Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future

Paul H. Desan, Paula C. Zimbrean, Hochang B. Lee, William H. Sledge

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Psychiatric consultation services in general medical hospitals typically operate on a consultation-as-requested basis: medical teams determine that a patient requires a consultation, place an order for a consultation, and the patient is then seen by a psychiatrist for a standard consultation. This system may fail to detect patients who could benefit from consultation or may detect such patients after a delay, and conversely may generate consult requests for patients who will not benefit from inpatient consultation. We argue that psychiatric consultation services must become proactive, organized to seek out cases that require and will benefit from consultation, and to provide the services actually needed in each case. We argue that such services can improve health care and decrease length of stay (LOS). LOS has been widely studied as an indicator of the timely delivery of appropriate care. Studies used many different models and research designs. We analyze the characteristics of the few studies that had a significant effect on LOS. There are ten studies of increased psychiatric consultation, with four showing a significant improvement in LOS. Twelve studies have analyzed the effects of increased geriatric consultation, with three showing significant improvement in LOS. Three studies have focused on delirium in geriatric patients without showing LOS benefit, but one study in geriatric trauma patients did demonstrate a notable trend towards LOS improvement. Eight studies have investigated increased geriatric consultation for elderly patients with hip fracture, two with statistically significant benefit, and an additional four with trend towards improvement. Additionally, we note that three studies on clinical pathways including comprehensive geriatric consultation all show clear evidence of LOS benefit, as do six studies with dedicated ortho-geriatric unit care. Finally, we describe two models of proactive psychiatric consultation implemented in our hospital that have demonstrated reductions in LOS. Successful studies do share certain elements in common: screening for and selection of appropriate target population who can benefit, focus on improving LOS, and close integration of consult care into medical team operation. We argue that the data thus far show that simply doing more consultations is not efficient, but that appropriately targeted and integrated care does provide timely services and reduce LOS. We conclude with suggestions about the design of successful proactive psychiatric consultation services, and with suggestions about appropriate research designs for further work in the field.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationIntegrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting
PublisherSpringer New York
Pages157-181
Number of pages25
ISBN (Print)9781493906888, 1493906879, 9781493906871
DOIs
StatePublished - May 1 2014
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

General Hospitals
Psychiatry
Referral and Consultation
Length of Stay
Geriatrics
Research Design
Naphazoline
Patient Care Team
Critical Pathways
Delirium
Health Services Needs and Demand
Hip Fractures
Inpatients

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Desan, P. H., Zimbrean, P. C., Lee, H. B., & Sledge, W. H. (2014). Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future. In Integrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting (pp. 157-181). Springer New York. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-0688-8_10

Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future. / Desan, Paul H.; Zimbrean, Paula C.; Lee, Hochang B.; Sledge, William H.

Integrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting. Springer New York, 2014. p. 157-181.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Desan, PH, Zimbrean, PC, Lee, HB & Sledge, WH 2014, Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future. in Integrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting. Springer New York, pp. 157-181. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-0688-8_10
Desan PH, Zimbrean PC, Lee HB, Sledge WH. Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future. In Integrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting. Springer New York. 2014. p. 157-181 https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-0688-8_10
Desan, Paul H. ; Zimbrean, Paula C. ; Lee, Hochang B. ; Sledge, William H. / Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future. Integrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting. Springer New York, 2014. pp. 157-181
@inbook{6af7107daa7a41e79572e3276c376798,
title = "Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future",
abstract = "Psychiatric consultation services in general medical hospitals typically operate on a consultation-as-requested basis: medical teams determine that a patient requires a consultation, place an order for a consultation, and the patient is then seen by a psychiatrist for a standard consultation. This system may fail to detect patients who could benefit from consultation or may detect such patients after a delay, and conversely may generate consult requests for patients who will not benefit from inpatient consultation. We argue that psychiatric consultation services must become proactive, organized to seek out cases that require and will benefit from consultation, and to provide the services actually needed in each case. We argue that such services can improve health care and decrease length of stay (LOS). LOS has been widely studied as an indicator of the timely delivery of appropriate care. Studies used many different models and research designs. We analyze the characteristics of the few studies that had a significant effect on LOS. There are ten studies of increased psychiatric consultation, with four showing a significant improvement in LOS. Twelve studies have analyzed the effects of increased geriatric consultation, with three showing significant improvement in LOS. Three studies have focused on delirium in geriatric patients without showing LOS benefit, but one study in geriatric trauma patients did demonstrate a notable trend towards LOS improvement. Eight studies have investigated increased geriatric consultation for elderly patients with hip fracture, two with statistically significant benefit, and an additional four with trend towards improvement. Additionally, we note that three studies on clinical pathways including comprehensive geriatric consultation all show clear evidence of LOS benefit, as do six studies with dedicated ortho-geriatric unit care. Finally, we describe two models of proactive psychiatric consultation implemented in our hospital that have demonstrated reductions in LOS. Successful studies do share certain elements in common: screening for and selection of appropriate target population who can benefit, focus on improving LOS, and close integration of consult care into medical team operation. We argue that the data thus far show that simply doing more consultations is not efficient, but that appropriately targeted and integrated care does provide timely services and reduce LOS. We conclude with suggestions about the design of successful proactive psychiatric consultation services, and with suggestions about appropriate research designs for further work in the field.",
author = "Desan, {Paul H.} and Zimbrean, {Paula C.} and Lee, {Hochang B.} and Sledge, {William H.}",
year = "2014",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/978-1-4939-0688-8_10",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9781493906888",
pages = "157--181",
booktitle = "Integrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting",
publisher = "Springer New York",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Proactive psychiatric consultation services for the general hospital of the future

AU - Desan, Paul H.

AU - Zimbrean, Paula C.

AU - Lee, Hochang B.

AU - Sledge, William H.

PY - 2014/5/1

Y1 - 2014/5/1

N2 - Psychiatric consultation services in general medical hospitals typically operate on a consultation-as-requested basis: medical teams determine that a patient requires a consultation, place an order for a consultation, and the patient is then seen by a psychiatrist for a standard consultation. This system may fail to detect patients who could benefit from consultation or may detect such patients after a delay, and conversely may generate consult requests for patients who will not benefit from inpatient consultation. We argue that psychiatric consultation services must become proactive, organized to seek out cases that require and will benefit from consultation, and to provide the services actually needed in each case. We argue that such services can improve health care and decrease length of stay (LOS). LOS has been widely studied as an indicator of the timely delivery of appropriate care. Studies used many different models and research designs. We analyze the characteristics of the few studies that had a significant effect on LOS. There are ten studies of increased psychiatric consultation, with four showing a significant improvement in LOS. Twelve studies have analyzed the effects of increased geriatric consultation, with three showing significant improvement in LOS. Three studies have focused on delirium in geriatric patients without showing LOS benefit, but one study in geriatric trauma patients did demonstrate a notable trend towards LOS improvement. Eight studies have investigated increased geriatric consultation for elderly patients with hip fracture, two with statistically significant benefit, and an additional four with trend towards improvement. Additionally, we note that three studies on clinical pathways including comprehensive geriatric consultation all show clear evidence of LOS benefit, as do six studies with dedicated ortho-geriatric unit care. Finally, we describe two models of proactive psychiatric consultation implemented in our hospital that have demonstrated reductions in LOS. Successful studies do share certain elements in common: screening for and selection of appropriate target population who can benefit, focus on improving LOS, and close integration of consult care into medical team operation. We argue that the data thus far show that simply doing more consultations is not efficient, but that appropriately targeted and integrated care does provide timely services and reduce LOS. We conclude with suggestions about the design of successful proactive psychiatric consultation services, and with suggestions about appropriate research designs for further work in the field.

AB - Psychiatric consultation services in general medical hospitals typically operate on a consultation-as-requested basis: medical teams determine that a patient requires a consultation, place an order for a consultation, and the patient is then seen by a psychiatrist for a standard consultation. This system may fail to detect patients who could benefit from consultation or may detect such patients after a delay, and conversely may generate consult requests for patients who will not benefit from inpatient consultation. We argue that psychiatric consultation services must become proactive, organized to seek out cases that require and will benefit from consultation, and to provide the services actually needed in each case. We argue that such services can improve health care and decrease length of stay (LOS). LOS has been widely studied as an indicator of the timely delivery of appropriate care. Studies used many different models and research designs. We analyze the characteristics of the few studies that had a significant effect on LOS. There are ten studies of increased psychiatric consultation, with four showing a significant improvement in LOS. Twelve studies have analyzed the effects of increased geriatric consultation, with three showing significant improvement in LOS. Three studies have focused on delirium in geriatric patients without showing LOS benefit, but one study in geriatric trauma patients did demonstrate a notable trend towards LOS improvement. Eight studies have investigated increased geriatric consultation for elderly patients with hip fracture, two with statistically significant benefit, and an additional four with trend towards improvement. Additionally, we note that three studies on clinical pathways including comprehensive geriatric consultation all show clear evidence of LOS benefit, as do six studies with dedicated ortho-geriatric unit care. Finally, we describe two models of proactive psychiatric consultation implemented in our hospital that have demonstrated reductions in LOS. Successful studies do share certain elements in common: screening for and selection of appropriate target population who can benefit, focus on improving LOS, and close integration of consult care into medical team operation. We argue that the data thus far show that simply doing more consultations is not efficient, but that appropriately targeted and integrated care does provide timely services and reduce LOS. We conclude with suggestions about the design of successful proactive psychiatric consultation services, and with suggestions about appropriate research designs for further work in the field.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84929901005&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84929901005&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/978-1-4939-0688-8_10

DO - 10.1007/978-1-4939-0688-8_10

M3 - Chapter

AN - SCOPUS:84929901005

SN - 9781493906888

SN - 1493906879

SN - 9781493906871

SP - 157

EP - 181

BT - Integrated Care in Psychiatry: Redefining the Role of Mental Health Professionals in the Medical Setting

PB - Springer New York

ER -