Generalized whole-body Patlak parametric imaging for enhanced quantification in clinical PET

Nicolas A. Karakatsanis, Yun Zhou, Martin Lodge, Michael E. Casey, Richard L. Wahl, Habib Zaidi, Arman Rahmim

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

We recently developed a dynamic multi-bed PET data acquisition framework to translate the quantitative benefits of Patlak voxel-wise analysis to the domain of routine clinical whole-body (WB) imaging. The standard Patlak (sPatlak) linear graphical analysis assumes irreversible PET tracer uptake, ignoring the effect of FDG dephosphorylation, which has been suggested by a number of PET studies. In this work: (i) a non-linear generalized Patlak (gPatlak) model is utilized, including a net efflux rate constant kloss, and (ii) a hybrid (s/g)Patlak (hPatlak) imaging technique is introduced to enhance contrast to noise ratios (CNRs) of uptake rate Ki images. Representative set of kinetic parameter values and the XCAT phantom were employed to generate realistic 4D simulation PET data, and the proposed methods were additionally evaluated on 11 WB dynamic PET patient studies. Quantitative analysis on the simulated Ki images over 2 groups of regions-of-interest (ROIs), with low (ROI A) or high (ROI B) true kloss relative to Ki, suggested superior accuracy for gPatlak. Bias of sPatlak was found to be 16-18% and 20-40% poorer than gPatlak for ROIs A and B, respectively. By contrast, gPatlak exhibited, on average, 10% higher noise than sPatlak. Meanwhile, the bias and noise levels for hPatlak always ranged between the other two methods. In general, hPatlak was seen to outperform all methods in terms of target-to-background ratio (TBR) and CNR for all ROIs. Validation on patient datasets demonstrated clinical feasibility for all Patlak methods, while TBR and CNR evaluations confirmed our simulation findings, and suggested presence of non-negligible kloss reversibility in clinical data. As such, we recommend gPatlak for highly quantitative imaging tasks, while, for tasks emphasizing lesion detectability (e.g. TBR, CNR) over quantification, or for high levels of noise, hPatlak is instead preferred. Finally, gPatlak and hPatlak CNR was systematically higher compared to routine SUV values.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)8643-8673
Number of pages31
JournalPhysics in Medicine and Biology
Volume60
Issue number22
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 28 2015

Fingerprint

Noise
Whole Body Imaging
Public Opinion

Keywords

  • detectability
  • generalized
  • parametric
  • Patlak
  • PET
  • quantification
  • whole-body

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging
  • Radiological and Ultrasound Technology

Cite this

Generalized whole-body Patlak parametric imaging for enhanced quantification in clinical PET. / Karakatsanis, Nicolas A.; Zhou, Yun; Lodge, Martin; Casey, Michael E.; Wahl, Richard L.; Zaidi, Habib; Rahmim, Arman.

In: Physics in Medicine and Biology, Vol. 60, No. 22, 28.10.2015, p. 8643-8673.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Karakatsanis, Nicolas A. ; Zhou, Yun ; Lodge, Martin ; Casey, Michael E. ; Wahl, Richard L. ; Zaidi, Habib ; Rahmim, Arman. / Generalized whole-body Patlak parametric imaging for enhanced quantification in clinical PET. In: Physics in Medicine and Biology. 2015 ; Vol. 60, No. 22. pp. 8643-8673.
@article{38a0ab9e6878401d8ae00a1eb8f7e95a,
title = "Generalized whole-body Patlak parametric imaging for enhanced quantification in clinical PET",
abstract = "We recently developed a dynamic multi-bed PET data acquisition framework to translate the quantitative benefits of Patlak voxel-wise analysis to the domain of routine clinical whole-body (WB) imaging. The standard Patlak (sPatlak) linear graphical analysis assumes irreversible PET tracer uptake, ignoring the effect of FDG dephosphorylation, which has been suggested by a number of PET studies. In this work: (i) a non-linear generalized Patlak (gPatlak) model is utilized, including a net efflux rate constant kloss, and (ii) a hybrid (s/g)Patlak (hPatlak) imaging technique is introduced to enhance contrast to noise ratios (CNRs) of uptake rate Ki images. Representative set of kinetic parameter values and the XCAT phantom were employed to generate realistic 4D simulation PET data, and the proposed methods were additionally evaluated on 11 WB dynamic PET patient studies. Quantitative analysis on the simulated Ki images over 2 groups of regions-of-interest (ROIs), with low (ROI A) or high (ROI B) true kloss relative to Ki, suggested superior accuracy for gPatlak. Bias of sPatlak was found to be 16-18{\%} and 20-40{\%} poorer than gPatlak for ROIs A and B, respectively. By contrast, gPatlak exhibited, on average, 10{\%} higher noise than sPatlak. Meanwhile, the bias and noise levels for hPatlak always ranged between the other two methods. In general, hPatlak was seen to outperform all methods in terms of target-to-background ratio (TBR) and CNR for all ROIs. Validation on patient datasets demonstrated clinical feasibility for all Patlak methods, while TBR and CNR evaluations confirmed our simulation findings, and suggested presence of non-negligible kloss reversibility in clinical data. As such, we recommend gPatlak for highly quantitative imaging tasks, while, for tasks emphasizing lesion detectability (e.g. TBR, CNR) over quantification, or for high levels of noise, hPatlak is instead preferred. Finally, gPatlak and hPatlak CNR was systematically higher compared to routine SUV values.",
keywords = "detectability, generalized, parametric, Patlak, PET, quantification, whole-body",
author = "Karakatsanis, {Nicolas A.} and Yun Zhou and Martin Lodge and Casey, {Michael E.} and Wahl, {Richard L.} and Habib Zaidi and Arman Rahmim",
year = "2015",
month = "10",
day = "28",
doi = "10.1088/0031-9155/60/22/8643",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "60",
pages = "8643--8673",
journal = "Physics in Medicine and Biology",
issn = "0031-9155",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "22",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Generalized whole-body Patlak parametric imaging for enhanced quantification in clinical PET

AU - Karakatsanis, Nicolas A.

AU - Zhou, Yun

AU - Lodge, Martin

AU - Casey, Michael E.

AU - Wahl, Richard L.

AU - Zaidi, Habib

AU - Rahmim, Arman

PY - 2015/10/28

Y1 - 2015/10/28

N2 - We recently developed a dynamic multi-bed PET data acquisition framework to translate the quantitative benefits of Patlak voxel-wise analysis to the domain of routine clinical whole-body (WB) imaging. The standard Patlak (sPatlak) linear graphical analysis assumes irreversible PET tracer uptake, ignoring the effect of FDG dephosphorylation, which has been suggested by a number of PET studies. In this work: (i) a non-linear generalized Patlak (gPatlak) model is utilized, including a net efflux rate constant kloss, and (ii) a hybrid (s/g)Patlak (hPatlak) imaging technique is introduced to enhance contrast to noise ratios (CNRs) of uptake rate Ki images. Representative set of kinetic parameter values and the XCAT phantom were employed to generate realistic 4D simulation PET data, and the proposed methods were additionally evaluated on 11 WB dynamic PET patient studies. Quantitative analysis on the simulated Ki images over 2 groups of regions-of-interest (ROIs), with low (ROI A) or high (ROI B) true kloss relative to Ki, suggested superior accuracy for gPatlak. Bias of sPatlak was found to be 16-18% and 20-40% poorer than gPatlak for ROIs A and B, respectively. By contrast, gPatlak exhibited, on average, 10% higher noise than sPatlak. Meanwhile, the bias and noise levels for hPatlak always ranged between the other two methods. In general, hPatlak was seen to outperform all methods in terms of target-to-background ratio (TBR) and CNR for all ROIs. Validation on patient datasets demonstrated clinical feasibility for all Patlak methods, while TBR and CNR evaluations confirmed our simulation findings, and suggested presence of non-negligible kloss reversibility in clinical data. As such, we recommend gPatlak for highly quantitative imaging tasks, while, for tasks emphasizing lesion detectability (e.g. TBR, CNR) over quantification, or for high levels of noise, hPatlak is instead preferred. Finally, gPatlak and hPatlak CNR was systematically higher compared to routine SUV values.

AB - We recently developed a dynamic multi-bed PET data acquisition framework to translate the quantitative benefits of Patlak voxel-wise analysis to the domain of routine clinical whole-body (WB) imaging. The standard Patlak (sPatlak) linear graphical analysis assumes irreversible PET tracer uptake, ignoring the effect of FDG dephosphorylation, which has been suggested by a number of PET studies. In this work: (i) a non-linear generalized Patlak (gPatlak) model is utilized, including a net efflux rate constant kloss, and (ii) a hybrid (s/g)Patlak (hPatlak) imaging technique is introduced to enhance contrast to noise ratios (CNRs) of uptake rate Ki images. Representative set of kinetic parameter values and the XCAT phantom were employed to generate realistic 4D simulation PET data, and the proposed methods were additionally evaluated on 11 WB dynamic PET patient studies. Quantitative analysis on the simulated Ki images over 2 groups of regions-of-interest (ROIs), with low (ROI A) or high (ROI B) true kloss relative to Ki, suggested superior accuracy for gPatlak. Bias of sPatlak was found to be 16-18% and 20-40% poorer than gPatlak for ROIs A and B, respectively. By contrast, gPatlak exhibited, on average, 10% higher noise than sPatlak. Meanwhile, the bias and noise levels for hPatlak always ranged between the other two methods. In general, hPatlak was seen to outperform all methods in terms of target-to-background ratio (TBR) and CNR for all ROIs. Validation on patient datasets demonstrated clinical feasibility for all Patlak methods, while TBR and CNR evaluations confirmed our simulation findings, and suggested presence of non-negligible kloss reversibility in clinical data. As such, we recommend gPatlak for highly quantitative imaging tasks, while, for tasks emphasizing lesion detectability (e.g. TBR, CNR) over quantification, or for high levels of noise, hPatlak is instead preferred. Finally, gPatlak and hPatlak CNR was systematically higher compared to routine SUV values.

KW - detectability

KW - generalized

KW - parametric

KW - Patlak

KW - PET

KW - quantification

KW - whole-body

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84947093683&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84947093683&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1088/0031-9155/60/22/8643

DO - 10.1088/0031-9155/60/22/8643

M3 - Article

C2 - 26509251

AN - SCOPUS:84947093683

VL - 60

SP - 8643

EP - 8673

JO - Physics in Medicine and Biology

JF - Physics in Medicine and Biology

SN - 0031-9155

IS - 22

ER -