High beta and electron dose from 192Ir

implications for "gamma" intravascular brachytherapy.

Neil S. Patel, Sou Tung Chiu-Tsao, Yunsil Ho, Tamara Duckworth, J. Allen Shih, Hung Sheng Tsao, Harry Quon, Louis B. Harrison

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

PURPOSE: Trains of multiple 192Ir seeds are used in many clinical trials for intravascular brachytherapy. 192Ir source is commonly considered as a gamma emitter, despite the understanding that this radionuclide also emits a wide range of electron and beta energies, with a similar range of energy. The high dose from betas and electrons in the submillimeter range due to unsealed ends of seed sources should be precisely quantified to fully understand the backdrop for complications associated with 192Ir coronary artery brachytherapy. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Monte Carlo simulations (MCNP4C code) were performed for a model 5-seed 192Ir train used in SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and the Washington Radiation for In-Stent Restenosis (WRIST) randomized clinical trials. A stack of radiochromic films was also used to measure the dose distributions for an actual 6-seed train. RESULTS: In the submillimeter range very close to the source, Monte Carlo results show that betas and electrons deposit a higher dose than 192Ir photons (gamma and X-rays) over the interseed gap. A high luminal dose from the combined effects of betas, electrons, and photons emitted from 192Ir can be deposited, particularly between seeds. When prescribing 15 Gy at 2 mm, the combined dose can be as high as 160 Gy at 0.5 mm. Different peak doses near the interseed gaps were noted, which may be due to variability of seed-end surfaces and nonuniformity of seed activity within a real multiseed train. Dose-volume histograms (DVH) of lumen surfaces were evaluated for an eccentric seed train. The DVH parameters indicating the extent of hot spots in the lumen wall, DV(10), DV(5), DV(2), and DV(1) (dose received by 10, 5, 2, 1% respectively of the total lumen surface), can be as high as 55, 76, 81, and 155 Gy for a lumen with 3-mm diameter, and 75, 80, 110, and 158 Gy for a narrow 2-mm lumen. CONCLUSION: 192Ir multiple seed trains used in the SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and WRIST trials can deposit a very high dose to the luminal wall. A particularly high electron and beta dose can be delivered near the interseed gap if the source is not centered in the catheter and lumen. The dose from 192Ir betas and electrons may partially explain adverse outcomes reported from 192Ir multiseed clinical trials. Improvement of the encapsulation design to filter out the betas and electrons should be seriously considered.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)972-980
Number of pages9
JournalInternational Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics
Volume54
Issue number3
StatePublished - Nov 1 2002
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Brachytherapy
Seeds
Electrons
seeds
dosage
lumens
electrons
Photons
Stents
histograms
Clinical Trials
Radiation
Gamma Rays
deposits
Radioisotopes
Coronary Vessels
eccentrics
photons
radiation
Catheters

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Oncology
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging
  • Radiation

Cite this

Patel, N. S., Chiu-Tsao, S. T., Ho, Y., Duckworth, T., Shih, J. A., Tsao, H. S., ... Harrison, L. B. (2002). High beta and electron dose from 192Ir: implications for "gamma" intravascular brachytherapy. International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics, 54(3), 972-980.

High beta and electron dose from 192Ir : implications for "gamma" intravascular brachytherapy. / Patel, Neil S.; Chiu-Tsao, Sou Tung; Ho, Yunsil; Duckworth, Tamara; Shih, J. Allen; Tsao, Hung Sheng; Quon, Harry; Harrison, Louis B.

In: International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics, Vol. 54, No. 3, 01.11.2002, p. 972-980.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Patel, NS, Chiu-Tsao, ST, Ho, Y, Duckworth, T, Shih, JA, Tsao, HS, Quon, H & Harrison, LB 2002, 'High beta and electron dose from 192Ir: implications for "gamma" intravascular brachytherapy.', International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics, vol. 54, no. 3, pp. 972-980.
Patel, Neil S. ; Chiu-Tsao, Sou Tung ; Ho, Yunsil ; Duckworth, Tamara ; Shih, J. Allen ; Tsao, Hung Sheng ; Quon, Harry ; Harrison, Louis B. / High beta and electron dose from 192Ir : implications for "gamma" intravascular brachytherapy. In: International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics. 2002 ; Vol. 54, No. 3. pp. 972-980.
@article{4f02d98271e64bfc8bd3467efb4faefd,
title = "High beta and electron dose from 192Ir: implications for {"}gamma{"} intravascular brachytherapy.",
abstract = "PURPOSE: Trains of multiple 192Ir seeds are used in many clinical trials for intravascular brachytherapy. 192Ir source is commonly considered as a gamma emitter, despite the understanding that this radionuclide also emits a wide range of electron and beta energies, with a similar range of energy. The high dose from betas and electrons in the submillimeter range due to unsealed ends of seed sources should be precisely quantified to fully understand the backdrop for complications associated with 192Ir coronary artery brachytherapy. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Monte Carlo simulations (MCNP4C code) were performed for a model 5-seed 192Ir train used in SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and the Washington Radiation for In-Stent Restenosis (WRIST) randomized clinical trials. A stack of radiochromic films was also used to measure the dose distributions for an actual 6-seed train. RESULTS: In the submillimeter range very close to the source, Monte Carlo results show that betas and electrons deposit a higher dose than 192Ir photons (gamma and X-rays) over the interseed gap. A high luminal dose from the combined effects of betas, electrons, and photons emitted from 192Ir can be deposited, particularly between seeds. When prescribing 15 Gy at 2 mm, the combined dose can be as high as 160 Gy at 0.5 mm. Different peak doses near the interseed gaps were noted, which may be due to variability of seed-end surfaces and nonuniformity of seed activity within a real multiseed train. Dose-volume histograms (DVH) of lumen surfaces were evaluated for an eccentric seed train. The DVH parameters indicating the extent of hot spots in the lumen wall, DV(10), DV(5), DV(2), and DV(1) (dose received by 10, 5, 2, 1{\%} respectively of the total lumen surface), can be as high as 55, 76, 81, and 155 Gy for a lumen with 3-mm diameter, and 75, 80, 110, and 158 Gy for a narrow 2-mm lumen. CONCLUSION: 192Ir multiple seed trains used in the SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and WRIST trials can deposit a very high dose to the luminal wall. A particularly high electron and beta dose can be delivered near the interseed gap if the source is not centered in the catheter and lumen. The dose from 192Ir betas and electrons may partially explain adverse outcomes reported from 192Ir multiseed clinical trials. Improvement of the encapsulation design to filter out the betas and electrons should be seriously considered.",
author = "Patel, {Neil S.} and Chiu-Tsao, {Sou Tung} and Yunsil Ho and Tamara Duckworth and Shih, {J. Allen} and Tsao, {Hung Sheng} and Harry Quon and Harrison, {Louis B.}",
year = "2002",
month = "11",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "54",
pages = "972--980",
journal = "International Journal of Radiation Oncology Biology Physics",
issn = "0360-3016",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - High beta and electron dose from 192Ir

T2 - implications for "gamma" intravascular brachytherapy.

AU - Patel, Neil S.

AU - Chiu-Tsao, Sou Tung

AU - Ho, Yunsil

AU - Duckworth, Tamara

AU - Shih, J. Allen

AU - Tsao, Hung Sheng

AU - Quon, Harry

AU - Harrison, Louis B.

PY - 2002/11/1

Y1 - 2002/11/1

N2 - PURPOSE: Trains of multiple 192Ir seeds are used in many clinical trials for intravascular brachytherapy. 192Ir source is commonly considered as a gamma emitter, despite the understanding that this radionuclide also emits a wide range of electron and beta energies, with a similar range of energy. The high dose from betas and electrons in the submillimeter range due to unsealed ends of seed sources should be precisely quantified to fully understand the backdrop for complications associated with 192Ir coronary artery brachytherapy. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Monte Carlo simulations (MCNP4C code) were performed for a model 5-seed 192Ir train used in SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and the Washington Radiation for In-Stent Restenosis (WRIST) randomized clinical trials. A stack of radiochromic films was also used to measure the dose distributions for an actual 6-seed train. RESULTS: In the submillimeter range very close to the source, Monte Carlo results show that betas and electrons deposit a higher dose than 192Ir photons (gamma and X-rays) over the interseed gap. A high luminal dose from the combined effects of betas, electrons, and photons emitted from 192Ir can be deposited, particularly between seeds. When prescribing 15 Gy at 2 mm, the combined dose can be as high as 160 Gy at 0.5 mm. Different peak doses near the interseed gaps were noted, which may be due to variability of seed-end surfaces and nonuniformity of seed activity within a real multiseed train. Dose-volume histograms (DVH) of lumen surfaces were evaluated for an eccentric seed train. The DVH parameters indicating the extent of hot spots in the lumen wall, DV(10), DV(5), DV(2), and DV(1) (dose received by 10, 5, 2, 1% respectively of the total lumen surface), can be as high as 55, 76, 81, and 155 Gy for a lumen with 3-mm diameter, and 75, 80, 110, and 158 Gy for a narrow 2-mm lumen. CONCLUSION: 192Ir multiple seed trains used in the SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and WRIST trials can deposit a very high dose to the luminal wall. A particularly high electron and beta dose can be delivered near the interseed gap if the source is not centered in the catheter and lumen. The dose from 192Ir betas and electrons may partially explain adverse outcomes reported from 192Ir multiseed clinical trials. Improvement of the encapsulation design to filter out the betas and electrons should be seriously considered.

AB - PURPOSE: Trains of multiple 192Ir seeds are used in many clinical trials for intravascular brachytherapy. 192Ir source is commonly considered as a gamma emitter, despite the understanding that this radionuclide also emits a wide range of electron and beta energies, with a similar range of energy. The high dose from betas and electrons in the submillimeter range due to unsealed ends of seed sources should be precisely quantified to fully understand the backdrop for complications associated with 192Ir coronary artery brachytherapy. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Monte Carlo simulations (MCNP4C code) were performed for a model 5-seed 192Ir train used in SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and the Washington Radiation for In-Stent Restenosis (WRIST) randomized clinical trials. A stack of radiochromic films was also used to measure the dose distributions for an actual 6-seed train. RESULTS: In the submillimeter range very close to the source, Monte Carlo results show that betas and electrons deposit a higher dose than 192Ir photons (gamma and X-rays) over the interseed gap. A high luminal dose from the combined effects of betas, electrons, and photons emitted from 192Ir can be deposited, particularly between seeds. When prescribing 15 Gy at 2 mm, the combined dose can be as high as 160 Gy at 0.5 mm. Different peak doses near the interseed gaps were noted, which may be due to variability of seed-end surfaces and nonuniformity of seed activity within a real multiseed train. Dose-volume histograms (DVH) of lumen surfaces were evaluated for an eccentric seed train. The DVH parameters indicating the extent of hot spots in the lumen wall, DV(10), DV(5), DV(2), and DV(1) (dose received by 10, 5, 2, 1% respectively of the total lumen surface), can be as high as 55, 76, 81, and 155 Gy for a lumen with 3-mm diameter, and 75, 80, 110, and 158 Gy for a narrow 2-mm lumen. CONCLUSION: 192Ir multiple seed trains used in the SCRIPPS, GAMMA, and WRIST trials can deposit a very high dose to the luminal wall. A particularly high electron and beta dose can be delivered near the interseed gap if the source is not centered in the catheter and lumen. The dose from 192Ir betas and electrons may partially explain adverse outcomes reported from 192Ir multiseed clinical trials. Improvement of the encapsulation design to filter out the betas and electrons should be seriously considered.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0036833880&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0036833880&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 54

SP - 972

EP - 980

JO - International Journal of Radiation Oncology Biology Physics

JF - International Journal of Radiation Oncology Biology Physics

SN - 0360-3016

IS - 3

ER -