“It's not like taking chocolates”: Factors influencing the feasibility and sustainability of universal test and treat in correctional health systems in Zambia and South Africa

Stephanie M. Topp, Candice M. Chetty-Makkan, Helene J. Smith, Lucy Chimoyi, Christopher Hoffmann, Katherine Fielding, Stewart E. Reid, Abraham J. Olivier, Harry Hausler, Michael E. Herce, Salome Charalambous

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Sub-Saharan African correctional facilities concentrate large numbers of people who are living with HIV or at risk for HIV infection. Universal test and treat (UTT) is widely recognized as a promising approach to improve the health of individuals and a population health strategy to reduce new HIV infections. In this study, we explored the feasibility and sustainability of implementing UTT in correctional facilities in Zambia and South Africa. Methods: Nested within a UTT implementation research study, our qualitative evaluation of feasibility and sustainability used a case-comparison design based on data from 1 Zambian and 3 South African correctional facilities. Primary data from in-depth interviews with incarcerated individuals, correctional managers, health care providers, and policy makers were supplemented by public policy documents, study documentation, and implementation memos in both countries. Thematic analysis was informed by an empirically established conceptual framework for health system analysis. Results: Despite different institutional profiles, we were able to successfully introduce UTT in the South Africa and Zambian correctional facilities participating in the study. A supportive policy backdrop was important to UTT implementation and establishment in both countries. However, sustainability of UTT, defined as relevant government departments' capacity to independently plan, resource, and administer quality UTT, differed. South Africa's correctional facilities had existing systems to deliver and monitor chronic HIV care and treatment, forming a “scaffolding” for sustained UTT despite some human resources shortages and poorly integrated health information systems. Notwithstanding recent improvements, Zambia's correctional health system demonstrated insufficient material and technical capacity to independently deliver quality UTT. In the correctional facilities of both countries, inmate population dynamics and their impact on HIV-related stigma were important factors in UTT service uptake. Conclusion: Findings demonstrate the critical role of policy directives, health service delivery systems, adequate resourcing, and population dynamics on the feasibility and likely sustainability of UTT in corrections in Zambia and South Africa.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)189-202
Number of pages14
JournalGlobal Health Science and Practice
Volume7
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Zambia
South Africa
Health
Population Dynamics
HIV
HIV Infections
Health Information Systems
Public Policy
Health Policy
Systems Analysis
Administrative Personnel
Documentation
Health Personnel
Health Services
Interviews
Chocolate
Research
Population

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Policy
  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

Cite this

“It's not like taking chocolates” : Factors influencing the feasibility and sustainability of universal test and treat in correctional health systems in Zambia and South Africa. / Topp, Stephanie M.; Chetty-Makkan, Candice M.; Smith, Helene J.; Chimoyi, Lucy; Hoffmann, Christopher; Fielding, Katherine; Reid, Stewart E.; Olivier, Abraham J.; Hausler, Harry; Herce, Michael E.; Charalambous, Salome.

In: Global Health Science and Practice, Vol. 7, No. 2, 01.01.2019, p. 189-202.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Topp, Stephanie M. ; Chetty-Makkan, Candice M. ; Smith, Helene J. ; Chimoyi, Lucy ; Hoffmann, Christopher ; Fielding, Katherine ; Reid, Stewart E. ; Olivier, Abraham J. ; Hausler, Harry ; Herce, Michael E. ; Charalambous, Salome. / “It's not like taking chocolates” : Factors influencing the feasibility and sustainability of universal test and treat in correctional health systems in Zambia and South Africa. In: Global Health Science and Practice. 2019 ; Vol. 7, No. 2. pp. 189-202.
@article{f9ac4c9dfe404a5d8c01b1875a44c4db,
title = "“It's not like taking chocolates”: Factors influencing the feasibility and sustainability of universal test and treat in correctional health systems in Zambia and South Africa",
abstract = "Background: Sub-Saharan African correctional facilities concentrate large numbers of people who are living with HIV or at risk for HIV infection. Universal test and treat (UTT) is widely recognized as a promising approach to improve the health of individuals and a population health strategy to reduce new HIV infections. In this study, we explored the feasibility and sustainability of implementing UTT in correctional facilities in Zambia and South Africa. Methods: Nested within a UTT implementation research study, our qualitative evaluation of feasibility and sustainability used a case-comparison design based on data from 1 Zambian and 3 South African correctional facilities. Primary data from in-depth interviews with incarcerated individuals, correctional managers, health care providers, and policy makers were supplemented by public policy documents, study documentation, and implementation memos in both countries. Thematic analysis was informed by an empirically established conceptual framework for health system analysis. Results: Despite different institutional profiles, we were able to successfully introduce UTT in the South Africa and Zambian correctional facilities participating in the study. A supportive policy backdrop was important to UTT implementation and establishment in both countries. However, sustainability of UTT, defined as relevant government departments' capacity to independently plan, resource, and administer quality UTT, differed. South Africa's correctional facilities had existing systems to deliver and monitor chronic HIV care and treatment, forming a “scaffolding” for sustained UTT despite some human resources shortages and poorly integrated health information systems. Notwithstanding recent improvements, Zambia's correctional health system demonstrated insufficient material and technical capacity to independently deliver quality UTT. In the correctional facilities of both countries, inmate population dynamics and their impact on HIV-related stigma were important factors in UTT service uptake. Conclusion: Findings demonstrate the critical role of policy directives, health service delivery systems, adequate resourcing, and population dynamics on the feasibility and likely sustainability of UTT in corrections in Zambia and South Africa.",
author = "Topp, {Stephanie M.} and Chetty-Makkan, {Candice M.} and Smith, {Helene J.} and Lucy Chimoyi and Christopher Hoffmann and Katherine Fielding and Reid, {Stewart E.} and Olivier, {Abraham J.} and Harry Hausler and Herce, {Michael E.} and Salome Charalambous",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.9745/GHSP-D-19-00051",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "7",
pages = "189--202",
journal = "Global health, science and practice",
issn = "2169-575X",
publisher = "U.S. Agency for International Development",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - “It's not like taking chocolates”

T2 - Factors influencing the feasibility and sustainability of universal test and treat in correctional health systems in Zambia and South Africa

AU - Topp, Stephanie M.

AU - Chetty-Makkan, Candice M.

AU - Smith, Helene J.

AU - Chimoyi, Lucy

AU - Hoffmann, Christopher

AU - Fielding, Katherine

AU - Reid, Stewart E.

AU - Olivier, Abraham J.

AU - Hausler, Harry

AU - Herce, Michael E.

AU - Charalambous, Salome

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Background: Sub-Saharan African correctional facilities concentrate large numbers of people who are living with HIV or at risk for HIV infection. Universal test and treat (UTT) is widely recognized as a promising approach to improve the health of individuals and a population health strategy to reduce new HIV infections. In this study, we explored the feasibility and sustainability of implementing UTT in correctional facilities in Zambia and South Africa. Methods: Nested within a UTT implementation research study, our qualitative evaluation of feasibility and sustainability used a case-comparison design based on data from 1 Zambian and 3 South African correctional facilities. Primary data from in-depth interviews with incarcerated individuals, correctional managers, health care providers, and policy makers were supplemented by public policy documents, study documentation, and implementation memos in both countries. Thematic analysis was informed by an empirically established conceptual framework for health system analysis. Results: Despite different institutional profiles, we were able to successfully introduce UTT in the South Africa and Zambian correctional facilities participating in the study. A supportive policy backdrop was important to UTT implementation and establishment in both countries. However, sustainability of UTT, defined as relevant government departments' capacity to independently plan, resource, and administer quality UTT, differed. South Africa's correctional facilities had existing systems to deliver and monitor chronic HIV care and treatment, forming a “scaffolding” for sustained UTT despite some human resources shortages and poorly integrated health information systems. Notwithstanding recent improvements, Zambia's correctional health system demonstrated insufficient material and technical capacity to independently deliver quality UTT. In the correctional facilities of both countries, inmate population dynamics and their impact on HIV-related stigma were important factors in UTT service uptake. Conclusion: Findings demonstrate the critical role of policy directives, health service delivery systems, adequate resourcing, and population dynamics on the feasibility and likely sustainability of UTT in corrections in Zambia and South Africa.

AB - Background: Sub-Saharan African correctional facilities concentrate large numbers of people who are living with HIV or at risk for HIV infection. Universal test and treat (UTT) is widely recognized as a promising approach to improve the health of individuals and a population health strategy to reduce new HIV infections. In this study, we explored the feasibility and sustainability of implementing UTT in correctional facilities in Zambia and South Africa. Methods: Nested within a UTT implementation research study, our qualitative evaluation of feasibility and sustainability used a case-comparison design based on data from 1 Zambian and 3 South African correctional facilities. Primary data from in-depth interviews with incarcerated individuals, correctional managers, health care providers, and policy makers were supplemented by public policy documents, study documentation, and implementation memos in both countries. Thematic analysis was informed by an empirically established conceptual framework for health system analysis. Results: Despite different institutional profiles, we were able to successfully introduce UTT in the South Africa and Zambian correctional facilities participating in the study. A supportive policy backdrop was important to UTT implementation and establishment in both countries. However, sustainability of UTT, defined as relevant government departments' capacity to independently plan, resource, and administer quality UTT, differed. South Africa's correctional facilities had existing systems to deliver and monitor chronic HIV care and treatment, forming a “scaffolding” for sustained UTT despite some human resources shortages and poorly integrated health information systems. Notwithstanding recent improvements, Zambia's correctional health system demonstrated insufficient material and technical capacity to independently deliver quality UTT. In the correctional facilities of both countries, inmate population dynamics and their impact on HIV-related stigma were important factors in UTT service uptake. Conclusion: Findings demonstrate the critical role of policy directives, health service delivery systems, adequate resourcing, and population dynamics on the feasibility and likely sustainability of UTT in corrections in Zambia and South Africa.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85068779256&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85068779256&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.9745/GHSP-D-19-00051

DO - 10.9745/GHSP-D-19-00051

M3 - Article

C2 - 31249019

AN - SCOPUS:85068779256

VL - 7

SP - 189

EP - 202

JO - Global health, science and practice

JF - Global health, science and practice

SN - 2169-575X

IS - 2

ER -