Integrity and function of gestures in aphasia

Niloofar Akhavan, Tilbe Göksun, Nazbanou Nozari

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Gestures can provide an excellent natural alternative to verbal communication in people with aphasia (PWA). However, despite numerous studies focusing on gesture production in aphasia, it is still a matter of debate whether the gesture system remains intact after language impairment and how PWA use gestures to improve communication. A likely source for the contradicting results is that many studies were conducted on individual cases or in heterogeneous groups of individuals with additional cognitive deficits such as conceptual impairment and comorbid conditions such as limb apraxia. Aims: The goal of the current study was to evaluate the integrity and function of gestures in PWA in light of cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship. Since all such theories presuppose the integrity of the conceptual system, and the absence of comorbid conditions that selectively impair gesturing (i.e., limb apraxia), our sample was selected to fulfill these assumptions. Methods & Procedures: We examined gesture production in eight PWA with preserved auditory comprehension, no comorbidities, and various degrees of expressive deficit, as well as 11 age- and education-matched controls, while they described events in 20 normed video clips. Both speech and gesture data were coded for quantitative measures of informativeness, and gestures were grouped into several functional categories (matching, complementary, compensatory, social cueing, and facilitating lexical retrieval) based on correspondence to the accompanying speech. Using rigorous group analyses, individual-case analyses, and analyses of individual differences, we provide converging evidence for the integrity and type of function(s) served by gesturing in PWA. Outcomes & Results: Our results indicate that the gesture system can remain functional even when language production is severely impaired. Our PWA heavily relied on iconic gestures to compensate for their language impairment, and the degree of such compensation was correlated with the extent of language impairment. In addition, we found evidence that producing iconic gestures was related to higher success rates in resolving lexical retrieval difficulties. Conclusions: When comprehension and comorbidities are controlled for, impairment of language and gesture systems is dissociable. In PWA with good comprehension, gesturing can provide an excellent means to both compensate for the impaired language and act as a retrieval cue. Implications for cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship and therapy are discussed.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1-26
Number of pages26
JournalAphasiology
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Nov 16 2017

Fingerprint

Gestures
Aphasia
speech disorder
integrity
Language
language
Apraxias
comprehension
cognitive theory
comorbidity
Integrity
Gesture
Comorbidity
deficit
Extremities
Communication
verbal communication
video clip
Surgical Instruments
Individuality

Keywords

  • Aphasia
  • gesture
  • Interface Model
  • Lexical Facilitation Model

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Otorhinolaryngology
  • Language and Linguistics
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology
  • Linguistics and Language
  • Neurology
  • Clinical Neurology
  • LPN and LVN

Cite this

Akhavan, N., Göksun, T., & Nozari, N. (Accepted/In press). Integrity and function of gestures in aphasia. Aphasiology, 1-26. https://doi.org/10.1080/02687038.2017.1396573

Integrity and function of gestures in aphasia. / Akhavan, Niloofar; Göksun, Tilbe; Nozari, Nazbanou.

In: Aphasiology, 16.11.2017, p. 1-26.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Akhavan, Niloofar ; Göksun, Tilbe ; Nozari, Nazbanou. / Integrity and function of gestures in aphasia. In: Aphasiology. 2017 ; pp. 1-26.
@article{02e2987f70a04fbb9f1f1f2d956e7e53,
title = "Integrity and function of gestures in aphasia",
abstract = "Background: Gestures can provide an excellent natural alternative to verbal communication in people with aphasia (PWA). However, despite numerous studies focusing on gesture production in aphasia, it is still a matter of debate whether the gesture system remains intact after language impairment and how PWA use gestures to improve communication. A likely source for the contradicting results is that many studies were conducted on individual cases or in heterogeneous groups of individuals with additional cognitive deficits such as conceptual impairment and comorbid conditions such as limb apraxia. Aims: The goal of the current study was to evaluate the integrity and function of gestures in PWA in light of cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship. Since all such theories presuppose the integrity of the conceptual system, and the absence of comorbid conditions that selectively impair gesturing (i.e., limb apraxia), our sample was selected to fulfill these assumptions. Methods & Procedures: We examined gesture production in eight PWA with preserved auditory comprehension, no comorbidities, and various degrees of expressive deficit, as well as 11 age- and education-matched controls, while they described events in 20 normed video clips. Both speech and gesture data were coded for quantitative measures of informativeness, and gestures were grouped into several functional categories (matching, complementary, compensatory, social cueing, and facilitating lexical retrieval) based on correspondence to the accompanying speech. Using rigorous group analyses, individual-case analyses, and analyses of individual differences, we provide converging evidence for the integrity and type of function(s) served by gesturing in PWA. Outcomes & Results: Our results indicate that the gesture system can remain functional even when language production is severely impaired. Our PWA heavily relied on iconic gestures to compensate for their language impairment, and the degree of such compensation was correlated with the extent of language impairment. In addition, we found evidence that producing iconic gestures was related to higher success rates in resolving lexical retrieval difficulties. Conclusions: When comprehension and comorbidities are controlled for, impairment of language and gesture systems is dissociable. In PWA with good comprehension, gesturing can provide an excellent means to both compensate for the impaired language and act as a retrieval cue. Implications for cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship and therapy are discussed.",
keywords = "Aphasia, gesture, Interface Model, Lexical Facilitation Model",
author = "Niloofar Akhavan and Tilbe G{\"o}ksun and Nazbanou Nozari",
year = "2017",
month = "11",
day = "16",
doi = "10.1080/02687038.2017.1396573",
language = "English (US)",
pages = "1--26",
journal = "Aphasiology",
issn = "0268-7038",
publisher = "Psychology Press Ltd",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Integrity and function of gestures in aphasia

AU - Akhavan, Niloofar

AU - Göksun, Tilbe

AU - Nozari, Nazbanou

PY - 2017/11/16

Y1 - 2017/11/16

N2 - Background: Gestures can provide an excellent natural alternative to verbal communication in people with aphasia (PWA). However, despite numerous studies focusing on gesture production in aphasia, it is still a matter of debate whether the gesture system remains intact after language impairment and how PWA use gestures to improve communication. A likely source for the contradicting results is that many studies were conducted on individual cases or in heterogeneous groups of individuals with additional cognitive deficits such as conceptual impairment and comorbid conditions such as limb apraxia. Aims: The goal of the current study was to evaluate the integrity and function of gestures in PWA in light of cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship. Since all such theories presuppose the integrity of the conceptual system, and the absence of comorbid conditions that selectively impair gesturing (i.e., limb apraxia), our sample was selected to fulfill these assumptions. Methods & Procedures: We examined gesture production in eight PWA with preserved auditory comprehension, no comorbidities, and various degrees of expressive deficit, as well as 11 age- and education-matched controls, while they described events in 20 normed video clips. Both speech and gesture data were coded for quantitative measures of informativeness, and gestures were grouped into several functional categories (matching, complementary, compensatory, social cueing, and facilitating lexical retrieval) based on correspondence to the accompanying speech. Using rigorous group analyses, individual-case analyses, and analyses of individual differences, we provide converging evidence for the integrity and type of function(s) served by gesturing in PWA. Outcomes & Results: Our results indicate that the gesture system can remain functional even when language production is severely impaired. Our PWA heavily relied on iconic gestures to compensate for their language impairment, and the degree of such compensation was correlated with the extent of language impairment. In addition, we found evidence that producing iconic gestures was related to higher success rates in resolving lexical retrieval difficulties. Conclusions: When comprehension and comorbidities are controlled for, impairment of language and gesture systems is dissociable. In PWA with good comprehension, gesturing can provide an excellent means to both compensate for the impaired language and act as a retrieval cue. Implications for cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship and therapy are discussed.

AB - Background: Gestures can provide an excellent natural alternative to verbal communication in people with aphasia (PWA). However, despite numerous studies focusing on gesture production in aphasia, it is still a matter of debate whether the gesture system remains intact after language impairment and how PWA use gestures to improve communication. A likely source for the contradicting results is that many studies were conducted on individual cases or in heterogeneous groups of individuals with additional cognitive deficits such as conceptual impairment and comorbid conditions such as limb apraxia. Aims: The goal of the current study was to evaluate the integrity and function of gestures in PWA in light of cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship. Since all such theories presuppose the integrity of the conceptual system, and the absence of comorbid conditions that selectively impair gesturing (i.e., limb apraxia), our sample was selected to fulfill these assumptions. Methods & Procedures: We examined gesture production in eight PWA with preserved auditory comprehension, no comorbidities, and various degrees of expressive deficit, as well as 11 age- and education-matched controls, while they described events in 20 normed video clips. Both speech and gesture data were coded for quantitative measures of informativeness, and gestures were grouped into several functional categories (matching, complementary, compensatory, social cueing, and facilitating lexical retrieval) based on correspondence to the accompanying speech. Using rigorous group analyses, individual-case analyses, and analyses of individual differences, we provide converging evidence for the integrity and type of function(s) served by gesturing in PWA. Outcomes & Results: Our results indicate that the gesture system can remain functional even when language production is severely impaired. Our PWA heavily relied on iconic gestures to compensate for their language impairment, and the degree of such compensation was correlated with the extent of language impairment. In addition, we found evidence that producing iconic gestures was related to higher success rates in resolving lexical retrieval difficulties. Conclusions: When comprehension and comorbidities are controlled for, impairment of language and gesture systems is dissociable. In PWA with good comprehension, gesturing can provide an excellent means to both compensate for the impaired language and act as a retrieval cue. Implications for cognitive theories of language–gesture relationship and therapy are discussed.

KW - Aphasia

KW - gesture

KW - Interface Model

KW - Lexical Facilitation Model

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85034261711&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85034261711&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/02687038.2017.1396573

DO - 10.1080/02687038.2017.1396573

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85034261711

SP - 1

EP - 26

JO - Aphasiology

JF - Aphasiology

SN - 0268-7038

ER -