Contact with the baby following stillbirth and parental mental health and well-being: a systematic review

Julie Hennegan, Jane Henderson, Maggie Redshaw

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To collate and critically appraise extant evidence for the impact of contact with the stillborn infant on parental mental health, well-being and satisfaction.

DESIGN: Systematic review.

DATA SOURCES: A structured systematic search was conducted in 13 databases, complemented by hand-searching.

STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: English language studies providing quantitative comparison of outcomes for parents who held their baby or engaged in other memory-making activities, such as having photos and handprints, compared to those who did not, were eligible for inclusion.

OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcomes included clinically diagnosed mental health issues, standardised assessment of mental health issues or self-reported psychological distress. Secondary outcomes included poor health, relationship difficulties and satisfaction with the decision to have contact with the baby.

RESULTS: Two authors independently screened abstracts, selected potentially eligible studies, extracted data and evaluated the quality of included papers. 11 eligible studies, reported in 18 papers, were included. Studies were heterogeneous, precluding quantitative synthesis, thus a narrative synthesis is presented. Studies presented high risks of bias, particularly in regard to sample representativeness, and confounder identification and adjustment. Results were mixed concerning the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being. One study found no significant effects, and two studies reported no impact on depression. Conflicting effects were found for anxiety and post-traumatic stress. Other memory-making activities were not found to have a significant association with mental health or well-being outcomes. Across studies, mothers were satisfied with their decision to hold their baby or engage in other memory making.

CONCLUSIONS: Evidence for the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being is sparse, and of poor quality. High-quality research guided by a priori hypotheses, with attention to potential confounders and moderating effects, is needed to provide more rigorous evidence to guide practitioners' and parents' decision-making for care following stillbirth.

REVIEW PROTOCOL NUMBER: PROSPERO CRD42014013890.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)e008616
JournalBMJ Open
Volume5
Issue number11
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 27 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Stillbirth
Mental Health
Mental Health Associations
Parents
Social Adjustment
Decision Making
Language
Anxiety
Mothers
Databases
Depression
Psychology
Health
Research

Keywords

  • bereavement
  • infant contact
  • stillbirth
  • systematic review
  • touch

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Contact with the baby following stillbirth and parental mental health and well-being : a systematic review. / Hennegan, Julie; Henderson, Jane; Redshaw, Maggie.

In: BMJ Open, Vol. 5, No. 11, 27.11.2015, p. e008616.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

@article{c7e4a54fc7af40cdbff57bb020592122,
title = "Contact with the baby following stillbirth and parental mental health and well-being: a systematic review",
abstract = "OBJECTIVE: To collate and critically appraise extant evidence for the impact of contact with the stillborn infant on parental mental health, well-being and satisfaction.DESIGN: Systematic review.DATA SOURCES: A structured systematic search was conducted in 13 databases, complemented by hand-searching.STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: English language studies providing quantitative comparison of outcomes for parents who held their baby or engaged in other memory-making activities, such as having photos and handprints, compared to those who did not, were eligible for inclusion.OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcomes included clinically diagnosed mental health issues, standardised assessment of mental health issues or self-reported psychological distress. Secondary outcomes included poor health, relationship difficulties and satisfaction with the decision to have contact with the baby.RESULTS: Two authors independently screened abstracts, selected potentially eligible studies, extracted data and evaluated the quality of included papers. 11 eligible studies, reported in 18 papers, were included. Studies were heterogeneous, precluding quantitative synthesis, thus a narrative synthesis is presented. Studies presented high risks of bias, particularly in regard to sample representativeness, and confounder identification and adjustment. Results were mixed concerning the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being. One study found no significant effects, and two studies reported no impact on depression. Conflicting effects were found for anxiety and post-traumatic stress. Other memory-making activities were not found to have a significant association with mental health or well-being outcomes. Across studies, mothers were satisfied with their decision to hold their baby or engage in other memory making.CONCLUSIONS: Evidence for the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being is sparse, and of poor quality. High-quality research guided by a priori hypotheses, with attention to potential confounders and moderating effects, is needed to provide more rigorous evidence to guide practitioners' and parents' decision-making for care following stillbirth.REVIEW PROTOCOL NUMBER: PROSPERO CRD42014013890.",
keywords = "bereavement, infant contact, stillbirth, systematic review, touch",
author = "Julie Hennegan and Jane Henderson and Maggie Redshaw",
year = "2015",
month = "11",
day = "27",
doi = "10.1136/bmjopen-2015-008616",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "5",
pages = "e008616",
journal = "BMJ Open",
issn = "2044-6055",
publisher = "BMJ Publishing Group",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Contact with the baby following stillbirth and parental mental health and well-being

T2 - a systematic review

AU - Hennegan, Julie

AU - Henderson, Jane

AU - Redshaw, Maggie

PY - 2015/11/27

Y1 - 2015/11/27

N2 - OBJECTIVE: To collate and critically appraise extant evidence for the impact of contact with the stillborn infant on parental mental health, well-being and satisfaction.DESIGN: Systematic review.DATA SOURCES: A structured systematic search was conducted in 13 databases, complemented by hand-searching.STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: English language studies providing quantitative comparison of outcomes for parents who held their baby or engaged in other memory-making activities, such as having photos and handprints, compared to those who did not, were eligible for inclusion.OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcomes included clinically diagnosed mental health issues, standardised assessment of mental health issues or self-reported psychological distress. Secondary outcomes included poor health, relationship difficulties and satisfaction with the decision to have contact with the baby.RESULTS: Two authors independently screened abstracts, selected potentially eligible studies, extracted data and evaluated the quality of included papers. 11 eligible studies, reported in 18 papers, were included. Studies were heterogeneous, precluding quantitative synthesis, thus a narrative synthesis is presented. Studies presented high risks of bias, particularly in regard to sample representativeness, and confounder identification and adjustment. Results were mixed concerning the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being. One study found no significant effects, and two studies reported no impact on depression. Conflicting effects were found for anxiety and post-traumatic stress. Other memory-making activities were not found to have a significant association with mental health or well-being outcomes. Across studies, mothers were satisfied with their decision to hold their baby or engage in other memory making.CONCLUSIONS: Evidence for the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being is sparse, and of poor quality. High-quality research guided by a priori hypotheses, with attention to potential confounders and moderating effects, is needed to provide more rigorous evidence to guide practitioners' and parents' decision-making for care following stillbirth.REVIEW PROTOCOL NUMBER: PROSPERO CRD42014013890.

AB - OBJECTIVE: To collate and critically appraise extant evidence for the impact of contact with the stillborn infant on parental mental health, well-being and satisfaction.DESIGN: Systematic review.DATA SOURCES: A structured systematic search was conducted in 13 databases, complemented by hand-searching.STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: English language studies providing quantitative comparison of outcomes for parents who held their baby or engaged in other memory-making activities, such as having photos and handprints, compared to those who did not, were eligible for inclusion.OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcomes included clinically diagnosed mental health issues, standardised assessment of mental health issues or self-reported psychological distress. Secondary outcomes included poor health, relationship difficulties and satisfaction with the decision to have contact with the baby.RESULTS: Two authors independently screened abstracts, selected potentially eligible studies, extracted data and evaluated the quality of included papers. 11 eligible studies, reported in 18 papers, were included. Studies were heterogeneous, precluding quantitative synthesis, thus a narrative synthesis is presented. Studies presented high risks of bias, particularly in regard to sample representativeness, and confounder identification and adjustment. Results were mixed concerning the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being. One study found no significant effects, and two studies reported no impact on depression. Conflicting effects were found for anxiety and post-traumatic stress. Other memory-making activities were not found to have a significant association with mental health or well-being outcomes. Across studies, mothers were satisfied with their decision to hold their baby or engage in other memory making.CONCLUSIONS: Evidence for the impact of holding the stillborn baby on mental health and well-being is sparse, and of poor quality. High-quality research guided by a priori hypotheses, with attention to potential confounders and moderating effects, is needed to provide more rigorous evidence to guide practitioners' and parents' decision-making for care following stillbirth.REVIEW PROTOCOL NUMBER: PROSPERO CRD42014013890.

KW - bereavement

KW - infant contact

KW - stillbirth

KW - systematic review

KW - touch

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84959468024&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84959468024&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-008616

DO - 10.1136/bmjopen-2015-008616

M3 - Review article

C2 - 26614620

AN - SCOPUS:84959468024

VL - 5

SP - e008616

JO - BMJ Open

JF - BMJ Open

SN - 2044-6055

IS - 11

ER -