Inter- and intra-observer variability in grading lesions of age-related maculopathy and macular degeneration

Hendrik P N Scholl, Tunde Peto, Samantha Dandekar, Catey Bunce, Wen Xing, Sharon Jenkins, Alan C. Bird

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose: To introduce a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group for identifying and quantifying abnormalities of age-related maculopathy (ARM) and age-related degeneration (AMD) and to investigate its reliability, specifically the inter- and intra-observer variability. Methods: Fifty eyes of 25 patients with ARM or AMD in at least one eye were randomly selected from a large ongoing collection of clinical data and DNA in a tertiary referral UK population. Stereoscopic color fundus photographs were taken with a 30° fundus camera and were centered on the macula. Presence and severity of fundus abnormalities in ARM and AMD were graded using a grid to define macular subfields and standard circles to define the size of lesions. Inter-observer variability was assessed by having three retinal specialists evaluate the color slides and intra-observer variability by regrading the same set. Results: The inter-observer agreement for all subfields was fair to substantial for small hard drusen (70-89%; κ=0.26-0.63) and intermediate soft drusen (76-94%; κ=0.27-0.69). Agreement ranged between 87% and 100%, between 50% and 92%, and between 78% and 100% for larger drusen, the presence of hyperpigmentation, and the presence of hypopigmentation, respectively. Agreement was moderate to almost perfect for the presence of geographic atrophy (88-98%; κ=0.60-0.95) and substantial to almost perfect for the presence of choroidal neovascularization (84-100%; κ=0.62-1.00). The intra-observer variability for the grading of drusen characteristics and pigmentary changes was similar in magnitude, but slightly greater for features of advanced AMD. Conclusion: Reproducibility was achieved using a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group. This grading system may therefore be used for phenotyping of ARM and AMD.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)39-47
Number of pages9
JournalGraefe's Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology
Volume241
Issue number1
StatePublished - Jan 1 2003
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Observer Variation
Macular Degeneration
Epidemiologic Studies
Color
Geographic Atrophy
Hypopigmentation
Choroidal Neovascularization
Hyperpigmentation
Referral and Consultation
DNA
Population

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ophthalmology

Cite this

Scholl, H. P. N., Peto, T., Dandekar, S., Bunce, C., Xing, W., Jenkins, S., & Bird, A. C. (2003). Inter- and intra-observer variability in grading lesions of age-related maculopathy and macular degeneration. Graefe's Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology, 241(1), 39-47.

Inter- and intra-observer variability in grading lesions of age-related maculopathy and macular degeneration. / Scholl, Hendrik P N; Peto, Tunde; Dandekar, Samantha; Bunce, Catey; Xing, Wen; Jenkins, Sharon; Bird, Alan C.

In: Graefe's Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology, Vol. 241, No. 1, 01.01.2003, p. 39-47.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Scholl, HPN, Peto, T, Dandekar, S, Bunce, C, Xing, W, Jenkins, S & Bird, AC 2003, 'Inter- and intra-observer variability in grading lesions of age-related maculopathy and macular degeneration', Graefe's Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology, vol. 241, no. 1, pp. 39-47.
Scholl, Hendrik P N ; Peto, Tunde ; Dandekar, Samantha ; Bunce, Catey ; Xing, Wen ; Jenkins, Sharon ; Bird, Alan C. / Inter- and intra-observer variability in grading lesions of age-related maculopathy and macular degeneration. In: Graefe's Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology. 2003 ; Vol. 241, No. 1. pp. 39-47.
@article{10b68254903d425bb7dc005474b722ad,
title = "Inter- and intra-observer variability in grading lesions of age-related maculopathy and macular degeneration",
abstract = "Purpose: To introduce a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group for identifying and quantifying abnormalities of age-related maculopathy (ARM) and age-related degeneration (AMD) and to investigate its reliability, specifically the inter- and intra-observer variability. Methods: Fifty eyes of 25 patients with ARM or AMD in at least one eye were randomly selected from a large ongoing collection of clinical data and DNA in a tertiary referral UK population. Stereoscopic color fundus photographs were taken with a 30° fundus camera and were centered on the macula. Presence and severity of fundus abnormalities in ARM and AMD were graded using a grid to define macular subfields and standard circles to define the size of lesions. Inter-observer variability was assessed by having three retinal specialists evaluate the color slides and intra-observer variability by regrading the same set. Results: The inter-observer agreement for all subfields was fair to substantial for small hard drusen (70-89{\%}; κ=0.26-0.63) and intermediate soft drusen (76-94{\%}; κ=0.27-0.69). Agreement ranged between 87{\%} and 100{\%}, between 50{\%} and 92{\%}, and between 78{\%} and 100{\%} for larger drusen, the presence of hyperpigmentation, and the presence of hypopigmentation, respectively. Agreement was moderate to almost perfect for the presence of geographic atrophy (88-98{\%}; κ=0.60-0.95) and substantial to almost perfect for the presence of choroidal neovascularization (84-100{\%}; κ=0.62-1.00). The intra-observer variability for the grading of drusen characteristics and pigmentary changes was similar in magnitude, but slightly greater for features of advanced AMD. Conclusion: Reproducibility was achieved using a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group. This grading system may therefore be used for phenotyping of ARM and AMD.",
author = "Scholl, {Hendrik P N} and Tunde Peto and Samantha Dandekar and Catey Bunce and Wen Xing and Sharon Jenkins and Bird, {Alan C.}",
year = "2003",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "241",
pages = "39--47",
journal = "Albrecht von Graefes Archiv für Klinische und Experimentelle Ophthalmologie",
issn = "0721-832X",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Inter- and intra-observer variability in grading lesions of age-related maculopathy and macular degeneration

AU - Scholl, Hendrik P N

AU - Peto, Tunde

AU - Dandekar, Samantha

AU - Bunce, Catey

AU - Xing, Wen

AU - Jenkins, Sharon

AU - Bird, Alan C.

PY - 2003/1/1

Y1 - 2003/1/1

N2 - Purpose: To introduce a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group for identifying and quantifying abnormalities of age-related maculopathy (ARM) and age-related degeneration (AMD) and to investigate its reliability, specifically the inter- and intra-observer variability. Methods: Fifty eyes of 25 patients with ARM or AMD in at least one eye were randomly selected from a large ongoing collection of clinical data and DNA in a tertiary referral UK population. Stereoscopic color fundus photographs were taken with a 30° fundus camera and were centered on the macula. Presence and severity of fundus abnormalities in ARM and AMD were graded using a grid to define macular subfields and standard circles to define the size of lesions. Inter-observer variability was assessed by having three retinal specialists evaluate the color slides and intra-observer variability by regrading the same set. Results: The inter-observer agreement for all subfields was fair to substantial for small hard drusen (70-89%; κ=0.26-0.63) and intermediate soft drusen (76-94%; κ=0.27-0.69). Agreement ranged between 87% and 100%, between 50% and 92%, and between 78% and 100% for larger drusen, the presence of hyperpigmentation, and the presence of hypopigmentation, respectively. Agreement was moderate to almost perfect for the presence of geographic atrophy (88-98%; κ=0.60-0.95) and substantial to almost perfect for the presence of choroidal neovascularization (84-100%; κ=0.62-1.00). The intra-observer variability for the grading of drusen characteristics and pigmentary changes was similar in magnitude, but slightly greater for features of advanced AMD. Conclusion: Reproducibility was achieved using a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group. This grading system may therefore be used for phenotyping of ARM and AMD.

AB - Purpose: To introduce a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group for identifying and quantifying abnormalities of age-related maculopathy (ARM) and age-related degeneration (AMD) and to investigate its reliability, specifically the inter- and intra-observer variability. Methods: Fifty eyes of 25 patients with ARM or AMD in at least one eye were randomly selected from a large ongoing collection of clinical data and DNA in a tertiary referral UK population. Stereoscopic color fundus photographs were taken with a 30° fundus camera and were centered on the macula. Presence and severity of fundus abnormalities in ARM and AMD were graded using a grid to define macular subfields and standard circles to define the size of lesions. Inter-observer variability was assessed by having three retinal specialists evaluate the color slides and intra-observer variability by regrading the same set. Results: The inter-observer agreement for all subfields was fair to substantial for small hard drusen (70-89%; κ=0.26-0.63) and intermediate soft drusen (76-94%; κ=0.27-0.69). Agreement ranged between 87% and 100%, between 50% and 92%, and between 78% and 100% for larger drusen, the presence of hyperpigmentation, and the presence of hypopigmentation, respectively. Agreement was moderate to almost perfect for the presence of geographic atrophy (88-98%; κ=0.60-0.95) and substantial to almost perfect for the presence of choroidal neovascularization (84-100%; κ=0.62-1.00). The intra-observer variability for the grading of drusen characteristics and pigmentary changes was similar in magnitude, but slightly greater for features of advanced AMD. Conclusion: Reproducibility was achieved using a revised version of the grading system established by the International ARM Epidemiological Study Group. This grading system may therefore be used for phenotyping of ARM and AMD.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0037270039&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0037270039&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 12545291

AN - SCOPUS:0037270039

VL - 241

SP - 39

EP - 47

JO - Albrecht von Graefes Archiv für Klinische und Experimentelle Ophthalmologie

JF - Albrecht von Graefes Archiv für Klinische und Experimentelle Ophthalmologie

SN - 0721-832X

IS - 1

ER -