Building consensus: Development of a best practice guideline (BPG) for surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in high-risk pediatric spine surgery

Michael G. Vitale, Matthew D. Riedel, Michael P. Glotzbecker, Hiroko Matsumoto, David P. Roye, Behrooz A. Akbarnia, Richard C E Anderson, Douglas L. Brockmeyer, John B. Emans, Mark Erickson, John M. Flynn, Lawrence G. Lenke, Stephen J. Lewis, Scott J. Luhmann, Lisa M. McLeod, Peter O. Newton, Ann Christine Nyquist, B. Stephens Richards, Suken A. Shah, David L. SkaggsJohn T. Smith, Paul David Sponseller, Daniel J. Sucato, Reinhard D. Zeller, Lisa Saiman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Perioperative surgical site infection (SSI) after pediatric spine fusion is a recognized complication with rates between 0.5% and 1.6% in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis and up to 22% in "high risk" patients. Significant variation in the approach to infection prophylaxis has been well documented. The purpose of this initiative is to develop a consensus-based "Best Practice" Guideline (BPG), informed by both the available evidence in the literature and expert opinion, for high-risk pediatric patients undergoing spine fusion. For the purpose of this effort, high risk was defined as anything other than a primary fusion in a patient with idiopathic scoliosis without significant comorbidities. The ultimate goal of this initiative is to decrease the wide variability in SSI prevention strategies in this area, ultimately leading to improved patient outcomes and reduced health care costs. METHODS: An expert panel composed of 20 pediatric spine surgeons and 3 infectious disease specialists from North America, selected for their extensive experience in the field of pediatric spine surgery, was developed. Using the Delphi process and iterative rounds using a nominal group technique, participants in this panel were as follows: (1) surveyed for current practices; (2) presented with a detailed systematic review of the relevant literature; (3) given the opportunity to voice opinion collectively; and (4) asked to vote regarding preferences privately. Round 1 was conducted using an electronic survey. Initial results were compiled and discussed face-to-face. Round 2 was conducted using the Audience Response System, allowing participants to vote for (strongly support or support) or against inclusion of each intervention. Agreement >80% was considered consensus. Interventions without consensus were discussed and revised, if feasible. Repeat voting for consensus was performed. RESULTS: Consensus was reached to support 14 SSI prevention strategies and all participants agreed to implement the BPG in their practices. All agreed to participate in further studies assessing implementation and effectiveness of the BPG. The final consensus driven BPG for high-risk pediatric spine surgery patients includes: (1) patients should have a chlorhexidine skin wash the night before surgery; (2) patients should have preoperative urine cultures obtained; (3) patients should receive a preoperative Patient Education Sheet; (4) patients should have a preoperative nutritional assessment; (5) if removing hair, clipping is preferred to shaving; (6) patients should receive perioperative intravenous cefazolin; (7) patients should receive perioperative intravenous prophylaxis for gram-negative bacilli; (8) adherence to perioperative antimicrobial regimens should be monitored; (9) operating room access should be limited during scoliosis surgery (whenever practical); (10) UV lights need NOT be used in the operating room; (11) patients should have intraoperative wound irrigation; (12) vancomycin powder should be used in the bone graft and/or the surgical site; (13) impervious dressings are preferred postoperatively; (14) postoperative dressing changes should be minimized before discharge to the extent possible. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, we present a consensus-based BPG consisting of 14 recommendations for the prevention of SSIs after spine surgery in high-risk pediatric patients. This can serve as a tool to reduce the variability in practice in this area and help guide research priorities in the future. Pending such data, it is the unsubstantiated opinion of the authors of the current paper that adherence to recommendations in the BPG will not only decrease variability in practice but also result in fewer SSI in high-risk children undergoing spinal fusion. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Not applicable.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)471-478
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of Pediatric Orthopaedics
Volume33
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 2013

Fingerprint

Surgical Wound Infection
Practice Guidelines
Consensus
Spine
Pediatrics
Scoliosis
Operating Rooms
Bandages
Cefazolin
Spinal Fusion
Nutrition Assessment
Chlorhexidine
Expert Testimony
Patient Education
Politics
Vancomycin
Ultraviolet Rays
North America
Health Care Costs
Powders

Keywords

  • Guideline
  • High risk
  • Infection
  • Outcomes
  • Scoliosis
  • Spine
  • SSI
  • Surgical site infection

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pediatrics, Perinatology, and Child Health
  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Cite this

Building consensus : Development of a best practice guideline (BPG) for surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in high-risk pediatric spine surgery. / Vitale, Michael G.; Riedel, Matthew D.; Glotzbecker, Michael P.; Matsumoto, Hiroko; Roye, David P.; Akbarnia, Behrooz A.; Anderson, Richard C E; Brockmeyer, Douglas L.; Emans, John B.; Erickson, Mark; Flynn, John M.; Lenke, Lawrence G.; Lewis, Stephen J.; Luhmann, Scott J.; McLeod, Lisa M.; Newton, Peter O.; Nyquist, Ann Christine; Richards, B. Stephens; Shah, Suken A.; Skaggs, David L.; Smith, John T.; Sponseller, Paul David; Sucato, Daniel J.; Zeller, Reinhard D.; Saiman, Lisa.

In: Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics, Vol. 33, No. 5, 07.2013, p. 471-478.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Vitale, MG, Riedel, MD, Glotzbecker, MP, Matsumoto, H, Roye, DP, Akbarnia, BA, Anderson, RCE, Brockmeyer, DL, Emans, JB, Erickson, M, Flynn, JM, Lenke, LG, Lewis, SJ, Luhmann, SJ, McLeod, LM, Newton, PO, Nyquist, AC, Richards, BS, Shah, SA, Skaggs, DL, Smith, JT, Sponseller, PD, Sucato, DJ, Zeller, RD & Saiman, L 2013, 'Building consensus: Development of a best practice guideline (BPG) for surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in high-risk pediatric spine surgery', Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics, vol. 33, no. 5, pp. 471-478. https://doi.org/10.1097/BPO.0b013e3182840de2
Vitale, Michael G. ; Riedel, Matthew D. ; Glotzbecker, Michael P. ; Matsumoto, Hiroko ; Roye, David P. ; Akbarnia, Behrooz A. ; Anderson, Richard C E ; Brockmeyer, Douglas L. ; Emans, John B. ; Erickson, Mark ; Flynn, John M. ; Lenke, Lawrence G. ; Lewis, Stephen J. ; Luhmann, Scott J. ; McLeod, Lisa M. ; Newton, Peter O. ; Nyquist, Ann Christine ; Richards, B. Stephens ; Shah, Suken A. ; Skaggs, David L. ; Smith, John T. ; Sponseller, Paul David ; Sucato, Daniel J. ; Zeller, Reinhard D. ; Saiman, Lisa. / Building consensus : Development of a best practice guideline (BPG) for surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in high-risk pediatric spine surgery. In: Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics. 2013 ; Vol. 33, No. 5. pp. 471-478.
@article{d76553e1a91a42f2b5f3b5a54d972b20,
title = "Building consensus: Development of a best practice guideline (BPG) for surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in high-risk pediatric spine surgery",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Perioperative surgical site infection (SSI) after pediatric spine fusion is a recognized complication with rates between 0.5{\%} and 1.6{\%} in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis and up to 22{\%} in {"}high risk{"} patients. Significant variation in the approach to infection prophylaxis has been well documented. The purpose of this initiative is to develop a consensus-based {"}Best Practice{"} Guideline (BPG), informed by both the available evidence in the literature and expert opinion, for high-risk pediatric patients undergoing spine fusion. For the purpose of this effort, high risk was defined as anything other than a primary fusion in a patient with idiopathic scoliosis without significant comorbidities. The ultimate goal of this initiative is to decrease the wide variability in SSI prevention strategies in this area, ultimately leading to improved patient outcomes and reduced health care costs. METHODS: An expert panel composed of 20 pediatric spine surgeons and 3 infectious disease specialists from North America, selected for their extensive experience in the field of pediatric spine surgery, was developed. Using the Delphi process and iterative rounds using a nominal group technique, participants in this panel were as follows: (1) surveyed for current practices; (2) presented with a detailed systematic review of the relevant literature; (3) given the opportunity to voice opinion collectively; and (4) asked to vote regarding preferences privately. Round 1 was conducted using an electronic survey. Initial results were compiled and discussed face-to-face. Round 2 was conducted using the Audience Response System, allowing participants to vote for (strongly support or support) or against inclusion of each intervention. Agreement >80{\%} was considered consensus. Interventions without consensus were discussed and revised, if feasible. Repeat voting for consensus was performed. RESULTS: Consensus was reached to support 14 SSI prevention strategies and all participants agreed to implement the BPG in their practices. All agreed to participate in further studies assessing implementation and effectiveness of the BPG. The final consensus driven BPG for high-risk pediatric spine surgery patients includes: (1) patients should have a chlorhexidine skin wash the night before surgery; (2) patients should have preoperative urine cultures obtained; (3) patients should receive a preoperative Patient Education Sheet; (4) patients should have a preoperative nutritional assessment; (5) if removing hair, clipping is preferred to shaving; (6) patients should receive perioperative intravenous cefazolin; (7) patients should receive perioperative intravenous prophylaxis for gram-negative bacilli; (8) adherence to perioperative antimicrobial regimens should be monitored; (9) operating room access should be limited during scoliosis surgery (whenever practical); (10) UV lights need NOT be used in the operating room; (11) patients should have intraoperative wound irrigation; (12) vancomycin powder should be used in the bone graft and/or the surgical site; (13) impervious dressings are preferred postoperatively; (14) postoperative dressing changes should be minimized before discharge to the extent possible. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, we present a consensus-based BPG consisting of 14 recommendations for the prevention of SSIs after spine surgery in high-risk pediatric patients. This can serve as a tool to reduce the variability in practice in this area and help guide research priorities in the future. Pending such data, it is the unsubstantiated opinion of the authors of the current paper that adherence to recommendations in the BPG will not only decrease variability in practice but also result in fewer SSI in high-risk children undergoing spinal fusion. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Not applicable.",
keywords = "Guideline, High risk, Infection, Outcomes, Scoliosis, Spine, SSI, Surgical site infection",
author = "Vitale, {Michael G.} and Riedel, {Matthew D.} and Glotzbecker, {Michael P.} and Hiroko Matsumoto and Roye, {David P.} and Akbarnia, {Behrooz A.} and Anderson, {Richard C E} and Brockmeyer, {Douglas L.} and Emans, {John B.} and Mark Erickson and Flynn, {John M.} and Lenke, {Lawrence G.} and Lewis, {Stephen J.} and Luhmann, {Scott J.} and McLeod, {Lisa M.} and Newton, {Peter O.} and Nyquist, {Ann Christine} and Richards, {B. Stephens} and Shah, {Suken A.} and Skaggs, {David L.} and Smith, {John T.} and Sponseller, {Paul David} and Sucato, {Daniel J.} and Zeller, {Reinhard D.} and Lisa Saiman",
year = "2013",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1097/BPO.0b013e3182840de2",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "33",
pages = "471--478",
journal = "Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics",
issn = "0271-6798",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Building consensus

T2 - Development of a best practice guideline (BPG) for surgical site infection (SSI) prevention in high-risk pediatric spine surgery

AU - Vitale, Michael G.

AU - Riedel, Matthew D.

AU - Glotzbecker, Michael P.

AU - Matsumoto, Hiroko

AU - Roye, David P.

AU - Akbarnia, Behrooz A.

AU - Anderson, Richard C E

AU - Brockmeyer, Douglas L.

AU - Emans, John B.

AU - Erickson, Mark

AU - Flynn, John M.

AU - Lenke, Lawrence G.

AU - Lewis, Stephen J.

AU - Luhmann, Scott J.

AU - McLeod, Lisa M.

AU - Newton, Peter O.

AU - Nyquist, Ann Christine

AU - Richards, B. Stephens

AU - Shah, Suken A.

AU - Skaggs, David L.

AU - Smith, John T.

AU - Sponseller, Paul David

AU - Sucato, Daniel J.

AU - Zeller, Reinhard D.

AU - Saiman, Lisa

PY - 2013/7

Y1 - 2013/7

N2 - BACKGROUND: Perioperative surgical site infection (SSI) after pediatric spine fusion is a recognized complication with rates between 0.5% and 1.6% in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis and up to 22% in "high risk" patients. Significant variation in the approach to infection prophylaxis has been well documented. The purpose of this initiative is to develop a consensus-based "Best Practice" Guideline (BPG), informed by both the available evidence in the literature and expert opinion, for high-risk pediatric patients undergoing spine fusion. For the purpose of this effort, high risk was defined as anything other than a primary fusion in a patient with idiopathic scoliosis without significant comorbidities. The ultimate goal of this initiative is to decrease the wide variability in SSI prevention strategies in this area, ultimately leading to improved patient outcomes and reduced health care costs. METHODS: An expert panel composed of 20 pediatric spine surgeons and 3 infectious disease specialists from North America, selected for their extensive experience in the field of pediatric spine surgery, was developed. Using the Delphi process and iterative rounds using a nominal group technique, participants in this panel were as follows: (1) surveyed for current practices; (2) presented with a detailed systematic review of the relevant literature; (3) given the opportunity to voice opinion collectively; and (4) asked to vote regarding preferences privately. Round 1 was conducted using an electronic survey. Initial results were compiled and discussed face-to-face. Round 2 was conducted using the Audience Response System, allowing participants to vote for (strongly support or support) or against inclusion of each intervention. Agreement >80% was considered consensus. Interventions without consensus were discussed and revised, if feasible. Repeat voting for consensus was performed. RESULTS: Consensus was reached to support 14 SSI prevention strategies and all participants agreed to implement the BPG in their practices. All agreed to participate in further studies assessing implementation and effectiveness of the BPG. The final consensus driven BPG for high-risk pediatric spine surgery patients includes: (1) patients should have a chlorhexidine skin wash the night before surgery; (2) patients should have preoperative urine cultures obtained; (3) patients should receive a preoperative Patient Education Sheet; (4) patients should have a preoperative nutritional assessment; (5) if removing hair, clipping is preferred to shaving; (6) patients should receive perioperative intravenous cefazolin; (7) patients should receive perioperative intravenous prophylaxis for gram-negative bacilli; (8) adherence to perioperative antimicrobial regimens should be monitored; (9) operating room access should be limited during scoliosis surgery (whenever practical); (10) UV lights need NOT be used in the operating room; (11) patients should have intraoperative wound irrigation; (12) vancomycin powder should be used in the bone graft and/or the surgical site; (13) impervious dressings are preferred postoperatively; (14) postoperative dressing changes should be minimized before discharge to the extent possible. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, we present a consensus-based BPG consisting of 14 recommendations for the prevention of SSIs after spine surgery in high-risk pediatric patients. This can serve as a tool to reduce the variability in practice in this area and help guide research priorities in the future. Pending such data, it is the unsubstantiated opinion of the authors of the current paper that adherence to recommendations in the BPG will not only decrease variability in practice but also result in fewer SSI in high-risk children undergoing spinal fusion. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Not applicable.

AB - BACKGROUND: Perioperative surgical site infection (SSI) after pediatric spine fusion is a recognized complication with rates between 0.5% and 1.6% in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis and up to 22% in "high risk" patients. Significant variation in the approach to infection prophylaxis has been well documented. The purpose of this initiative is to develop a consensus-based "Best Practice" Guideline (BPG), informed by both the available evidence in the literature and expert opinion, for high-risk pediatric patients undergoing spine fusion. For the purpose of this effort, high risk was defined as anything other than a primary fusion in a patient with idiopathic scoliosis without significant comorbidities. The ultimate goal of this initiative is to decrease the wide variability in SSI prevention strategies in this area, ultimately leading to improved patient outcomes and reduced health care costs. METHODS: An expert panel composed of 20 pediatric spine surgeons and 3 infectious disease specialists from North America, selected for their extensive experience in the field of pediatric spine surgery, was developed. Using the Delphi process and iterative rounds using a nominal group technique, participants in this panel were as follows: (1) surveyed for current practices; (2) presented with a detailed systematic review of the relevant literature; (3) given the opportunity to voice opinion collectively; and (4) asked to vote regarding preferences privately. Round 1 was conducted using an electronic survey. Initial results were compiled and discussed face-to-face. Round 2 was conducted using the Audience Response System, allowing participants to vote for (strongly support or support) or against inclusion of each intervention. Agreement >80% was considered consensus. Interventions without consensus were discussed and revised, if feasible. Repeat voting for consensus was performed. RESULTS: Consensus was reached to support 14 SSI prevention strategies and all participants agreed to implement the BPG in their practices. All agreed to participate in further studies assessing implementation and effectiveness of the BPG. The final consensus driven BPG for high-risk pediatric spine surgery patients includes: (1) patients should have a chlorhexidine skin wash the night before surgery; (2) patients should have preoperative urine cultures obtained; (3) patients should receive a preoperative Patient Education Sheet; (4) patients should have a preoperative nutritional assessment; (5) if removing hair, clipping is preferred to shaving; (6) patients should receive perioperative intravenous cefazolin; (7) patients should receive perioperative intravenous prophylaxis for gram-negative bacilli; (8) adherence to perioperative antimicrobial regimens should be monitored; (9) operating room access should be limited during scoliosis surgery (whenever practical); (10) UV lights need NOT be used in the operating room; (11) patients should have intraoperative wound irrigation; (12) vancomycin powder should be used in the bone graft and/or the surgical site; (13) impervious dressings are preferred postoperatively; (14) postoperative dressing changes should be minimized before discharge to the extent possible. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, we present a consensus-based BPG consisting of 14 recommendations for the prevention of SSIs after spine surgery in high-risk pediatric patients. This can serve as a tool to reduce the variability in practice in this area and help guide research priorities in the future. Pending such data, it is the unsubstantiated opinion of the authors of the current paper that adherence to recommendations in the BPG will not only decrease variability in practice but also result in fewer SSI in high-risk children undergoing spinal fusion. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Not applicable.

KW - Guideline

KW - High risk

KW - Infection

KW - Outcomes

KW - Scoliosis

KW - Spine

KW - SSI

KW - Surgical site infection

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84879863606&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84879863606&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/BPO.0b013e3182840de2

DO - 10.1097/BPO.0b013e3182840de2

M3 - Article

C2 - 23752142

AN - SCOPUS:84879863606

VL - 33

SP - 471

EP - 478

JO - Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics

JF - Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics

SN - 0271-6798

IS - 5

ER -