Methods for the accurate estimation of confidence intervals on protein folding φ-values

Ingo Ruczinski, Tobin R. Sosnick, Kevin W. Plaxco

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

φ-Values provide an important benchmark for the comparison of experimental protein folding studies to computer simulations and theories of the folding process. Despite the growing importance of φ measurements, however, formulas to quantify the precision with which φ is measured have seen little significant discussion. Moreover, a commonly employed method for the determination of standard errors on φ estimates assumes that estimates of the changes in free energy of the transition and folded states are independent. Here we demonstrate that this assumption is usually incorrect and that this typically leads to the underestimation of φ precision. We derive an analytical expression for the precision of φ estimates (assuming linear chevron behavior) that explicitly takes this dependence into account. We also describe an alternative method that implicitly corrects for the effect. By simulating experimental chevron data, we show that both methods accurately estimate φ confidence intervals. We also explore the effects of the commonly employed techniques of calculating φ from kinetics estimated at non-zero denaturant concentrations and via the assumption of parallel chevron arms. We find that these approaches can produce significantly different estimates for φ (again, even for truly linear chevron behavior), indicating that they are not equivalent, interchangeable measures of transition state structure. Lastly, we describe a Web-based implementation of the above algorithms for general use by the protein folding community. Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)2257-2264
Number of pages8
JournalProtein Science
Volume15
Issue number10
DOIs
StatePublished - 2006

Fingerprint

Protein folding
Protein Folding
Confidence Intervals
Ports and harbors
Free energy
Benchmarking
Computer Simulation
Kinetics
Computer simulation

Keywords

  • φ-value
  • Estimate
  • Free energy
  • Protein folding
  • Standard error
  • Transition state

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biochemistry

Cite this

Methods for the accurate estimation of confidence intervals on protein folding φ-values. / Ruczinski, Ingo; Sosnick, Tobin R.; Plaxco, Kevin W.

In: Protein Science, Vol. 15, No. 10, 2006, p. 2257-2264.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ruczinski, Ingo ; Sosnick, Tobin R. ; Plaxco, Kevin W. / Methods for the accurate estimation of confidence intervals on protein folding φ-values. In: Protein Science. 2006 ; Vol. 15, No. 10. pp. 2257-2264.
@article{6ef520d22e3b4d17ba2eed8f085bc857,
title = "Methods for the accurate estimation of confidence intervals on protein folding φ-values",
abstract = "φ-Values provide an important benchmark for the comparison of experimental protein folding studies to computer simulations and theories of the folding process. Despite the growing importance of φ measurements, however, formulas to quantify the precision with which φ is measured have seen little significant discussion. Moreover, a commonly employed method for the determination of standard errors on φ estimates assumes that estimates of the changes in free energy of the transition and folded states are independent. Here we demonstrate that this assumption is usually incorrect and that this typically leads to the underestimation of φ precision. We derive an analytical expression for the precision of φ estimates (assuming linear chevron behavior) that explicitly takes this dependence into account. We also describe an alternative method that implicitly corrects for the effect. By simulating experimental chevron data, we show that both methods accurately estimate φ confidence intervals. We also explore the effects of the commonly employed techniques of calculating φ from kinetics estimated at non-zero denaturant concentrations and via the assumption of parallel chevron arms. We find that these approaches can produce significantly different estimates for φ (again, even for truly linear chevron behavior), indicating that they are not equivalent, interchangeable measures of transition state structure. Lastly, we describe a Web-based implementation of the above algorithms for general use by the protein folding community. Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.",
keywords = "φ-value, Estimate, Free energy, Protein folding, Standard error, Transition state",
author = "Ingo Ruczinski and Sosnick, {Tobin R.} and Plaxco, {Kevin W.}",
year = "2006",
doi = "10.1110/ps.062230106",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "15",
pages = "2257--2264",
journal = "Protein Science",
issn = "0961-8368",
publisher = "Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Methods for the accurate estimation of confidence intervals on protein folding φ-values

AU - Ruczinski, Ingo

AU - Sosnick, Tobin R.

AU - Plaxco, Kevin W.

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - φ-Values provide an important benchmark for the comparison of experimental protein folding studies to computer simulations and theories of the folding process. Despite the growing importance of φ measurements, however, formulas to quantify the precision with which φ is measured have seen little significant discussion. Moreover, a commonly employed method for the determination of standard errors on φ estimates assumes that estimates of the changes in free energy of the transition and folded states are independent. Here we demonstrate that this assumption is usually incorrect and that this typically leads to the underestimation of φ precision. We derive an analytical expression for the precision of φ estimates (assuming linear chevron behavior) that explicitly takes this dependence into account. We also describe an alternative method that implicitly corrects for the effect. By simulating experimental chevron data, we show that both methods accurately estimate φ confidence intervals. We also explore the effects of the commonly employed techniques of calculating φ from kinetics estimated at non-zero denaturant concentrations and via the assumption of parallel chevron arms. We find that these approaches can produce significantly different estimates for φ (again, even for truly linear chevron behavior), indicating that they are not equivalent, interchangeable measures of transition state structure. Lastly, we describe a Web-based implementation of the above algorithms for general use by the protein folding community. Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.

AB - φ-Values provide an important benchmark for the comparison of experimental protein folding studies to computer simulations and theories of the folding process. Despite the growing importance of φ measurements, however, formulas to quantify the precision with which φ is measured have seen little significant discussion. Moreover, a commonly employed method for the determination of standard errors on φ estimates assumes that estimates of the changes in free energy of the transition and folded states are independent. Here we demonstrate that this assumption is usually incorrect and that this typically leads to the underestimation of φ precision. We derive an analytical expression for the precision of φ estimates (assuming linear chevron behavior) that explicitly takes this dependence into account. We also describe an alternative method that implicitly corrects for the effect. By simulating experimental chevron data, we show that both methods accurately estimate φ confidence intervals. We also explore the effects of the commonly employed techniques of calculating φ from kinetics estimated at non-zero denaturant concentrations and via the assumption of parallel chevron arms. We find that these approaches can produce significantly different estimates for φ (again, even for truly linear chevron behavior), indicating that they are not equivalent, interchangeable measures of transition state structure. Lastly, we describe a Web-based implementation of the above algorithms for general use by the protein folding community. Published by Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.

KW - φ-value

KW - Estimate

KW - Free energy

KW - Protein folding

KW - Standard error

KW - Transition state

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33749322256&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33749322256&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1110/ps.062230106

DO - 10.1110/ps.062230106

M3 - Article

C2 - 17008714

AN - SCOPUS:33749322256

VL - 15

SP - 2257

EP - 2264

JO - Protein Science

JF - Protein Science

SN - 0961-8368

IS - 10

ER -