Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke

A longitudinal study

Naveed Ejaz, Jing Xu, Meret Branscheidt, Benjamin Hertler, Heidi Schambra, Mario Widmer, Andreia Vasconcellos Faria, Michelle D. Harran, Juan C. Cortes, Nathan Kim, Pablo A Celnik, Tomoko Kitago, Andreas R. Luft, John Krakauer, Jörn Diedrichsen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Following a stroke, mirror movements are unintended movements that appear in the non-paretic hand when the paretic hand voluntarily moves. Mirror movements have previously been linked to overactivation of sensorimotor areas in the non-lesioned hemisphere. In this study, we hypothesized that mirror movements might instead have a subcortical origin, and are the by-product of subcortical motor pathways upregulating their contributions to the paretic hand. To test this idea, we first characterized the time course of mirroring in 53 first-time stroke patients, and compared it to the time course of activities in sensorimotor areas of the lesioned and non-lesioned hemispheres (measured using functional MRI). Mirroring in the non-paretic hand was exaggerated early after stroke (Week 2), but progressively diminished over the year with a time course that parallelled individuation deficits in the paretic hand. We found no evidence of cortical overactivation that could explain the time course changes in behaviour, contrary to the cortical model of mirroring. Consistent with a subcortical origin of mirroring, we predicted that subcortical contributions should broadly recruit fingers in the non-paretic hand, reflecting the limited capacity of subcortical pathways in providing individuated finger control. We therefore characterized finger recruitment patterns in the non-paretic hand during mirroring. During mirroring, non-paretic fingers were broadly recruited, with mirrored forces in homologous fingers being only slightly larger (1.76 times) than those in non-homologous fingers. Throughout recovery, the pattern of finger recruitment during mirroring for patients looked like a scaled version of the corresponding control mirroring pattern, suggesting that the system that is responsible for mirroring in controls is upregulated after stroke. Together, our results suggest that post-stroke mirror movements in the non-paretic hand, like enslaved movements in the paretic hand, are caused by the upregulation of a bilaterally organized subcortical system.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)837-847
Number of pages11
JournalBrain
Volume141
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2018

Fingerprint

Longitudinal Studies
Hand
Stroke
Fingers
Individuation
Efferent Pathways
Up-Regulation
Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Keywords

  • Corticospinal
  • Mirror movements
  • Recovery
  • Reticulospinal
  • Stroke

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology

Cite this

Ejaz, N., Xu, J., Branscheidt, M., Hertler, B., Schambra, H., Widmer, M., ... Diedrichsen, J. (2018). Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke: A longitudinal study. Brain, 141(3), 837-847. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awx384

Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke : A longitudinal study. / Ejaz, Naveed; Xu, Jing; Branscheidt, Meret; Hertler, Benjamin; Schambra, Heidi; Widmer, Mario; Faria, Andreia Vasconcellos; Harran, Michelle D.; Cortes, Juan C.; Kim, Nathan; Celnik, Pablo A; Kitago, Tomoko; Luft, Andreas R.; Krakauer, John; Diedrichsen, Jörn.

In: Brain, Vol. 141, No. 3, 01.03.2018, p. 837-847.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ejaz, N, Xu, J, Branscheidt, M, Hertler, B, Schambra, H, Widmer, M, Faria, AV, Harran, MD, Cortes, JC, Kim, N, Celnik, PA, Kitago, T, Luft, AR, Krakauer, J & Diedrichsen, J 2018, 'Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke: A longitudinal study', Brain, vol. 141, no. 3, pp. 837-847. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awx384
Ejaz N, Xu J, Branscheidt M, Hertler B, Schambra H, Widmer M et al. Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke: A longitudinal study. Brain. 2018 Mar 1;141(3):837-847. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awx384
Ejaz, Naveed ; Xu, Jing ; Branscheidt, Meret ; Hertler, Benjamin ; Schambra, Heidi ; Widmer, Mario ; Faria, Andreia Vasconcellos ; Harran, Michelle D. ; Cortes, Juan C. ; Kim, Nathan ; Celnik, Pablo A ; Kitago, Tomoko ; Luft, Andreas R. ; Krakauer, John ; Diedrichsen, Jörn. / Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke : A longitudinal study. In: Brain. 2018 ; Vol. 141, No. 3. pp. 837-847.
@article{8068a24cea8846499e2e63c455cc9a03,
title = "Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke: A longitudinal study",
abstract = "Following a stroke, mirror movements are unintended movements that appear in the non-paretic hand when the paretic hand voluntarily moves. Mirror movements have previously been linked to overactivation of sensorimotor areas in the non-lesioned hemisphere. In this study, we hypothesized that mirror movements might instead have a subcortical origin, and are the by-product of subcortical motor pathways upregulating their contributions to the paretic hand. To test this idea, we first characterized the time course of mirroring in 53 first-time stroke patients, and compared it to the time course of activities in sensorimotor areas of the lesioned and non-lesioned hemispheres (measured using functional MRI). Mirroring in the non-paretic hand was exaggerated early after stroke (Week 2), but progressively diminished over the year with a time course that parallelled individuation deficits in the paretic hand. We found no evidence of cortical overactivation that could explain the time course changes in behaviour, contrary to the cortical model of mirroring. Consistent with a subcortical origin of mirroring, we predicted that subcortical contributions should broadly recruit fingers in the non-paretic hand, reflecting the limited capacity of subcortical pathways in providing individuated finger control. We therefore characterized finger recruitment patterns in the non-paretic hand during mirroring. During mirroring, non-paretic fingers were broadly recruited, with mirrored forces in homologous fingers being only slightly larger (1.76 times) than those in non-homologous fingers. Throughout recovery, the pattern of finger recruitment during mirroring for patients looked like a scaled version of the corresponding control mirroring pattern, suggesting that the system that is responsible for mirroring in controls is upregulated after stroke. Together, our results suggest that post-stroke mirror movements in the non-paretic hand, like enslaved movements in the paretic hand, are caused by the upregulation of a bilaterally organized subcortical system.",
keywords = "Corticospinal, Mirror movements, Recovery, Reticulospinal, Stroke",
author = "Naveed Ejaz and Jing Xu and Meret Branscheidt and Benjamin Hertler and Heidi Schambra and Mario Widmer and Faria, {Andreia Vasconcellos} and Harran, {Michelle D.} and Cortes, {Juan C.} and Nathan Kim and Celnik, {Pablo A} and Tomoko Kitago and Luft, {Andreas R.} and John Krakauer and J{\"o}rn Diedrichsen",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1093/brain/awx384",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "141",
pages = "837--847",
journal = "Brain",
issn = "0006-8950",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evidence for a subcortical origin of mirror movements after stroke

T2 - A longitudinal study

AU - Ejaz, Naveed

AU - Xu, Jing

AU - Branscheidt, Meret

AU - Hertler, Benjamin

AU - Schambra, Heidi

AU - Widmer, Mario

AU - Faria, Andreia Vasconcellos

AU - Harran, Michelle D.

AU - Cortes, Juan C.

AU - Kim, Nathan

AU - Celnik, Pablo A

AU - Kitago, Tomoko

AU - Luft, Andreas R.

AU - Krakauer, John

AU - Diedrichsen, Jörn

PY - 2018/3/1

Y1 - 2018/3/1

N2 - Following a stroke, mirror movements are unintended movements that appear in the non-paretic hand when the paretic hand voluntarily moves. Mirror movements have previously been linked to overactivation of sensorimotor areas in the non-lesioned hemisphere. In this study, we hypothesized that mirror movements might instead have a subcortical origin, and are the by-product of subcortical motor pathways upregulating their contributions to the paretic hand. To test this idea, we first characterized the time course of mirroring in 53 first-time stroke patients, and compared it to the time course of activities in sensorimotor areas of the lesioned and non-lesioned hemispheres (measured using functional MRI). Mirroring in the non-paretic hand was exaggerated early after stroke (Week 2), but progressively diminished over the year with a time course that parallelled individuation deficits in the paretic hand. We found no evidence of cortical overactivation that could explain the time course changes in behaviour, contrary to the cortical model of mirroring. Consistent with a subcortical origin of mirroring, we predicted that subcortical contributions should broadly recruit fingers in the non-paretic hand, reflecting the limited capacity of subcortical pathways in providing individuated finger control. We therefore characterized finger recruitment patterns in the non-paretic hand during mirroring. During mirroring, non-paretic fingers were broadly recruited, with mirrored forces in homologous fingers being only slightly larger (1.76 times) than those in non-homologous fingers. Throughout recovery, the pattern of finger recruitment during mirroring for patients looked like a scaled version of the corresponding control mirroring pattern, suggesting that the system that is responsible for mirroring in controls is upregulated after stroke. Together, our results suggest that post-stroke mirror movements in the non-paretic hand, like enslaved movements in the paretic hand, are caused by the upregulation of a bilaterally organized subcortical system.

AB - Following a stroke, mirror movements are unintended movements that appear in the non-paretic hand when the paretic hand voluntarily moves. Mirror movements have previously been linked to overactivation of sensorimotor areas in the non-lesioned hemisphere. In this study, we hypothesized that mirror movements might instead have a subcortical origin, and are the by-product of subcortical motor pathways upregulating their contributions to the paretic hand. To test this idea, we first characterized the time course of mirroring in 53 first-time stroke patients, and compared it to the time course of activities in sensorimotor areas of the lesioned and non-lesioned hemispheres (measured using functional MRI). Mirroring in the non-paretic hand was exaggerated early after stroke (Week 2), but progressively diminished over the year with a time course that parallelled individuation deficits in the paretic hand. We found no evidence of cortical overactivation that could explain the time course changes in behaviour, contrary to the cortical model of mirroring. Consistent with a subcortical origin of mirroring, we predicted that subcortical contributions should broadly recruit fingers in the non-paretic hand, reflecting the limited capacity of subcortical pathways in providing individuated finger control. We therefore characterized finger recruitment patterns in the non-paretic hand during mirroring. During mirroring, non-paretic fingers were broadly recruited, with mirrored forces in homologous fingers being only slightly larger (1.76 times) than those in non-homologous fingers. Throughout recovery, the pattern of finger recruitment during mirroring for patients looked like a scaled version of the corresponding control mirroring pattern, suggesting that the system that is responsible for mirroring in controls is upregulated after stroke. Together, our results suggest that post-stroke mirror movements in the non-paretic hand, like enslaved movements in the paretic hand, are caused by the upregulation of a bilaterally organized subcortical system.

KW - Corticospinal

KW - Mirror movements

KW - Recovery

KW - Reticulospinal

KW - Stroke

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85042922317&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85042922317&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1093/brain/awx384

DO - 10.1093/brain/awx384

M3 - Article

VL - 141

SP - 837

EP - 847

JO - Brain

JF - Brain

SN - 0006-8950

IS - 3

ER -