Opportunities and challenges in conducting systematic reviews to support the development of nutrient reference values: Vitamin A as an example

Robert Russell, Mei Chung, Ethan M. Balk, Stephanie Atkinson, Edward L. Giovannucci, Stanley Ip, Alice H. Lichtenstein, Susan Taylor Mayne, Gowri Raman, A. Catharine Ross, Thomas A. Trikalinos, Keith West, Joseph Lau

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Nutrient reference values have significant public health and policy implications. Given the importance of defining reliable nutrient reference values, there is a need for an explicit, objective, and transparent process to set these values. The Tufts Medical Center Evidence-based Practice Center assembled a group of nutrition experts from academic institutions and federal government agencies, led participants in discussions, conducted exercises in formulating questions and evidence review criteria that would be amenable to systematic reviews of the scientific literature, performed a literature search on the questions to identify potentially relevant publications, and identified challenges and limitations of applying this method to support the development of nutrient reference values using vitamin A as an example. The workgroup concluded that the systematic review approach could be productively used to inform the development of reference values. Challenges identified in this exercise include prioritizing and defining research questions when the volume of literature is large, relying on intermediate (surrogate) outcomes when few or no studies directly linking nutrient intake with clinical outcomes are available, and determining reliable nutrient biomarkers. Ultimately, an objective, unbiased systematic review of a defined question could be useful, not only in helping to set nutrient reference values, but also for increasing the transparency of the decision making process.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)728-733
Number of pages6
JournalAmerican Journal of Clinical Nutrition
Volume89
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2009

Fingerprint

Vitamin A
Reference Values
Food
Government Agencies
Federal Government
Evidence-Based Practice
Public Policy
Health Policy
Publications
Decision Making
Public Health
Biomarkers
Research

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine (miscellaneous)
  • Nutrition and Dietetics

Cite this

Opportunities and challenges in conducting systematic reviews to support the development of nutrient reference values : Vitamin A as an example. / Russell, Robert; Chung, Mei; Balk, Ethan M.; Atkinson, Stephanie; Giovannucci, Edward L.; Ip, Stanley; Lichtenstein, Alice H.; Mayne, Susan Taylor; Raman, Gowri; Catharine Ross, A.; Trikalinos, Thomas A.; West, Keith; Lau, Joseph.

In: American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Vol. 89, No. 3, 01.03.2009, p. 728-733.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Russell, R, Chung, M, Balk, EM, Atkinson, S, Giovannucci, EL, Ip, S, Lichtenstein, AH, Mayne, ST, Raman, G, Catharine Ross, A, Trikalinos, TA, West, K & Lau, J 2009, 'Opportunities and challenges in conducting systematic reviews to support the development of nutrient reference values: Vitamin A as an example', American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, vol. 89, no. 3, pp. 728-733. https://doi.org/10.3945/ajcn.2008.27154
Russell, Robert ; Chung, Mei ; Balk, Ethan M. ; Atkinson, Stephanie ; Giovannucci, Edward L. ; Ip, Stanley ; Lichtenstein, Alice H. ; Mayne, Susan Taylor ; Raman, Gowri ; Catharine Ross, A. ; Trikalinos, Thomas A. ; West, Keith ; Lau, Joseph. / Opportunities and challenges in conducting systematic reviews to support the development of nutrient reference values : Vitamin A as an example. In: American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2009 ; Vol. 89, No. 3. pp. 728-733.
@article{5928590638644efab99b4334e372d4e2,
title = "Opportunities and challenges in conducting systematic reviews to support the development of nutrient reference values: Vitamin A as an example",
abstract = "Nutrient reference values have significant public health and policy implications. Given the importance of defining reliable nutrient reference values, there is a need for an explicit, objective, and transparent process to set these values. The Tufts Medical Center Evidence-based Practice Center assembled a group of nutrition experts from academic institutions and federal government agencies, led participants in discussions, conducted exercises in formulating questions and evidence review criteria that would be amenable to systematic reviews of the scientific literature, performed a literature search on the questions to identify potentially relevant publications, and identified challenges and limitations of applying this method to support the development of nutrient reference values using vitamin A as an example. The workgroup concluded that the systematic review approach could be productively used to inform the development of reference values. Challenges identified in this exercise include prioritizing and defining research questions when the volume of literature is large, relying on intermediate (surrogate) outcomes when few or no studies directly linking nutrient intake with clinical outcomes are available, and determining reliable nutrient biomarkers. Ultimately, an objective, unbiased systematic review of a defined question could be useful, not only in helping to set nutrient reference values, but also for increasing the transparency of the decision making process.",
author = "Robert Russell and Mei Chung and Balk, {Ethan M.} and Stephanie Atkinson and Giovannucci, {Edward L.} and Stanley Ip and Lichtenstein, {Alice H.} and Mayne, {Susan Taylor} and Gowri Raman and {Catharine Ross}, A. and Trikalinos, {Thomas A.} and Keith West and Joseph Lau",
year = "2009",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3945/ajcn.2008.27154",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "89",
pages = "728--733",
journal = "American Journal of Clinical Nutrition",
issn = "0002-9165",
publisher = "American Society for Nutrition",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Opportunities and challenges in conducting systematic reviews to support the development of nutrient reference values

T2 - Vitamin A as an example

AU - Russell, Robert

AU - Chung, Mei

AU - Balk, Ethan M.

AU - Atkinson, Stephanie

AU - Giovannucci, Edward L.

AU - Ip, Stanley

AU - Lichtenstein, Alice H.

AU - Mayne, Susan Taylor

AU - Raman, Gowri

AU - Catharine Ross, A.

AU - Trikalinos, Thomas A.

AU - West, Keith

AU - Lau, Joseph

PY - 2009/3/1

Y1 - 2009/3/1

N2 - Nutrient reference values have significant public health and policy implications. Given the importance of defining reliable nutrient reference values, there is a need for an explicit, objective, and transparent process to set these values. The Tufts Medical Center Evidence-based Practice Center assembled a group of nutrition experts from academic institutions and federal government agencies, led participants in discussions, conducted exercises in formulating questions and evidence review criteria that would be amenable to systematic reviews of the scientific literature, performed a literature search on the questions to identify potentially relevant publications, and identified challenges and limitations of applying this method to support the development of nutrient reference values using vitamin A as an example. The workgroup concluded that the systematic review approach could be productively used to inform the development of reference values. Challenges identified in this exercise include prioritizing and defining research questions when the volume of literature is large, relying on intermediate (surrogate) outcomes when few or no studies directly linking nutrient intake with clinical outcomes are available, and determining reliable nutrient biomarkers. Ultimately, an objective, unbiased systematic review of a defined question could be useful, not only in helping to set nutrient reference values, but also for increasing the transparency of the decision making process.

AB - Nutrient reference values have significant public health and policy implications. Given the importance of defining reliable nutrient reference values, there is a need for an explicit, objective, and transparent process to set these values. The Tufts Medical Center Evidence-based Practice Center assembled a group of nutrition experts from academic institutions and federal government agencies, led participants in discussions, conducted exercises in formulating questions and evidence review criteria that would be amenable to systematic reviews of the scientific literature, performed a literature search on the questions to identify potentially relevant publications, and identified challenges and limitations of applying this method to support the development of nutrient reference values using vitamin A as an example. The workgroup concluded that the systematic review approach could be productively used to inform the development of reference values. Challenges identified in this exercise include prioritizing and defining research questions when the volume of literature is large, relying on intermediate (surrogate) outcomes when few or no studies directly linking nutrient intake with clinical outcomes are available, and determining reliable nutrient biomarkers. Ultimately, an objective, unbiased systematic review of a defined question could be useful, not only in helping to set nutrient reference values, but also for increasing the transparency of the decision making process.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=61449121062&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=61449121062&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3945/ajcn.2008.27154

DO - 10.3945/ajcn.2008.27154

M3 - Article

C2 - 19176732

AN - SCOPUS:61449121062

VL - 89

SP - 728

EP - 733

JO - American Journal of Clinical Nutrition

JF - American Journal of Clinical Nutrition

SN - 0002-9165

IS - 3

ER -