Mobile C-Arm with a CMOS detector

Technical assessment of fluoroscopy and Cone-Beam CT imaging performance

Niral M. Sheth, Wojciech Zbijewski, Matthew W. Jacobson, Godwin Abiola, Gerhard Kleinszig, Sebastian Vogt, Stefan Soellradl, Jens Bialkowski, William S Anderson, Clifford Weiss, Greg Osgood, Jeff Siewerdsen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose: Indirect-detection CMOS flat-panel detectors (FPDs) offer fine pixel pitch, fast readout, and low electronic noise in comparison to current a-Si:H FPDs. This work investigates the extent to which these potential advantages affect imaging performance in mobile C-arm fluoroscopy and cone-beam CT (CBCT). Methods: FPDs based on CMOS (Xineos 3030HS, 0.151 mm pixel pitch) or a-Si:H (PaxScan 3030X, 0.194 mm pixel pitch) sensors were outfitted on equivalent mobile C-arms for fluoroscopy and CBCT. Technical assessment of 2D and 3D imaging performance included measurement of electronic noise, gain, lag, modulation transfer function (MTF), noise-power spectrum (NPS), detective quantum efficiency (DQE), and noise-equivalent quanta (NEQ) in fluoroscopy (with entrance air kerma ranging 5–800 nGy per frame) and cone-beam CT (with weighted CT dose index, CTDIw, ranging 0.08–1 mGy). Image quality was evaluated by clinicians in vascular, orthopaedic, and neurological surgery in realistic interventional scenarios with cadaver subjects emulating a variety of 2D and 3D imaging tasks. Results: The CMOS FPD exhibited ~2–3× lower electronic noise and ~7× lower image lag than the a-Si:H FPD. The 2D (projection) DQE was superior for CMOS at ≤50 nGy per frame, especially at high spatial frequencies (~2% improvement at 0.5 mm−1 and ≥50% improvement at 2.3 mm−1) and was somewhat inferior at moderate-high doses (up to 18% lower DQE for CMOS at 0.5 mm−1). For smooth CBCT reconstructions (low-frequency imaging tasks), CMOS exhibited ~10%–20% higher NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 mm−1) at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy), while the a-Si:H system yielded slightly (~5%) improved NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 lp/mm) at higher dose levels (CTDIw ≥0.6 mGy). For sharp CBCT reconstructions (high-frequency imaging tasks), NEQ was ~32% higher above 1 mm−1 for the CMOS system at mid-high-dose levels and ≥75% higher at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy). Observer assessment of 2D and 3D cadaver images corroborated the objective metrics with respect to a variety of pertinent interventional imaging tasks. Conclusion: Measurements of image noise, spatial resolution, DQE, and NEQ indicate improved low-dose performance for the CMOS-based system, particularly at lower doses and higher spatial frequencies. Assessment in realistic imaging scenarios confirmed improved visibility of fine details in low-dose fluoroscopy and CBCT. The results quantitate the extent to which CMOS detectors improve mobile C-arm imaging performance, especially in 2D and 3D imaging scenarios involving high-resolution tasks and low-dose conditions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalMedical Physics
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2018

Fingerprint

Fluoroscopy
Noise
Cone-Beam Computed Tomography
Cadaver
Orthopedics
Blood Vessels
Air

Keywords

  • amorphous silicon
  • C-arm
  • CMOS
  • cone-beam CT
  • DQE
  • flat-panel detector
  • fluoroscopy
  • image-guided procedures
  • NEQ
  • NPS
  • spatial resolution
  • technical assessment

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biophysics
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Mobile C-Arm with a CMOS detector : Technical assessment of fluoroscopy and Cone-Beam CT imaging performance. / Sheth, Niral M.; Zbijewski, Wojciech; Jacobson, Matthew W.; Abiola, Godwin; Kleinszig, Gerhard; Vogt, Sebastian; Soellradl, Stefan; Bialkowski, Jens; Anderson, William S; Weiss, Clifford; Osgood, Greg; Siewerdsen, Jeff.

In: Medical Physics, 01.01.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Sheth, Niral M. ; Zbijewski, Wojciech ; Jacobson, Matthew W. ; Abiola, Godwin ; Kleinszig, Gerhard ; Vogt, Sebastian ; Soellradl, Stefan ; Bialkowski, Jens ; Anderson, William S ; Weiss, Clifford ; Osgood, Greg ; Siewerdsen, Jeff. / Mobile C-Arm with a CMOS detector : Technical assessment of fluoroscopy and Cone-Beam CT imaging performance. In: Medical Physics. 2018.
@article{c643618f90d44f8b948162d3a9dc10f4,
title = "Mobile C-Arm with a CMOS detector: Technical assessment of fluoroscopy and Cone-Beam CT imaging performance",
abstract = "Purpose: Indirect-detection CMOS flat-panel detectors (FPDs) offer fine pixel pitch, fast readout, and low electronic noise in comparison to current a-Si:H FPDs. This work investigates the extent to which these potential advantages affect imaging performance in mobile C-arm fluoroscopy and cone-beam CT (CBCT). Methods: FPDs based on CMOS (Xineos 3030HS, 0.151 mm pixel pitch) or a-Si:H (PaxScan 3030X, 0.194 mm pixel pitch) sensors were outfitted on equivalent mobile C-arms for fluoroscopy and CBCT. Technical assessment of 2D and 3D imaging performance included measurement of electronic noise, gain, lag, modulation transfer function (MTF), noise-power spectrum (NPS), detective quantum efficiency (DQE), and noise-equivalent quanta (NEQ) in fluoroscopy (with entrance air kerma ranging 5–800 nGy per frame) and cone-beam CT (with weighted CT dose index, CTDIw, ranging 0.08–1 mGy). Image quality was evaluated by clinicians in vascular, orthopaedic, and neurological surgery in realistic interventional scenarios with cadaver subjects emulating a variety of 2D and 3D imaging tasks. Results: The CMOS FPD exhibited ~2–3× lower electronic noise and ~7× lower image lag than the a-Si:H FPD. The 2D (projection) DQE was superior for CMOS at ≤50 nGy per frame, especially at high spatial frequencies (~2{\%} improvement at 0.5 mm−1 and ≥50{\%} improvement at 2.3 mm−1) and was somewhat inferior at moderate-high doses (up to 18{\%} lower DQE for CMOS at 0.5 mm−1). For smooth CBCT reconstructions (low-frequency imaging tasks), CMOS exhibited ~10{\%}–20{\%} higher NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 mm−1) at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy), while the a-Si:H system yielded slightly (~5{\%}) improved NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 lp/mm) at higher dose levels (CTDIw ≥0.6 mGy). For sharp CBCT reconstructions (high-frequency imaging tasks), NEQ was ~32{\%} higher above 1 mm−1 for the CMOS system at mid-high-dose levels and ≥75{\%} higher at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy). Observer assessment of 2D and 3D cadaver images corroborated the objective metrics with respect to a variety of pertinent interventional imaging tasks. Conclusion: Measurements of image noise, spatial resolution, DQE, and NEQ indicate improved low-dose performance for the CMOS-based system, particularly at lower doses and higher spatial frequencies. Assessment in realistic imaging scenarios confirmed improved visibility of fine details in low-dose fluoroscopy and CBCT. The results quantitate the extent to which CMOS detectors improve mobile C-arm imaging performance, especially in 2D and 3D imaging scenarios involving high-resolution tasks and low-dose conditions.",
keywords = "amorphous silicon, C-arm, CMOS, cone-beam CT, DQE, flat-panel detector, fluoroscopy, image-guided procedures, NEQ, NPS, spatial resolution, technical assessment",
author = "Sheth, {Niral M.} and Wojciech Zbijewski and Jacobson, {Matthew W.} and Godwin Abiola and Gerhard Kleinszig and Sebastian Vogt and Stefan Soellradl and Jens Bialkowski and Anderson, {William S} and Clifford Weiss and Greg Osgood and Jeff Siewerdsen",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/mp.13244",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Medical Physics",
issn = "0094-2405",
publisher = "AAPM - American Association of Physicists in Medicine",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Mobile C-Arm with a CMOS detector

T2 - Technical assessment of fluoroscopy and Cone-Beam CT imaging performance

AU - Sheth, Niral M.

AU - Zbijewski, Wojciech

AU - Jacobson, Matthew W.

AU - Abiola, Godwin

AU - Kleinszig, Gerhard

AU - Vogt, Sebastian

AU - Soellradl, Stefan

AU - Bialkowski, Jens

AU - Anderson, William S

AU - Weiss, Clifford

AU - Osgood, Greg

AU - Siewerdsen, Jeff

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Purpose: Indirect-detection CMOS flat-panel detectors (FPDs) offer fine pixel pitch, fast readout, and low electronic noise in comparison to current a-Si:H FPDs. This work investigates the extent to which these potential advantages affect imaging performance in mobile C-arm fluoroscopy and cone-beam CT (CBCT). Methods: FPDs based on CMOS (Xineos 3030HS, 0.151 mm pixel pitch) or a-Si:H (PaxScan 3030X, 0.194 mm pixel pitch) sensors were outfitted on equivalent mobile C-arms for fluoroscopy and CBCT. Technical assessment of 2D and 3D imaging performance included measurement of electronic noise, gain, lag, modulation transfer function (MTF), noise-power spectrum (NPS), detective quantum efficiency (DQE), and noise-equivalent quanta (NEQ) in fluoroscopy (with entrance air kerma ranging 5–800 nGy per frame) and cone-beam CT (with weighted CT dose index, CTDIw, ranging 0.08–1 mGy). Image quality was evaluated by clinicians in vascular, orthopaedic, and neurological surgery in realistic interventional scenarios with cadaver subjects emulating a variety of 2D and 3D imaging tasks. Results: The CMOS FPD exhibited ~2–3× lower electronic noise and ~7× lower image lag than the a-Si:H FPD. The 2D (projection) DQE was superior for CMOS at ≤50 nGy per frame, especially at high spatial frequencies (~2% improvement at 0.5 mm−1 and ≥50% improvement at 2.3 mm−1) and was somewhat inferior at moderate-high doses (up to 18% lower DQE for CMOS at 0.5 mm−1). For smooth CBCT reconstructions (low-frequency imaging tasks), CMOS exhibited ~10%–20% higher NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 mm−1) at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy), while the a-Si:H system yielded slightly (~5%) improved NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 lp/mm) at higher dose levels (CTDIw ≥0.6 mGy). For sharp CBCT reconstructions (high-frequency imaging tasks), NEQ was ~32% higher above 1 mm−1 for the CMOS system at mid-high-dose levels and ≥75% higher at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy). Observer assessment of 2D and 3D cadaver images corroborated the objective metrics with respect to a variety of pertinent interventional imaging tasks. Conclusion: Measurements of image noise, spatial resolution, DQE, and NEQ indicate improved low-dose performance for the CMOS-based system, particularly at lower doses and higher spatial frequencies. Assessment in realistic imaging scenarios confirmed improved visibility of fine details in low-dose fluoroscopy and CBCT. The results quantitate the extent to which CMOS detectors improve mobile C-arm imaging performance, especially in 2D and 3D imaging scenarios involving high-resolution tasks and low-dose conditions.

AB - Purpose: Indirect-detection CMOS flat-panel detectors (FPDs) offer fine pixel pitch, fast readout, and low electronic noise in comparison to current a-Si:H FPDs. This work investigates the extent to which these potential advantages affect imaging performance in mobile C-arm fluoroscopy and cone-beam CT (CBCT). Methods: FPDs based on CMOS (Xineos 3030HS, 0.151 mm pixel pitch) or a-Si:H (PaxScan 3030X, 0.194 mm pixel pitch) sensors were outfitted on equivalent mobile C-arms for fluoroscopy and CBCT. Technical assessment of 2D and 3D imaging performance included measurement of electronic noise, gain, lag, modulation transfer function (MTF), noise-power spectrum (NPS), detective quantum efficiency (DQE), and noise-equivalent quanta (NEQ) in fluoroscopy (with entrance air kerma ranging 5–800 nGy per frame) and cone-beam CT (with weighted CT dose index, CTDIw, ranging 0.08–1 mGy). Image quality was evaluated by clinicians in vascular, orthopaedic, and neurological surgery in realistic interventional scenarios with cadaver subjects emulating a variety of 2D and 3D imaging tasks. Results: The CMOS FPD exhibited ~2–3× lower electronic noise and ~7× lower image lag than the a-Si:H FPD. The 2D (projection) DQE was superior for CMOS at ≤50 nGy per frame, especially at high spatial frequencies (~2% improvement at 0.5 mm−1 and ≥50% improvement at 2.3 mm−1) and was somewhat inferior at moderate-high doses (up to 18% lower DQE for CMOS at 0.5 mm−1). For smooth CBCT reconstructions (low-frequency imaging tasks), CMOS exhibited ~10%–20% higher NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 mm−1) at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy), while the a-Si:H system yielded slightly (~5%) improved NEQ (at 0.1–0.5 lp/mm) at higher dose levels (CTDIw ≥0.6 mGy). For sharp CBCT reconstructions (high-frequency imaging tasks), NEQ was ~32% higher above 1 mm−1 for the CMOS system at mid-high-dose levels and ≥75% higher at the lowest dose levels (CTDIw ≤0.1 mGy). Observer assessment of 2D and 3D cadaver images corroborated the objective metrics with respect to a variety of pertinent interventional imaging tasks. Conclusion: Measurements of image noise, spatial resolution, DQE, and NEQ indicate improved low-dose performance for the CMOS-based system, particularly at lower doses and higher spatial frequencies. Assessment in realistic imaging scenarios confirmed improved visibility of fine details in low-dose fluoroscopy and CBCT. The results quantitate the extent to which CMOS detectors improve mobile C-arm imaging performance, especially in 2D and 3D imaging scenarios involving high-resolution tasks and low-dose conditions.

KW - amorphous silicon

KW - C-arm

KW - CMOS

KW - cone-beam CT

KW - DQE

KW - flat-panel detector

KW - fluoroscopy

KW - image-guided procedures

KW - NEQ

KW - NPS

KW - spatial resolution

KW - technical assessment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85056414887&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85056414887&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/mp.13244

DO - 10.1002/mp.13244

M3 - Article

JO - Medical Physics

JF - Medical Physics

SN - 0094-2405

ER -