Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls

Bhart Anjan S Bhullar, Jesús Marugán-Lobón, Fernando Racimo, Gaberiel Bever, Timothy B. Rowe, Mark A. Norell, Arhat Abzhanov

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The interplay of evolution and development has been at the heart of evolutionary theory for more than a century. Heterochrony-change in the timing or rate of developmental events-has been implicated in the evolution of major vertebrate lineages such as mammals, including humans. Birds are the most speciose land vertebrates, with more than 10,000 living species representing a bewildering array of ecologies. Their anatomy is radically different from that of other vertebrates. The unique bird skull houses two highly specialized systems: the sophisticated visual and neuromuscular coordination system allows flight coordination and exploitation of diverse visual landscapes, and the astonishing variations of the beak enable a wide range of avian lifestyles. Here we use a geometric morphometric approach integrating developmental, neontological and palaeontological data to show that the heterochronic process of paedomorphosis, by which descendants resemble the juveniles of their ancestors, is responsible for several major evolutionary transitions in the origin of birds. We analysed the variability of a series of landmarks on all known theropod dinosaur skull ontogenies as well as outgroups and birds. The first dimension of variability captured ontogeny, indicating a conserved ontogenetic trajectory. The second dimension accounted for phylogenetic change towards more bird-like dinosaurs. Basally branching eumaniraptorans and avialans clustered with embryos of other archosaurs, indicating paedomorphosis. Our results reveal at least four paedomorphic episodes in the history of birds combined with localized peramorphosis (development beyond the adult state of ancestors) in the beak. Paedomorphic enlargement of the eyes and associated brain regions parallels the enlargement of the nasal cavity and olfactory brain in mammals. This study can be a model for investigations of heterochrony in evolutionary transitions, illuminating the origin of adaptive features and inspiring studies of developmental mechanisms.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)223-226
Number of pages4
JournalNature
Volume487
Issue number7406
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 12 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Dinosaurs
Skull
Birds
Beak
Vertebrates
Mammals
Nasal Cavity
Ecology
Life Style
Anatomy
Embryonic Structures
History
Brain

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)
  • General

Cite this

Bhullar, B. A. S., Marugán-Lobón, J., Racimo, F., Bever, G., Rowe, T. B., Norell, M. A., & Abzhanov, A. (2012). Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls. Nature, 487(7406), 223-226. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11146

Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls. / Bhullar, Bhart Anjan S; Marugán-Lobón, Jesús; Racimo, Fernando; Bever, Gaberiel; Rowe, Timothy B.; Norell, Mark A.; Abzhanov, Arhat.

In: Nature, Vol. 487, No. 7406, 12.07.2012, p. 223-226.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bhullar, BAS, Marugán-Lobón, J, Racimo, F, Bever, G, Rowe, TB, Norell, MA & Abzhanov, A 2012, 'Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls', Nature, vol. 487, no. 7406, pp. 223-226. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11146
Bhullar BAS, Marugán-Lobón J, Racimo F, Bever G, Rowe TB, Norell MA et al. Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls. Nature. 2012 Jul 12;487(7406):223-226. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11146
Bhullar, Bhart Anjan S ; Marugán-Lobón, Jesús ; Racimo, Fernando ; Bever, Gaberiel ; Rowe, Timothy B. ; Norell, Mark A. ; Abzhanov, Arhat. / Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls. In: Nature. 2012 ; Vol. 487, No. 7406. pp. 223-226.
@article{e27fd3f5e2254b74aca139a9fb709eff,
title = "Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls",
abstract = "The interplay of evolution and development has been at the heart of evolutionary theory for more than a century. Heterochrony-change in the timing or rate of developmental events-has been implicated in the evolution of major vertebrate lineages such as mammals, including humans. Birds are the most speciose land vertebrates, with more than 10,000 living species representing a bewildering array of ecologies. Their anatomy is radically different from that of other vertebrates. The unique bird skull houses two highly specialized systems: the sophisticated visual and neuromuscular coordination system allows flight coordination and exploitation of diverse visual landscapes, and the astonishing variations of the beak enable a wide range of avian lifestyles. Here we use a geometric morphometric approach integrating developmental, neontological and palaeontological data to show that the heterochronic process of paedomorphosis, by which descendants resemble the juveniles of their ancestors, is responsible for several major evolutionary transitions in the origin of birds. We analysed the variability of a series of landmarks on all known theropod dinosaur skull ontogenies as well as outgroups and birds. The first dimension of variability captured ontogeny, indicating a conserved ontogenetic trajectory. The second dimension accounted for phylogenetic change towards more bird-like dinosaurs. Basally branching eumaniraptorans and avialans clustered with embryos of other archosaurs, indicating paedomorphosis. Our results reveal at least four paedomorphic episodes in the history of birds combined with localized peramorphosis (development beyond the adult state of ancestors) in the beak. Paedomorphic enlargement of the eyes and associated brain regions parallels the enlargement of the nasal cavity and olfactory brain in mammals. This study can be a model for investigations of heterochrony in evolutionary transitions, illuminating the origin of adaptive features and inspiring studies of developmental mechanisms.",
author = "Bhullar, {Bhart Anjan S} and Jes{\'u}s Marug{\'a}n-Lob{\'o}n and Fernando Racimo and Gaberiel Bever and Rowe, {Timothy B.} and Norell, {Mark A.} and Arhat Abzhanov",
year = "2012",
month = "7",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1038/nature11146",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "487",
pages = "223--226",
journal = "Nature",
issn = "0028-0836",
publisher = "Nature Publishing Group",
number = "7406",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Birds have paedomorphic dinosaur skulls

AU - Bhullar, Bhart Anjan S

AU - Marugán-Lobón, Jesús

AU - Racimo, Fernando

AU - Bever, Gaberiel

AU - Rowe, Timothy B.

AU - Norell, Mark A.

AU - Abzhanov, Arhat

PY - 2012/7/12

Y1 - 2012/7/12

N2 - The interplay of evolution and development has been at the heart of evolutionary theory for more than a century. Heterochrony-change in the timing or rate of developmental events-has been implicated in the evolution of major vertebrate lineages such as mammals, including humans. Birds are the most speciose land vertebrates, with more than 10,000 living species representing a bewildering array of ecologies. Their anatomy is radically different from that of other vertebrates. The unique bird skull houses two highly specialized systems: the sophisticated visual and neuromuscular coordination system allows flight coordination and exploitation of diverse visual landscapes, and the astonishing variations of the beak enable a wide range of avian lifestyles. Here we use a geometric morphometric approach integrating developmental, neontological and palaeontological data to show that the heterochronic process of paedomorphosis, by which descendants resemble the juveniles of their ancestors, is responsible for several major evolutionary transitions in the origin of birds. We analysed the variability of a series of landmarks on all known theropod dinosaur skull ontogenies as well as outgroups and birds. The first dimension of variability captured ontogeny, indicating a conserved ontogenetic trajectory. The second dimension accounted for phylogenetic change towards more bird-like dinosaurs. Basally branching eumaniraptorans and avialans clustered with embryos of other archosaurs, indicating paedomorphosis. Our results reveal at least four paedomorphic episodes in the history of birds combined with localized peramorphosis (development beyond the adult state of ancestors) in the beak. Paedomorphic enlargement of the eyes and associated brain regions parallels the enlargement of the nasal cavity and olfactory brain in mammals. This study can be a model for investigations of heterochrony in evolutionary transitions, illuminating the origin of adaptive features and inspiring studies of developmental mechanisms.

AB - The interplay of evolution and development has been at the heart of evolutionary theory for more than a century. Heterochrony-change in the timing or rate of developmental events-has been implicated in the evolution of major vertebrate lineages such as mammals, including humans. Birds are the most speciose land vertebrates, with more than 10,000 living species representing a bewildering array of ecologies. Their anatomy is radically different from that of other vertebrates. The unique bird skull houses two highly specialized systems: the sophisticated visual and neuromuscular coordination system allows flight coordination and exploitation of diverse visual landscapes, and the astonishing variations of the beak enable a wide range of avian lifestyles. Here we use a geometric morphometric approach integrating developmental, neontological and palaeontological data to show that the heterochronic process of paedomorphosis, by which descendants resemble the juveniles of their ancestors, is responsible for several major evolutionary transitions in the origin of birds. We analysed the variability of a series of landmarks on all known theropod dinosaur skull ontogenies as well as outgroups and birds. The first dimension of variability captured ontogeny, indicating a conserved ontogenetic trajectory. The second dimension accounted for phylogenetic change towards more bird-like dinosaurs. Basally branching eumaniraptorans and avialans clustered with embryos of other archosaurs, indicating paedomorphosis. Our results reveal at least four paedomorphic episodes in the history of birds combined with localized peramorphosis (development beyond the adult state of ancestors) in the beak. Paedomorphic enlargement of the eyes and associated brain regions parallels the enlargement of the nasal cavity and olfactory brain in mammals. This study can be a model for investigations of heterochrony in evolutionary transitions, illuminating the origin of adaptive features and inspiring studies of developmental mechanisms.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84863725587&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84863725587&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1038/nature11146

DO - 10.1038/nature11146

M3 - Article

C2 - 22722850

AN - SCOPUS:84863725587

VL - 487

SP - 223

EP - 226

JO - Nature

JF - Nature

SN - 0028-0836

IS - 7406

ER -