Lumbar spine: Reliability of MR imaging findings

John A. Carrino, Jon D. Lurie, Anna N A Tosteson, Tor D. Tosteson, Eugene J. Carragee, Jay Kaiser, Margaret R. Grove, Emily Blood, Loretta H. Pearson, N. James Weinstein, Richard Herzog

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose: To characterize the inter- and intraobserver variability of qualitative, non-disk contour degenerative findings of the lumbar spine at magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. Materials and Methods: The case accrual method used to perform this institutional review board-approved, HIPAA-compliant retrospective study was the random selection of 111 interpretable MR examination cases of subjects from the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial. The subjects were aged 18-87 years (mean, 53 years ± 16 [standard deviation]). Four independent readers rated the cases according to defined criteria. A subsample of 40 MR examination cases was selected for reevaluation at least 1 month later. The following findings were assessed: spondylolisthesis, disk degeneration, marrow endplate abnormality (Modic changes), posterior anular hyperintense zone (HIZ), and facet arthropathy. Inter-and intraobserver agreement in rating the data was summarized by using weighted κ statistics. Results: Interobserver agreement was good (k = 0.66) in rating disk degeneration and moderate in rating spondylolisthe- sis (k = 0.55), Modic changes (k = 0.59), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.54), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.44). Interob-server agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate: κ Values were 0.43 for determining superior anteroposterior extent, 0.47 for determining superior craniocaudal extent, 0.57 for determining inferior antero- posterior extent, and 0.48 for determining inferior cranio- caudal extent. Intraobserver agreement was good in rating spondylolisthesis (κ = 0.66), disk degeneration (κ = 0.74), Modic changes (κ = 0.64), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.69), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.67). Intraobserver agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate, with κ values of 0.54 for superior anteroposterior, 0.60 for inferior anteroposterior, 0.50 for superior craniocaudal, and 0.60 for inferior craniocaudal extent determinations. Conclusion: The interpretation of general lumbar spine MR characteristics has sufficient reliability to warrant the further evaluation of these features as potential prognostic indicators.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)161-170
Number of pages10
JournalRadiology
Volume250
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 2009

Fingerprint

Intervertebral Disc Degeneration
Spondylolisthesis
Joint Diseases
Spine
Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
Observer Variation
Research Ethics Committees
Retrospective Studies
Bone Marrow
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Carrino, J. A., Lurie, J. D., Tosteson, A. N. A., Tosteson, T. D., Carragee, E. J., Kaiser, J., ... Herzog, R. (2009). Lumbar spine: Reliability of MR imaging findings. Radiology, 250(1), 161-170. https://doi.org/10.1148/radiol.2493071999

Lumbar spine : Reliability of MR imaging findings. / Carrino, John A.; Lurie, Jon D.; Tosteson, Anna N A; Tosteson, Tor D.; Carragee, Eugene J.; Kaiser, Jay; Grove, Margaret R.; Blood, Emily; Pearson, Loretta H.; Weinstein, N. James; Herzog, Richard.

In: Radiology, Vol. 250, No. 1, 01.2009, p. 161-170.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Carrino, JA, Lurie, JD, Tosteson, ANA, Tosteson, TD, Carragee, EJ, Kaiser, J, Grove, MR, Blood, E, Pearson, LH, Weinstein, NJ & Herzog, R 2009, 'Lumbar spine: Reliability of MR imaging findings', Radiology, vol. 250, no. 1, pp. 161-170. https://doi.org/10.1148/radiol.2493071999
Carrino JA, Lurie JD, Tosteson ANA, Tosteson TD, Carragee EJ, Kaiser J et al. Lumbar spine: Reliability of MR imaging findings. Radiology. 2009 Jan;250(1):161-170. https://doi.org/10.1148/radiol.2493071999
Carrino, John A. ; Lurie, Jon D. ; Tosteson, Anna N A ; Tosteson, Tor D. ; Carragee, Eugene J. ; Kaiser, Jay ; Grove, Margaret R. ; Blood, Emily ; Pearson, Loretta H. ; Weinstein, N. James ; Herzog, Richard. / Lumbar spine : Reliability of MR imaging findings. In: Radiology. 2009 ; Vol. 250, No. 1. pp. 161-170.
@article{ae2a0754f5754e83a77504dabc7323c6,
title = "Lumbar spine: Reliability of MR imaging findings",
abstract = "Purpose: To characterize the inter- and intraobserver variability of qualitative, non-disk contour degenerative findings of the lumbar spine at magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. Materials and Methods: The case accrual method used to perform this institutional review board-approved, HIPAA-compliant retrospective study was the random selection of 111 interpretable MR examination cases of subjects from the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial. The subjects were aged 18-87 years (mean, 53 years ± 16 [standard deviation]). Four independent readers rated the cases according to defined criteria. A subsample of 40 MR examination cases was selected for reevaluation at least 1 month later. The following findings were assessed: spondylolisthesis, disk degeneration, marrow endplate abnormality (Modic changes), posterior anular hyperintense zone (HIZ), and facet arthropathy. Inter-and intraobserver agreement in rating the data was summarized by using weighted κ statistics. Results: Interobserver agreement was good (k = 0.66) in rating disk degeneration and moderate in rating spondylolisthe- sis (k = 0.55), Modic changes (k = 0.59), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.54), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.44). Interob-server agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate: κ Values were 0.43 for determining superior anteroposterior extent, 0.47 for determining superior craniocaudal extent, 0.57 for determining inferior antero- posterior extent, and 0.48 for determining inferior cranio- caudal extent. Intraobserver agreement was good in rating spondylolisthesis (κ = 0.66), disk degeneration (κ = 0.74), Modic changes (κ = 0.64), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.69), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.67). Intraobserver agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate, with κ values of 0.54 for superior anteroposterior, 0.60 for inferior anteroposterior, 0.50 for superior craniocaudal, and 0.60 for inferior craniocaudal extent determinations. Conclusion: The interpretation of general lumbar spine MR characteristics has sufficient reliability to warrant the further evaluation of these features as potential prognostic indicators.",
author = "Carrino, {John A.} and Lurie, {Jon D.} and Tosteson, {Anna N A} and Tosteson, {Tor D.} and Carragee, {Eugene J.} and Jay Kaiser and Grove, {Margaret R.} and Emily Blood and Pearson, {Loretta H.} and Weinstein, {N. James} and Richard Herzog",
year = "2009",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1148/radiol.2493071999",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "250",
pages = "161--170",
journal = "Radiology",
issn = "0033-8419",
publisher = "Radiological Society of North America Inc.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Lumbar spine

T2 - Reliability of MR imaging findings

AU - Carrino, John A.

AU - Lurie, Jon D.

AU - Tosteson, Anna N A

AU - Tosteson, Tor D.

AU - Carragee, Eugene J.

AU - Kaiser, Jay

AU - Grove, Margaret R.

AU - Blood, Emily

AU - Pearson, Loretta H.

AU - Weinstein, N. James

AU - Herzog, Richard

PY - 2009/1

Y1 - 2009/1

N2 - Purpose: To characterize the inter- and intraobserver variability of qualitative, non-disk contour degenerative findings of the lumbar spine at magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. Materials and Methods: The case accrual method used to perform this institutional review board-approved, HIPAA-compliant retrospective study was the random selection of 111 interpretable MR examination cases of subjects from the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial. The subjects were aged 18-87 years (mean, 53 years ± 16 [standard deviation]). Four independent readers rated the cases according to defined criteria. A subsample of 40 MR examination cases was selected for reevaluation at least 1 month later. The following findings were assessed: spondylolisthesis, disk degeneration, marrow endplate abnormality (Modic changes), posterior anular hyperintense zone (HIZ), and facet arthropathy. Inter-and intraobserver agreement in rating the data was summarized by using weighted κ statistics. Results: Interobserver agreement was good (k = 0.66) in rating disk degeneration and moderate in rating spondylolisthe- sis (k = 0.55), Modic changes (k = 0.59), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.54), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.44). Interob-server agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate: κ Values were 0.43 for determining superior anteroposterior extent, 0.47 for determining superior craniocaudal extent, 0.57 for determining inferior antero- posterior extent, and 0.48 for determining inferior cranio- caudal extent. Intraobserver agreement was good in rating spondylolisthesis (κ = 0.66), disk degeneration (κ = 0.74), Modic changes (κ = 0.64), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.69), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.67). Intraobserver agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate, with κ values of 0.54 for superior anteroposterior, 0.60 for inferior anteroposterior, 0.50 for superior craniocaudal, and 0.60 for inferior craniocaudal extent determinations. Conclusion: The interpretation of general lumbar spine MR characteristics has sufficient reliability to warrant the further evaluation of these features as potential prognostic indicators.

AB - Purpose: To characterize the inter- and intraobserver variability of qualitative, non-disk contour degenerative findings of the lumbar spine at magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. Materials and Methods: The case accrual method used to perform this institutional review board-approved, HIPAA-compliant retrospective study was the random selection of 111 interpretable MR examination cases of subjects from the Spine Patient Outcomes Research Trial. The subjects were aged 18-87 years (mean, 53 years ± 16 [standard deviation]). Four independent readers rated the cases according to defined criteria. A subsample of 40 MR examination cases was selected for reevaluation at least 1 month later. The following findings were assessed: spondylolisthesis, disk degeneration, marrow endplate abnormality (Modic changes), posterior anular hyperintense zone (HIZ), and facet arthropathy. Inter-and intraobserver agreement in rating the data was summarized by using weighted κ statistics. Results: Interobserver agreement was good (k = 0.66) in rating disk degeneration and moderate in rating spondylolisthe- sis (k = 0.55), Modic changes (k = 0.59), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.54), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.44). Interob-server agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate: κ Values were 0.43 for determining superior anteroposterior extent, 0.47 for determining superior craniocaudal extent, 0.57 for determining inferior antero- posterior extent, and 0.48 for determining inferior cranio- caudal extent. Intraobserver agreement was good in rating spondylolisthesis (κ = 0.66), disk degeneration (κ = 0.74), Modic changes (κ = 0.64), facet arthropathy (κ = 0.69), and posterior HIZ (κ = 0.67). Intraobserver agreement in rating the extent of Modic changes was moderate, with κ values of 0.54 for superior anteroposterior, 0.60 for inferior anteroposterior, 0.50 for superior craniocaudal, and 0.60 for inferior craniocaudal extent determinations. Conclusion: The interpretation of general lumbar spine MR characteristics has sufficient reliability to warrant the further evaluation of these features as potential prognostic indicators.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=58149331043&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=58149331043&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1148/radiol.2493071999

DO - 10.1148/radiol.2493071999

M3 - Article

C2 - 18955509

AN - SCOPUS:58149331043

VL - 250

SP - 161

EP - 170

JO - Radiology

JF - Radiology

SN - 0033-8419

IS - 1

ER -