On optimal screening ages

Giovanni Parmigiani

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Several chronic diseases are characterized by an initial asymptomatic stage during which, if detected by screening, they can be cured in a more effective way. This article considers two statistical design problems in screening for chronic disease: the choice of examination ages and the choice of the part of the population to be screened. One main goal is capturing the trade-off between the costs of examination and the losses due to late detection, while accounting for the effects of age on the incidence of the disease, on mortality, and on the relative advantages of early detection. The problem is posed in a decision theoretic way. The model adopted considers a single individual, whose history relative to the disease is represented by a discrete-valued stochastic process. The transition structure is general, but known. The decision space includes all sequences of examination times, as well as no examination. The optimality criterion accounts for the cost of examinations and, in a general way, for the goals of screening in terms of mortality and morbidity. So the optimality criterion may depend on survival, quality-adjusted life years, cost of care, and so on, as well as on combinations of these factors. A general solution and computational algorithms are derived by extending to this context methodologies developed in reliability theory. The case in which the test used for screening has high sensitivity is studied in detail; then the determination of the optimal schedule and stopping rule is reduced to a one-dimensional optimization problem by recursive dynamic methods. Moreover, sufficient conditions for screening to be increasingly worthwhile with age are derived. Under these conditions, the optimal number of planned examinations is either 0 or infinity, and there is a simple check to establish whether or not to screen without having to compute the optimal schedule. Under slightly stronger conditions, the times between examinations decrease and the optimal solution is unique and easy to compute. The conditions mentioned relate increasing times between checks to properties of the failure rate of the time to onset of the disease and of the relative incidence of the disease. Applications of the results include developing guidelines for screening for breast and cervical cancers—currently a controversial issue.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)622-628
Number of pages7
JournalJournal of the American Statistical Association
Volume88
Issue number422
DOIs
StatePublished - 1993
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Screening
Chronic Disease
Optimality Criteria
Mortality
Incidence
Schedule
Costs
Reliability Theory
Morbidity
Stopping Rule
Computational Algorithm
Failure Rate
General Solution
Stochastic Processes
Optimal Solution
Trade-offs
Infinity
Optimization Problem
Decrease
Methodology

Keywords

  • Chronic disease
  • Design
  • Inspections policy
  • Medical decision-making
  • Public health
  • Scheduling

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Statistics and Probability
  • Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty

Cite this

On optimal screening ages. / Parmigiani, Giovanni.

In: Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol. 88, No. 422, 1993, p. 622-628.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Parmigiani, Giovanni. / On optimal screening ages. In: Journal of the American Statistical Association. 1993 ; Vol. 88, No. 422. pp. 622-628.
@article{d1f71ceef1b84af3a2ab527ad221d420,
title = "On optimal screening ages",
abstract = "Several chronic diseases are characterized by an initial asymptomatic stage during which, if detected by screening, they can be cured in a more effective way. This article considers two statistical design problems in screening for chronic disease: the choice of examination ages and the choice of the part of the population to be screened. One main goal is capturing the trade-off between the costs of examination and the losses due to late detection, while accounting for the effects of age on the incidence of the disease, on mortality, and on the relative advantages of early detection. The problem is posed in a decision theoretic way. The model adopted considers a single individual, whose history relative to the disease is represented by a discrete-valued stochastic process. The transition structure is general, but known. The decision space includes all sequences of examination times, as well as no examination. The optimality criterion accounts for the cost of examinations and, in a general way, for the goals of screening in terms of mortality and morbidity. So the optimality criterion may depend on survival, quality-adjusted life years, cost of care, and so on, as well as on combinations of these factors. A general solution and computational algorithms are derived by extending to this context methodologies developed in reliability theory. The case in which the test used for screening has high sensitivity is studied in detail; then the determination of the optimal schedule and stopping rule is reduced to a one-dimensional optimization problem by recursive dynamic methods. Moreover, sufficient conditions for screening to be increasingly worthwhile with age are derived. Under these conditions, the optimal number of planned examinations is either 0 or infinity, and there is a simple check to establish whether or not to screen without having to compute the optimal schedule. Under slightly stronger conditions, the times between examinations decrease and the optimal solution is unique and easy to compute. The conditions mentioned relate increasing times between checks to properties of the failure rate of the time to onset of the disease and of the relative incidence of the disease. Applications of the results include developing guidelines for screening for breast and cervical cancers—currently a controversial issue.",
keywords = "Chronic disease, Design, Inspections policy, Medical decision-making, Public health, Scheduling",
author = "Giovanni Parmigiani",
year = "1993",
doi = "10.1080/01621459.1993.10476315",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "88",
pages = "622--628",
journal = "Journal of the American Statistical Association",
issn = "0162-1459",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
number = "422",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - On optimal screening ages

AU - Parmigiani, Giovanni

PY - 1993

Y1 - 1993

N2 - Several chronic diseases are characterized by an initial asymptomatic stage during which, if detected by screening, they can be cured in a more effective way. This article considers two statistical design problems in screening for chronic disease: the choice of examination ages and the choice of the part of the population to be screened. One main goal is capturing the trade-off between the costs of examination and the losses due to late detection, while accounting for the effects of age on the incidence of the disease, on mortality, and on the relative advantages of early detection. The problem is posed in a decision theoretic way. The model adopted considers a single individual, whose history relative to the disease is represented by a discrete-valued stochastic process. The transition structure is general, but known. The decision space includes all sequences of examination times, as well as no examination. The optimality criterion accounts for the cost of examinations and, in a general way, for the goals of screening in terms of mortality and morbidity. So the optimality criterion may depend on survival, quality-adjusted life years, cost of care, and so on, as well as on combinations of these factors. A general solution and computational algorithms are derived by extending to this context methodologies developed in reliability theory. The case in which the test used for screening has high sensitivity is studied in detail; then the determination of the optimal schedule and stopping rule is reduced to a one-dimensional optimization problem by recursive dynamic methods. Moreover, sufficient conditions for screening to be increasingly worthwhile with age are derived. Under these conditions, the optimal number of planned examinations is either 0 or infinity, and there is a simple check to establish whether or not to screen without having to compute the optimal schedule. Under slightly stronger conditions, the times between examinations decrease and the optimal solution is unique and easy to compute. The conditions mentioned relate increasing times between checks to properties of the failure rate of the time to onset of the disease and of the relative incidence of the disease. Applications of the results include developing guidelines for screening for breast and cervical cancers—currently a controversial issue.

AB - Several chronic diseases are characterized by an initial asymptomatic stage during which, if detected by screening, they can be cured in a more effective way. This article considers two statistical design problems in screening for chronic disease: the choice of examination ages and the choice of the part of the population to be screened. One main goal is capturing the trade-off between the costs of examination and the losses due to late detection, while accounting for the effects of age on the incidence of the disease, on mortality, and on the relative advantages of early detection. The problem is posed in a decision theoretic way. The model adopted considers a single individual, whose history relative to the disease is represented by a discrete-valued stochastic process. The transition structure is general, but known. The decision space includes all sequences of examination times, as well as no examination. The optimality criterion accounts for the cost of examinations and, in a general way, for the goals of screening in terms of mortality and morbidity. So the optimality criterion may depend on survival, quality-adjusted life years, cost of care, and so on, as well as on combinations of these factors. A general solution and computational algorithms are derived by extending to this context methodologies developed in reliability theory. The case in which the test used for screening has high sensitivity is studied in detail; then the determination of the optimal schedule and stopping rule is reduced to a one-dimensional optimization problem by recursive dynamic methods. Moreover, sufficient conditions for screening to be increasingly worthwhile with age are derived. Under these conditions, the optimal number of planned examinations is either 0 or infinity, and there is a simple check to establish whether or not to screen without having to compute the optimal schedule. Under slightly stronger conditions, the times between examinations decrease and the optimal solution is unique and easy to compute. The conditions mentioned relate increasing times between checks to properties of the failure rate of the time to onset of the disease and of the relative incidence of the disease. Applications of the results include developing guidelines for screening for breast and cervical cancers—currently a controversial issue.

KW - Chronic disease

KW - Design

KW - Inspections policy

KW - Medical decision-making

KW - Public health

KW - Scheduling

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=21144479180&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=21144479180&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/01621459.1993.10476315

DO - 10.1080/01621459.1993.10476315

M3 - Article

VL - 88

SP - 622

EP - 628

JO - Journal of the American Statistical Association

JF - Journal of the American Statistical Association

SN - 0162-1459

IS - 422

ER -