Comparison of decoding resolution of standard and high-density electrocorticogram electrodes

Po T. Wang, Christine E. King, Colin M. McCrimmon, Jack J. Lin, Mona Sazgar, Frank P K Hsu, Susan J. Shaw, David E. Millet, Luis A. Chui, Charles Y. Liu, An H. Do, Zoran Nenadic

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective. Electrocorticography (ECoG)-based brain-computer interface (BCI) is a promising platform for controlling arm prostheses. To restore functional independence, a BCI must be able to control arm prostheses along at least six degrees-of-freedoms (DOFs). Prior studies suggest that standard ECoG grids may be insufficient to decode multi-DOF arm movements. This study compared the ability of standard and high-density (HD) ECoG grids to decode the presence/absence of six elementary arm movements and the type of movement performed. Approach. Three subjects implanted with standard grids (4 mm diameter, 10 mm spacing) and three with HD grids (2 mm diameter, 4 mm spacing) had ECoG signals recorded while performing the following movements: (1) pincer grasp/release, (2) wrist flexion/extension, (3) pronation/supination, (4) elbow flexion/extension, (5) shoulder internal/external rotation, and (6) shoulder forward flexion/extension. Data from the primary motor cortex were used to train a state decoder to detect the presence/absence of movement, and a six-class decoder to distinguish between these movements. Main results. The average performances of the state decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those of their standard grid counterparts across all combinations of the μ, β, low-γ, and high-γ frequency bands. The average best decoding error for HD grids was 2.6%, compared to 8.5% of standard grids (chance 50%). The movement decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those based on standard ECoG across all band combinations. The average best decoding errors of 11.9% and 33.1% were obtained for HD and standard grids, respectively (chance error 83.3%). These improvements can be attributed to higher electrode density and signal quality of HD grids. Significance. Commonly used ECoG grids are inadequate for multi-DOF BCI arm prostheses. The performance gains by HD grids may eventually lead to independence-restoring BCI arm prosthesis.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number026016
JournalJournal of Neural Engineering
Volume13
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 9 2016
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Decoding
Electrodes
Artificial Limbs
Brain computer interface
Brain-Computer Interfaces
Prosthetics
Arm
Pronation
Supination
Electrocorticography
Motor Cortex
Hand Strength
Frequency bands
Elbow
Wrist

Keywords

  • arm
  • brain computer interface
  • classification
  • electrocorticogram
  • high density electrocorticogram
  • upper extremity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biomedical Engineering
  • Cellular and Molecular Neuroscience

Cite this

Wang, P. T., King, C. E., McCrimmon, C. M., Lin, J. J., Sazgar, M., Hsu, F. P. K., ... Nenadic, Z. (2016). Comparison of decoding resolution of standard and high-density electrocorticogram electrodes. Journal of Neural Engineering, 13(2), [026016]. https://doi.org/10.1088/1741-2560/13/2/026016

Comparison of decoding resolution of standard and high-density electrocorticogram electrodes. / Wang, Po T.; King, Christine E.; McCrimmon, Colin M.; Lin, Jack J.; Sazgar, Mona; Hsu, Frank P K; Shaw, Susan J.; Millet, David E.; Chui, Luis A.; Liu, Charles Y.; Do, An H.; Nenadic, Zoran.

In: Journal of Neural Engineering, Vol. 13, No. 2, 026016, 09.02.2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Wang, PT, King, CE, McCrimmon, CM, Lin, JJ, Sazgar, M, Hsu, FPK, Shaw, SJ, Millet, DE, Chui, LA, Liu, CY, Do, AH & Nenadic, Z 2016, 'Comparison of decoding resolution of standard and high-density electrocorticogram electrodes', Journal of Neural Engineering, vol. 13, no. 2, 026016. https://doi.org/10.1088/1741-2560/13/2/026016
Wang, Po T. ; King, Christine E. ; McCrimmon, Colin M. ; Lin, Jack J. ; Sazgar, Mona ; Hsu, Frank P K ; Shaw, Susan J. ; Millet, David E. ; Chui, Luis A. ; Liu, Charles Y. ; Do, An H. ; Nenadic, Zoran. / Comparison of decoding resolution of standard and high-density electrocorticogram electrodes. In: Journal of Neural Engineering. 2016 ; Vol. 13, No. 2.
@article{3b6c10d47b564ad1bc04c04c55f63cf3,
title = "Comparison of decoding resolution of standard and high-density electrocorticogram electrodes",
abstract = "Objective. Electrocorticography (ECoG)-based brain-computer interface (BCI) is a promising platform for controlling arm prostheses. To restore functional independence, a BCI must be able to control arm prostheses along at least six degrees-of-freedoms (DOFs). Prior studies suggest that standard ECoG grids may be insufficient to decode multi-DOF arm movements. This study compared the ability of standard and high-density (HD) ECoG grids to decode the presence/absence of six elementary arm movements and the type of movement performed. Approach. Three subjects implanted with standard grids (4 mm diameter, 10 mm spacing) and three with HD grids (2 mm diameter, 4 mm spacing) had ECoG signals recorded while performing the following movements: (1) pincer grasp/release, (2) wrist flexion/extension, (3) pronation/supination, (4) elbow flexion/extension, (5) shoulder internal/external rotation, and (6) shoulder forward flexion/extension. Data from the primary motor cortex were used to train a state decoder to detect the presence/absence of movement, and a six-class decoder to distinguish between these movements. Main results. The average performances of the state decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those of their standard grid counterparts across all combinations of the μ, β, low-γ, and high-γ frequency bands. The average best decoding error for HD grids was 2.6{\%}, compared to 8.5{\%} of standard grids (chance 50{\%}). The movement decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those based on standard ECoG across all band combinations. The average best decoding errors of 11.9{\%} and 33.1{\%} were obtained for HD and standard grids, respectively (chance error 83.3{\%}). These improvements can be attributed to higher electrode density and signal quality of HD grids. Significance. Commonly used ECoG grids are inadequate for multi-DOF BCI arm prostheses. The performance gains by HD grids may eventually lead to independence-restoring BCI arm prosthesis.",
keywords = "arm, brain computer interface, classification, electrocorticogram, high density electrocorticogram, upper extremity",
author = "Wang, {Po T.} and King, {Christine E.} and McCrimmon, {Colin M.} and Lin, {Jack J.} and Mona Sazgar and Hsu, {Frank P K} and Shaw, {Susan J.} and Millet, {David E.} and Chui, {Luis A.} and Liu, {Charles Y.} and Do, {An H.} and Zoran Nenadic",
year = "2016",
month = "2",
day = "9",
doi = "10.1088/1741-2560/13/2/026016",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "13",
journal = "Journal of Neural Engineering",
issn = "1741-2560",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of decoding resolution of standard and high-density electrocorticogram electrodes

AU - Wang, Po T.

AU - King, Christine E.

AU - McCrimmon, Colin M.

AU - Lin, Jack J.

AU - Sazgar, Mona

AU - Hsu, Frank P K

AU - Shaw, Susan J.

AU - Millet, David E.

AU - Chui, Luis A.

AU - Liu, Charles Y.

AU - Do, An H.

AU - Nenadic, Zoran

PY - 2016/2/9

Y1 - 2016/2/9

N2 - Objective. Electrocorticography (ECoG)-based brain-computer interface (BCI) is a promising platform for controlling arm prostheses. To restore functional independence, a BCI must be able to control arm prostheses along at least six degrees-of-freedoms (DOFs). Prior studies suggest that standard ECoG grids may be insufficient to decode multi-DOF arm movements. This study compared the ability of standard and high-density (HD) ECoG grids to decode the presence/absence of six elementary arm movements and the type of movement performed. Approach. Three subjects implanted with standard grids (4 mm diameter, 10 mm spacing) and three with HD grids (2 mm diameter, 4 mm spacing) had ECoG signals recorded while performing the following movements: (1) pincer grasp/release, (2) wrist flexion/extension, (3) pronation/supination, (4) elbow flexion/extension, (5) shoulder internal/external rotation, and (6) shoulder forward flexion/extension. Data from the primary motor cortex were used to train a state decoder to detect the presence/absence of movement, and a six-class decoder to distinguish between these movements. Main results. The average performances of the state decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those of their standard grid counterparts across all combinations of the μ, β, low-γ, and high-γ frequency bands. The average best decoding error for HD grids was 2.6%, compared to 8.5% of standard grids (chance 50%). The movement decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those based on standard ECoG across all band combinations. The average best decoding errors of 11.9% and 33.1% were obtained for HD and standard grids, respectively (chance error 83.3%). These improvements can be attributed to higher electrode density and signal quality of HD grids. Significance. Commonly used ECoG grids are inadequate for multi-DOF BCI arm prostheses. The performance gains by HD grids may eventually lead to independence-restoring BCI arm prosthesis.

AB - Objective. Electrocorticography (ECoG)-based brain-computer interface (BCI) is a promising platform for controlling arm prostheses. To restore functional independence, a BCI must be able to control arm prostheses along at least six degrees-of-freedoms (DOFs). Prior studies suggest that standard ECoG grids may be insufficient to decode multi-DOF arm movements. This study compared the ability of standard and high-density (HD) ECoG grids to decode the presence/absence of six elementary arm movements and the type of movement performed. Approach. Three subjects implanted with standard grids (4 mm diameter, 10 mm spacing) and three with HD grids (2 mm diameter, 4 mm spacing) had ECoG signals recorded while performing the following movements: (1) pincer grasp/release, (2) wrist flexion/extension, (3) pronation/supination, (4) elbow flexion/extension, (5) shoulder internal/external rotation, and (6) shoulder forward flexion/extension. Data from the primary motor cortex were used to train a state decoder to detect the presence/absence of movement, and a six-class decoder to distinguish between these movements. Main results. The average performances of the state decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those of their standard grid counterparts across all combinations of the μ, β, low-γ, and high-γ frequency bands. The average best decoding error for HD grids was 2.6%, compared to 8.5% of standard grids (chance 50%). The movement decoders trained on HD ECoG data were superior (p = 3.05 10-5) to those based on standard ECoG across all band combinations. The average best decoding errors of 11.9% and 33.1% were obtained for HD and standard grids, respectively (chance error 83.3%). These improvements can be attributed to higher electrode density and signal quality of HD grids. Significance. Commonly used ECoG grids are inadequate for multi-DOF BCI arm prostheses. The performance gains by HD grids may eventually lead to independence-restoring BCI arm prosthesis.

KW - arm

KW - brain computer interface

KW - classification

KW - electrocorticogram

KW - high density electrocorticogram

KW - upper extremity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84962456200&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84962456200&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1088/1741-2560/13/2/026016

DO - 10.1088/1741-2560/13/2/026016

M3 - Article

C2 - 26859341

AN - SCOPUS:84962456200

VL - 13

JO - Journal of Neural Engineering

JF - Journal of Neural Engineering

SN - 1741-2560

IS - 2

M1 - 026016

ER -