Distinction of Plasmodium falciparum recrudescence and re-infection by MSP2 genotyping: A caution about unstandardized classification criteria

Petrica Rouse, Mtawa A P Mkulama, Philip E Thuma, Sungano Mharakurwa

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background. Plasmodium falciparum genotyping with molecular polymorphic markers is widely employed to distinguish recrudescence from re-infection in antimalarial drug efficacy monitoring programmes. However, limitations occur on agarose gel DNA measurements used to resolve the polymorphisms. Without empirical data, the current distinction of pre- and post-treatment bands, as persistent or new infection, is subjective and often varying by author. This study measures empirical tolerance limits for classifying different-sized bands as same or different alleles during MSP2 genotyping. Methods. P. falciparum field samples from 161 volunteers were genotyped by nested PCR using polymorphic MSP2 family-specific primers. Data were analysed to determine variability of band size measurements between identical MSP2 alleles randomized into different agarose lanes. Results. The mean (95% CI) paired difference in band size between identical alleles was 9.8 bp (1.48 - 18.16 bp, p = 0.022) for 3D7/IC and 2.54 (-3.04 - 8.05 bp, p = 0.362) for FC27. Based on these findings, pre- and post-treatment samples with 3D7/IC alleles showing less than 18 bp difference corresponded to recrudescence, with 95% confidence, while greater difference indicated new infection. FC27 allele differences were much narrower. For both 3D7/IC and FC27 amplicon, allele detection sensitivity was significantly higher with 13 μl compared to 20 μl or 30 μl lane loading volumes. Conclusion. During MSP genotyping, it is useful to standardize classifications against measurement of background variability on identical alleles, in order to obtain reliable findings. It is critical to use a fixed optimal lane loading volume for constant allele patency, to avoid the disappearance or false appearance of new infection.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number185
JournalMalaria Journal
Volume7
DOIs
StatePublished - 2008

Fingerprint

Plasmodium falciparum
Alleles
Recurrence
Infection
Sepharose
Drug Monitoring
Antimalarials
Therapeutics
Volunteers
Gels
Polymerase Chain Reaction
DNA

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Infectious Diseases
  • Parasitology

Cite this

Distinction of Plasmodium falciparum recrudescence and re-infection by MSP2 genotyping : A caution about unstandardized classification criteria. / Rouse, Petrica; Mkulama, Mtawa A P; Thuma, Philip E; Mharakurwa, Sungano.

In: Malaria Journal, Vol. 7, 185, 2008.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{7c02407fd45448fbb32e05a9ddfd8eef,
title = "Distinction of Plasmodium falciparum recrudescence and re-infection by MSP2 genotyping: A caution about unstandardized classification criteria",
abstract = "Background. Plasmodium falciparum genotyping with molecular polymorphic markers is widely employed to distinguish recrudescence from re-infection in antimalarial drug efficacy monitoring programmes. However, limitations occur on agarose gel DNA measurements used to resolve the polymorphisms. Without empirical data, the current distinction of pre- and post-treatment bands, as persistent or new infection, is subjective and often varying by author. This study measures empirical tolerance limits for classifying different-sized bands as same or different alleles during MSP2 genotyping. Methods. P. falciparum field samples from 161 volunteers were genotyped by nested PCR using polymorphic MSP2 family-specific primers. Data were analysed to determine variability of band size measurements between identical MSP2 alleles randomized into different agarose lanes. Results. The mean (95{\%} CI) paired difference in band size between identical alleles was 9.8 bp (1.48 - 18.16 bp, p = 0.022) for 3D7/IC and 2.54 (-3.04 - 8.05 bp, p = 0.362) for FC27. Based on these findings, pre- and post-treatment samples with 3D7/IC alleles showing less than 18 bp difference corresponded to recrudescence, with 95{\%} confidence, while greater difference indicated new infection. FC27 allele differences were much narrower. For both 3D7/IC and FC27 amplicon, allele detection sensitivity was significantly higher with 13 μl compared to 20 μl or 30 μl lane loading volumes. Conclusion. During MSP genotyping, it is useful to standardize classifications against measurement of background variability on identical alleles, in order to obtain reliable findings. It is critical to use a fixed optimal lane loading volume for constant allele patency, to avoid the disappearance or false appearance of new infection.",
author = "Petrica Rouse and Mkulama, {Mtawa A P} and Thuma, {Philip E} and Sungano Mharakurwa",
year = "2008",
doi = "10.1186/1475-2875-7-185",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "7",
journal = "Malaria Journal",
issn = "1475-2875",
publisher = "BioMed Central",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Distinction of Plasmodium falciparum recrudescence and re-infection by MSP2 genotyping

T2 - A caution about unstandardized classification criteria

AU - Rouse, Petrica

AU - Mkulama, Mtawa A P

AU - Thuma, Philip E

AU - Mharakurwa, Sungano

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - Background. Plasmodium falciparum genotyping with molecular polymorphic markers is widely employed to distinguish recrudescence from re-infection in antimalarial drug efficacy monitoring programmes. However, limitations occur on agarose gel DNA measurements used to resolve the polymorphisms. Without empirical data, the current distinction of pre- and post-treatment bands, as persistent or new infection, is subjective and often varying by author. This study measures empirical tolerance limits for classifying different-sized bands as same or different alleles during MSP2 genotyping. Methods. P. falciparum field samples from 161 volunteers were genotyped by nested PCR using polymorphic MSP2 family-specific primers. Data were analysed to determine variability of band size measurements between identical MSP2 alleles randomized into different agarose lanes. Results. The mean (95% CI) paired difference in band size between identical alleles was 9.8 bp (1.48 - 18.16 bp, p = 0.022) for 3D7/IC and 2.54 (-3.04 - 8.05 bp, p = 0.362) for FC27. Based on these findings, pre- and post-treatment samples with 3D7/IC alleles showing less than 18 bp difference corresponded to recrudescence, with 95% confidence, while greater difference indicated new infection. FC27 allele differences were much narrower. For both 3D7/IC and FC27 amplicon, allele detection sensitivity was significantly higher with 13 μl compared to 20 μl or 30 μl lane loading volumes. Conclusion. During MSP genotyping, it is useful to standardize classifications against measurement of background variability on identical alleles, in order to obtain reliable findings. It is critical to use a fixed optimal lane loading volume for constant allele patency, to avoid the disappearance or false appearance of new infection.

AB - Background. Plasmodium falciparum genotyping with molecular polymorphic markers is widely employed to distinguish recrudescence from re-infection in antimalarial drug efficacy monitoring programmes. However, limitations occur on agarose gel DNA measurements used to resolve the polymorphisms. Without empirical data, the current distinction of pre- and post-treatment bands, as persistent or new infection, is subjective and often varying by author. This study measures empirical tolerance limits for classifying different-sized bands as same or different alleles during MSP2 genotyping. Methods. P. falciparum field samples from 161 volunteers were genotyped by nested PCR using polymorphic MSP2 family-specific primers. Data were analysed to determine variability of band size measurements between identical MSP2 alleles randomized into different agarose lanes. Results. The mean (95% CI) paired difference in band size between identical alleles was 9.8 bp (1.48 - 18.16 bp, p = 0.022) for 3D7/IC and 2.54 (-3.04 - 8.05 bp, p = 0.362) for FC27. Based on these findings, pre- and post-treatment samples with 3D7/IC alleles showing less than 18 bp difference corresponded to recrudescence, with 95% confidence, while greater difference indicated new infection. FC27 allele differences were much narrower. For both 3D7/IC and FC27 amplicon, allele detection sensitivity was significantly higher with 13 μl compared to 20 μl or 30 μl lane loading volumes. Conclusion. During MSP genotyping, it is useful to standardize classifications against measurement of background variability on identical alleles, in order to obtain reliable findings. It is critical to use a fixed optimal lane loading volume for constant allele patency, to avoid the disappearance or false appearance of new infection.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=52949135492&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=52949135492&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/1475-2875-7-185

DO - 10.1186/1475-2875-7-185

M3 - Article

C2 - 18811949

AN - SCOPUS:52949135492

VL - 7

JO - Malaria Journal

JF - Malaria Journal

SN - 1475-2875

M1 - 185

ER -