

KW - Inter-subject variability

KW - Intra-subject variability

KW - Power calculations

KW - White matter

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84937251053&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84937251053&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/nbm.3340

DO - 10.1002/nbm.3340

M3 - Article

C2 - 26084563

AN - SCOPUS:84937251053

VL - 28

SP - 976

EP - 987

JO - NMR in Biomedicine

JF - NMR in Biomedicine

SN - 0952-3480

IS - 8

ER -