Effects of visual force feedback on robot-assisted surgical task performance

Carol E. Reiley, Takintope Akinbiyi, Darius Burschka, David C. Chang, Allison M. Okamura, David D. Yuh

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective: Direct haptic (force or tactile) feedback is negligible in current surgical robotic systems. The relevance of haptic feedback in robot-assisted performances of surgical tasks is controversial. We studied the effects of visual force feedback, a haptic feedback surrogate, on tying surgical knots with fine sutures similar to those used in cardiovascular surgery. Methods: By using a modified da Vinci robotic system (Intuitive Surgical, Inc, Sunnyvale, Calif) equipped with force-sensing instrument tips and real-time visual force feedback overlays in the console image, 10 surgeons each tied 10 knots with and 10 knots without visual force feedback. Four surgeons had significant prior da Vinci experience, and the remaining 6 surgeons did not. Performance parameters, including suture breakage and secure knots, peak and standard deviation of applied forces, and completion times using 5-0 silk sutures, were recorded. Chi-square and Student t test analyses determined the differences between groups. Results: Among surgeon subjects with robotic experience, no differences in measured performance parameters were found between robot-assisted knot ties executed with and without visual force feedback. Among surgeons without robotic experience, however, visual force feedback was associated with lower suture breakage rates, peak applied forces, and standard deviations of applied forces. Visual force feedback did not impart differences in knot completion times or loose knots for either surgeon group. Conclusions: Visual force feedback resulted in reduced suture breakage, lower forces, and decreased force inconsistencies among novice robotic surgeons, although elapsed time and knot quality were unaffected. In contrast, visual force feedback did not affect these metrics among surgeons experienced with the da Vinci system. These results suggest that visual force feedback primarily benefits novice robot-assisted surgeons, with diminishing benefits among experienced surgeons.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)196-202
Number of pages7
JournalJournal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery
Volume135
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 2008

Fingerprint

Sensory Feedback
Task Performance and Analysis
Robotics
Sutures
Surgeons
Silk
Touch
Students

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cardiology and Cardiovascular Medicine
  • Surgery

Cite this

Reiley, C. E., Akinbiyi, T., Burschka, D., Chang, D. C., Okamura, A. M., & Yuh, D. D. (2008). Effects of visual force feedback on robot-assisted surgical task performance. Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, 135(1), 196-202. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtcvs.2007.08.043

Effects of visual force feedback on robot-assisted surgical task performance. / Reiley, Carol E.; Akinbiyi, Takintope; Burschka, Darius; Chang, David C.; Okamura, Allison M.; Yuh, David D.

In: Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Vol. 135, No. 1, 01.2008, p. 196-202.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Reiley, CE, Akinbiyi, T, Burschka, D, Chang, DC, Okamura, AM & Yuh, DD 2008, 'Effects of visual force feedback on robot-assisted surgical task performance', Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, vol. 135, no. 1, pp. 196-202. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtcvs.2007.08.043
Reiley, Carol E. ; Akinbiyi, Takintope ; Burschka, Darius ; Chang, David C. ; Okamura, Allison M. ; Yuh, David D. / Effects of visual force feedback on robot-assisted surgical task performance. In: Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery. 2008 ; Vol. 135, No. 1. pp. 196-202.
@article{8b9ed64255d54c008a41e5222f5fe89e,
title = "Effects of visual force feedback on robot-assisted surgical task performance",
abstract = "Objective: Direct haptic (force or tactile) feedback is negligible in current surgical robotic systems. The relevance of haptic feedback in robot-assisted performances of surgical tasks is controversial. We studied the effects of visual force feedback, a haptic feedback surrogate, on tying surgical knots with fine sutures similar to those used in cardiovascular surgery. Methods: By using a modified da Vinci robotic system (Intuitive Surgical, Inc, Sunnyvale, Calif) equipped with force-sensing instrument tips and real-time visual force feedback overlays in the console image, 10 surgeons each tied 10 knots with and 10 knots without visual force feedback. Four surgeons had significant prior da Vinci experience, and the remaining 6 surgeons did not. Performance parameters, including suture breakage and secure knots, peak and standard deviation of applied forces, and completion times using 5-0 silk sutures, were recorded. Chi-square and Student t test analyses determined the differences between groups. Results: Among surgeon subjects with robotic experience, no differences in measured performance parameters were found between robot-assisted knot ties executed with and without visual force feedback. Among surgeons without robotic experience, however, visual force feedback was associated with lower suture breakage rates, peak applied forces, and standard deviations of applied forces. Visual force feedback did not impart differences in knot completion times or loose knots for either surgeon group. Conclusions: Visual force feedback resulted in reduced suture breakage, lower forces, and decreased force inconsistencies among novice robotic surgeons, although elapsed time and knot quality were unaffected. In contrast, visual force feedback did not affect these metrics among surgeons experienced with the da Vinci system. These results suggest that visual force feedback primarily benefits novice robot-assisted surgeons, with diminishing benefits among experienced surgeons.",
author = "Reiley, {Carol E.} and Takintope Akinbiyi and Darius Burschka and Chang, {David C.} and Okamura, {Allison M.} and Yuh, {David D.}",
year = "2008",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jtcvs.2007.08.043",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "135",
pages = "196--202",
journal = "Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery",
issn = "0022-5223",
publisher = "Mosby Inc.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effects of visual force feedback on robot-assisted surgical task performance

AU - Reiley, Carol E.

AU - Akinbiyi, Takintope

AU - Burschka, Darius

AU - Chang, David C.

AU - Okamura, Allison M.

AU - Yuh, David D.

PY - 2008/1

Y1 - 2008/1

N2 - Objective: Direct haptic (force or tactile) feedback is negligible in current surgical robotic systems. The relevance of haptic feedback in robot-assisted performances of surgical tasks is controversial. We studied the effects of visual force feedback, a haptic feedback surrogate, on tying surgical knots with fine sutures similar to those used in cardiovascular surgery. Methods: By using a modified da Vinci robotic system (Intuitive Surgical, Inc, Sunnyvale, Calif) equipped with force-sensing instrument tips and real-time visual force feedback overlays in the console image, 10 surgeons each tied 10 knots with and 10 knots without visual force feedback. Four surgeons had significant prior da Vinci experience, and the remaining 6 surgeons did not. Performance parameters, including suture breakage and secure knots, peak and standard deviation of applied forces, and completion times using 5-0 silk sutures, were recorded. Chi-square and Student t test analyses determined the differences between groups. Results: Among surgeon subjects with robotic experience, no differences in measured performance parameters were found between robot-assisted knot ties executed with and without visual force feedback. Among surgeons without robotic experience, however, visual force feedback was associated with lower suture breakage rates, peak applied forces, and standard deviations of applied forces. Visual force feedback did not impart differences in knot completion times or loose knots for either surgeon group. Conclusions: Visual force feedback resulted in reduced suture breakage, lower forces, and decreased force inconsistencies among novice robotic surgeons, although elapsed time and knot quality were unaffected. In contrast, visual force feedback did not affect these metrics among surgeons experienced with the da Vinci system. These results suggest that visual force feedback primarily benefits novice robot-assisted surgeons, with diminishing benefits among experienced surgeons.

AB - Objective: Direct haptic (force or tactile) feedback is negligible in current surgical robotic systems. The relevance of haptic feedback in robot-assisted performances of surgical tasks is controversial. We studied the effects of visual force feedback, a haptic feedback surrogate, on tying surgical knots with fine sutures similar to those used in cardiovascular surgery. Methods: By using a modified da Vinci robotic system (Intuitive Surgical, Inc, Sunnyvale, Calif) equipped with force-sensing instrument tips and real-time visual force feedback overlays in the console image, 10 surgeons each tied 10 knots with and 10 knots without visual force feedback. Four surgeons had significant prior da Vinci experience, and the remaining 6 surgeons did not. Performance parameters, including suture breakage and secure knots, peak and standard deviation of applied forces, and completion times using 5-0 silk sutures, were recorded. Chi-square and Student t test analyses determined the differences between groups. Results: Among surgeon subjects with robotic experience, no differences in measured performance parameters were found between robot-assisted knot ties executed with and without visual force feedback. Among surgeons without robotic experience, however, visual force feedback was associated with lower suture breakage rates, peak applied forces, and standard deviations of applied forces. Visual force feedback did not impart differences in knot completion times or loose knots for either surgeon group. Conclusions: Visual force feedback resulted in reduced suture breakage, lower forces, and decreased force inconsistencies among novice robotic surgeons, although elapsed time and knot quality were unaffected. In contrast, visual force feedback did not affect these metrics among surgeons experienced with the da Vinci system. These results suggest that visual force feedback primarily benefits novice robot-assisted surgeons, with diminishing benefits among experienced surgeons.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=37549063919&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=37549063919&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2007.08.043

DO - 10.1016/j.jtcvs.2007.08.043

M3 - Article

C2 - 18179942

AN - SCOPUS:37549063919

VL - 135

SP - 196

EP - 202

JO - Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery

JF - Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery

SN - 0022-5223

IS - 1

ER -