Educating smokers about the risk of blindness - Insights to improve tobacco product health warning labels

Ryan David Kennedy, David Hammond, Marlee M. Spafford, Ornell Douglas, Julie Brûlé, Geoffrey T. Fong, Annette S H Schultz

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Health warning labels (HWL) on tobacco products help educate smokers about the health effects from smoking; however, there is a need to improve HWL content including images and text to increase effectiveness. In Canada, a HWL was created that communicates smoking's causal association with "blindness" from age-related macular degeneration (AMD). This study surveyed Canadian optometrists about their opinions regarding the image and text used in the "blindness" HWL. Methods: An online survey was sent to all 4528 registered Canadian optometrists. Respondents were asked if the HWL conveyed important and believable information, and if the picture was appropriate. Optometrists were invited to make open-ended comments about the label which were analyzed using a qualitative analysis framework suitable for health policy evaluation. Frequency distributions were calculated for closed-ended questions. Results: The survey was completed by 850 respondents (19 %). Most respondents (90 %) reported the message was believable/somewhat believable; while 35 % felt the picture was "too graphic". Some respondents reported in their open-ended comments that they were concerned the HWL was internally inconsistent because it reports there is "no effective treatment in most cases" for AMD but the image depicts someone undergoing surgery. There was concern that this may discourage patients from seeking needed treatment. Conclusion: The majority of Canadian optometrist respondents were in agreement that the new, "RISK OF BLINDNESS" pictorial HWL includes important, believable information. Some optometrists had concerns that the HWL included a confusing message or a message that may discourage some patients from pursuing treatment for AMD. Future development of blindness-related HWL should seek practitioner input.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number30
JournalTobacco Induced Diseases
Volume14
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 19 2016

Fingerprint

blindness
Blindness
Tobacco Products
nicotine
Health
health
Macular Degeneration
smoking
Smoking
frequency distribution
Health Policy
Surveys and Questionnaires
online survey
health policy
surgery
Canada
Therapeutics
Optometrists

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
  • Health(social science)
  • Medicine (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Educating smokers about the risk of blindness - Insights to improve tobacco product health warning labels. / Kennedy, Ryan David; Hammond, David; Spafford, Marlee M.; Douglas, Ornell; Brûlé, Julie; Fong, Geoffrey T.; Schultz, Annette S H.

In: Tobacco Induced Diseases, Vol. 14, No. 1, 30, 19.08.2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Kennedy, Ryan David ; Hammond, David ; Spafford, Marlee M. ; Douglas, Ornell ; Brûlé, Julie ; Fong, Geoffrey T. ; Schultz, Annette S H. / Educating smokers about the risk of blindness - Insights to improve tobacco product health warning labels. In: Tobacco Induced Diseases. 2016 ; Vol. 14, No. 1.
@article{bdc0dd60be134fd285b1566ebeeb822d,
title = "Educating smokers about the risk of blindness - Insights to improve tobacco product health warning labels",
abstract = "Background: Health warning labels (HWL) on tobacco products help educate smokers about the health effects from smoking; however, there is a need to improve HWL content including images and text to increase effectiveness. In Canada, a HWL was created that communicates smoking's causal association with {"}blindness{"} from age-related macular degeneration (AMD). This study surveyed Canadian optometrists about their opinions regarding the image and text used in the {"}blindness{"} HWL. Methods: An online survey was sent to all 4528 registered Canadian optometrists. Respondents were asked if the HWL conveyed important and believable information, and if the picture was appropriate. Optometrists were invited to make open-ended comments about the label which were analyzed using a qualitative analysis framework suitable for health policy evaluation. Frequency distributions were calculated for closed-ended questions. Results: The survey was completed by 850 respondents (19 {\%}). Most respondents (90 {\%}) reported the message was believable/somewhat believable; while 35 {\%} felt the picture was {"}too graphic{"}. Some respondents reported in their open-ended comments that they were concerned the HWL was internally inconsistent because it reports there is {"}no effective treatment in most cases{"} for AMD but the image depicts someone undergoing surgery. There was concern that this may discourage patients from seeking needed treatment. Conclusion: The majority of Canadian optometrist respondents were in agreement that the new, {"}RISK OF BLINDNESS{"} pictorial HWL includes important, believable information. Some optometrists had concerns that the HWL included a confusing message or a message that may discourage some patients from pursuing treatment for AMD. Future development of blindness-related HWL should seek practitioner input.",
author = "Kennedy, {Ryan David} and David Hammond and Spafford, {Marlee M.} and Ornell Douglas and Julie Br{\^u}l{\'e} and Fong, {Geoffrey T.} and Schultz, {Annette S H}",
year = "2016",
month = "8",
day = "19",
doi = "10.1186/s12971-016-0094-7",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "14",
journal = "Tobacco Induced Diseases",
issn = "1617-9625",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Educating smokers about the risk of blindness - Insights to improve tobacco product health warning labels

AU - Kennedy, Ryan David

AU - Hammond, David

AU - Spafford, Marlee M.

AU - Douglas, Ornell

AU - Brûlé, Julie

AU - Fong, Geoffrey T.

AU - Schultz, Annette S H

PY - 2016/8/19

Y1 - 2016/8/19

N2 - Background: Health warning labels (HWL) on tobacco products help educate smokers about the health effects from smoking; however, there is a need to improve HWL content including images and text to increase effectiveness. In Canada, a HWL was created that communicates smoking's causal association with "blindness" from age-related macular degeneration (AMD). This study surveyed Canadian optometrists about their opinions regarding the image and text used in the "blindness" HWL. Methods: An online survey was sent to all 4528 registered Canadian optometrists. Respondents were asked if the HWL conveyed important and believable information, and if the picture was appropriate. Optometrists were invited to make open-ended comments about the label which were analyzed using a qualitative analysis framework suitable for health policy evaluation. Frequency distributions were calculated for closed-ended questions. Results: The survey was completed by 850 respondents (19 %). Most respondents (90 %) reported the message was believable/somewhat believable; while 35 % felt the picture was "too graphic". Some respondents reported in their open-ended comments that they were concerned the HWL was internally inconsistent because it reports there is "no effective treatment in most cases" for AMD but the image depicts someone undergoing surgery. There was concern that this may discourage patients from seeking needed treatment. Conclusion: The majority of Canadian optometrist respondents were in agreement that the new, "RISK OF BLINDNESS" pictorial HWL includes important, believable information. Some optometrists had concerns that the HWL included a confusing message or a message that may discourage some patients from pursuing treatment for AMD. Future development of blindness-related HWL should seek practitioner input.

AB - Background: Health warning labels (HWL) on tobacco products help educate smokers about the health effects from smoking; however, there is a need to improve HWL content including images and text to increase effectiveness. In Canada, a HWL was created that communicates smoking's causal association with "blindness" from age-related macular degeneration (AMD). This study surveyed Canadian optometrists about their opinions regarding the image and text used in the "blindness" HWL. Methods: An online survey was sent to all 4528 registered Canadian optometrists. Respondents were asked if the HWL conveyed important and believable information, and if the picture was appropriate. Optometrists were invited to make open-ended comments about the label which were analyzed using a qualitative analysis framework suitable for health policy evaluation. Frequency distributions were calculated for closed-ended questions. Results: The survey was completed by 850 respondents (19 %). Most respondents (90 %) reported the message was believable/somewhat believable; while 35 % felt the picture was "too graphic". Some respondents reported in their open-ended comments that they were concerned the HWL was internally inconsistent because it reports there is "no effective treatment in most cases" for AMD but the image depicts someone undergoing surgery. There was concern that this may discourage patients from seeking needed treatment. Conclusion: The majority of Canadian optometrist respondents were in agreement that the new, "RISK OF BLINDNESS" pictorial HWL includes important, believable information. Some optometrists had concerns that the HWL included a confusing message or a message that may discourage some patients from pursuing treatment for AMD. Future development of blindness-related HWL should seek practitioner input.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84982291589&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84982291589&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/s12971-016-0094-7

DO - 10.1186/s12971-016-0094-7

M3 - Article

VL - 14

JO - Tobacco Induced Diseases

JF - Tobacco Induced Diseases

SN - 1617-9625

IS - 1

M1 - 30

ER -