Comparison of organ residence time estimation methods for radioimmunotherapy dosimetry and treatment planning-patient studies

Bin He, Richard L. Wahl, George Sgouros, Yong Du, Heather Jacene, Wayne R. Kasecamp, Ian Flinn, Richard J. Hammes, Jay Bianco, Brad Kahl, Eric Frey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The estimation of organ residence time is essential for high-dose myeloablative regimens in radioimmunotherapy (RIT). Frequently, this estimation is based on a series of simple planar scans and planar processing. The authors previously performed a simulation study which demonstrated that the accuracy of this methodology is limited compared to a hybrid planar/SPECT residence time estimation method. In this work the authors applied this hybrid method to data from a clinical trial of high-dose myeloablative yttrium-90 ibritumomab tiuxetan therapy. Image data acquired from 18 patients were comprised of planar scans at five time points ranging from 1 to 144 h postinjection and abdominal and thoracic SPECT/CT scans obtained at 24 h postinjection. The simple planar processing method used in this work was based on the geometric mean method with energy window based scatter compensation. No explicit background subtraction nor object or source thickness corrections were performed. The SPECT projections were reconstructed using iterative reconstruction with compensations for attenuation, scatter, and full collimator-detector response. Large differences were observed when residence times were estimated using the simple planar method compared to the hybrid method. The differences were not constant but varied in magnitude and sign. For the dose-limiting organ (liver), the average difference was -18% and variation in the difference was 19%, similar to the differences observed in a previously reported simulation study. The authors also looked at the relationship between the weight of the patient and the liver residence time and found that there was no meaningful correlation for either method. This indicates that weight would not be an adequate proxy for an experimental estimate of residence time when choosing the activity to administer for therapy. The authors conclude that methods such as the simple planar method used here are inadequate for RIT treatment planning. More sophisticated methods, such as the hybrid SPECT/planar method investigated here, are likely to be better predictors of organ dose and, as a result, organ toxicities.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1595-1601
Number of pages7
JournalMedical Physics
Volume36
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - 2009

Fingerprint

Radioimmunotherapy
Single-Photon Emission-Computed Tomography
Therapeutics
Weights and Measures
Liver
Proxy
Thorax

Keywords

  • Absolute quantitation
  • Quantitative SPECT
  • Radioimmunotherapy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biophysics
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Comparison of organ residence time estimation methods for radioimmunotherapy dosimetry and treatment planning-patient studies. / He, Bin; Wahl, Richard L.; Sgouros, George; Du, Yong; Jacene, Heather; Kasecamp, Wayne R.; Flinn, Ian; Hammes, Richard J.; Bianco, Jay; Kahl, Brad; Frey, Eric.

In: Medical Physics, Vol. 36, No. 5, 2009, p. 1595-1601.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

He, Bin ; Wahl, Richard L. ; Sgouros, George ; Du, Yong ; Jacene, Heather ; Kasecamp, Wayne R. ; Flinn, Ian ; Hammes, Richard J. ; Bianco, Jay ; Kahl, Brad ; Frey, Eric. / Comparison of organ residence time estimation methods for radioimmunotherapy dosimetry and treatment planning-patient studies. In: Medical Physics. 2009 ; Vol. 36, No. 5. pp. 1595-1601.
@article{cade544adbbb439e89c8f1a1fed482dd,
title = "Comparison of organ residence time estimation methods for radioimmunotherapy dosimetry and treatment planning-patient studies",
abstract = "The estimation of organ residence time is essential for high-dose myeloablative regimens in radioimmunotherapy (RIT). Frequently, this estimation is based on a series of simple planar scans and planar processing. The authors previously performed a simulation study which demonstrated that the accuracy of this methodology is limited compared to a hybrid planar/SPECT residence time estimation method. In this work the authors applied this hybrid method to data from a clinical trial of high-dose myeloablative yttrium-90 ibritumomab tiuxetan therapy. Image data acquired from 18 patients were comprised of planar scans at five time points ranging from 1 to 144 h postinjection and abdominal and thoracic SPECT/CT scans obtained at 24 h postinjection. The simple planar processing method used in this work was based on the geometric mean method with energy window based scatter compensation. No explicit background subtraction nor object or source thickness corrections were performed. The SPECT projections were reconstructed using iterative reconstruction with compensations for attenuation, scatter, and full collimator-detector response. Large differences were observed when residence times were estimated using the simple planar method compared to the hybrid method. The differences were not constant but varied in magnitude and sign. For the dose-limiting organ (liver), the average difference was -18{\%} and variation in the difference was 19{\%}, similar to the differences observed in a previously reported simulation study. The authors also looked at the relationship between the weight of the patient and the liver residence time and found that there was no meaningful correlation for either method. This indicates that weight would not be an adequate proxy for an experimental estimate of residence time when choosing the activity to administer for therapy. The authors conclude that methods such as the simple planar method used here are inadequate for RIT treatment planning. More sophisticated methods, such as the hybrid SPECT/planar method investigated here, are likely to be better predictors of organ dose and, as a result, organ toxicities.",
keywords = "Absolute quantitation, Quantitative SPECT, Radioimmunotherapy",
author = "Bin He and Wahl, {Richard L.} and George Sgouros and Yong Du and Heather Jacene and Kasecamp, {Wayne R.} and Ian Flinn and Hammes, {Richard J.} and Jay Bianco and Brad Kahl and Eric Frey",
year = "2009",
doi = "10.1118/1.3100265",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "36",
pages = "1595--1601",
journal = "Medical Physics",
issn = "0094-2405",
publisher = "AAPM - American Association of Physicists in Medicine",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of organ residence time estimation methods for radioimmunotherapy dosimetry and treatment planning-patient studies

AU - He, Bin

AU - Wahl, Richard L.

AU - Sgouros, George

AU - Du, Yong

AU - Jacene, Heather

AU - Kasecamp, Wayne R.

AU - Flinn, Ian

AU - Hammes, Richard J.

AU - Bianco, Jay

AU - Kahl, Brad

AU - Frey, Eric

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - The estimation of organ residence time is essential for high-dose myeloablative regimens in radioimmunotherapy (RIT). Frequently, this estimation is based on a series of simple planar scans and planar processing. The authors previously performed a simulation study which demonstrated that the accuracy of this methodology is limited compared to a hybrid planar/SPECT residence time estimation method. In this work the authors applied this hybrid method to data from a clinical trial of high-dose myeloablative yttrium-90 ibritumomab tiuxetan therapy. Image data acquired from 18 patients were comprised of planar scans at five time points ranging from 1 to 144 h postinjection and abdominal and thoracic SPECT/CT scans obtained at 24 h postinjection. The simple planar processing method used in this work was based on the geometric mean method with energy window based scatter compensation. No explicit background subtraction nor object or source thickness corrections were performed. The SPECT projections were reconstructed using iterative reconstruction with compensations for attenuation, scatter, and full collimator-detector response. Large differences were observed when residence times were estimated using the simple planar method compared to the hybrid method. The differences were not constant but varied in magnitude and sign. For the dose-limiting organ (liver), the average difference was -18% and variation in the difference was 19%, similar to the differences observed in a previously reported simulation study. The authors also looked at the relationship between the weight of the patient and the liver residence time and found that there was no meaningful correlation for either method. This indicates that weight would not be an adequate proxy for an experimental estimate of residence time when choosing the activity to administer for therapy. The authors conclude that methods such as the simple planar method used here are inadequate for RIT treatment planning. More sophisticated methods, such as the hybrid SPECT/planar method investigated here, are likely to be better predictors of organ dose and, as a result, organ toxicities.

AB - The estimation of organ residence time is essential for high-dose myeloablative regimens in radioimmunotherapy (RIT). Frequently, this estimation is based on a series of simple planar scans and planar processing. The authors previously performed a simulation study which demonstrated that the accuracy of this methodology is limited compared to a hybrid planar/SPECT residence time estimation method. In this work the authors applied this hybrid method to data from a clinical trial of high-dose myeloablative yttrium-90 ibritumomab tiuxetan therapy. Image data acquired from 18 patients were comprised of planar scans at five time points ranging from 1 to 144 h postinjection and abdominal and thoracic SPECT/CT scans obtained at 24 h postinjection. The simple planar processing method used in this work was based on the geometric mean method with energy window based scatter compensation. No explicit background subtraction nor object or source thickness corrections were performed. The SPECT projections were reconstructed using iterative reconstruction with compensations for attenuation, scatter, and full collimator-detector response. Large differences were observed when residence times were estimated using the simple planar method compared to the hybrid method. The differences were not constant but varied in magnitude and sign. For the dose-limiting organ (liver), the average difference was -18% and variation in the difference was 19%, similar to the differences observed in a previously reported simulation study. The authors also looked at the relationship between the weight of the patient and the liver residence time and found that there was no meaningful correlation for either method. This indicates that weight would not be an adequate proxy for an experimental estimate of residence time when choosing the activity to administer for therapy. The authors conclude that methods such as the simple planar method used here are inadequate for RIT treatment planning. More sophisticated methods, such as the hybrid SPECT/planar method investigated here, are likely to be better predictors of organ dose and, as a result, organ toxicities.

KW - Absolute quantitation

KW - Quantitative SPECT

KW - Radioimmunotherapy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=65449124640&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=65449124640&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1118/1.3100265

DO - 10.1118/1.3100265

M3 - Article

C2 - 19544775

AN - SCOPUS:65449124640

VL - 36

SP - 1595

EP - 1601

JO - Medical Physics

JF - Medical Physics

SN - 0094-2405

IS - 5

ER -