Association of Skin and Cartilage Variables with Composite Graft Healing in a Rabbit Model

Guanning Lu, Ossama Tawfik, Kevin Sykes, J. David Kriet, Dianne Durham, Clinton D. Humphrey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Importance: Composite grafting in nasal reconstruction involves transplanting auricular chondrocutaneous grafts, but the optimal design of these grafts is unknown. Objectives: To investigate the ideal ratio of skin to cartilage as well as study the importance of the perichondrial attachment for graft survival. Design, Setting, and Participants: A New England white rabbit model was used in this study, performed at the Laboratory for Animal Research at University of Kansas Medical Center from January 25 to March 18, 2016. Four varying designs of chondrocutaneous auricular grafts were transplanted to dorsal back defects, with a total of 10 grafts per treatment arm completed. The following 4 chondrocutaneous circular grafts were designed: group A, 1.5-cm diameter graft of equal skin to cartilage ratio; group B, 2.0-cm diameter skin and 1.5-cm diameter cartilage; group C, 1.5-cm diameter skin and 2.0-cm diameter cartilage; and group D, 1.5-cm diameter skin and cartilage separated and placed back together in a layered fashion. Grafts were observed until postoperative day 21, harvested, and evaluated with visual observation as well as histopathologic assessment. Main Outcomes and Measures: Visually graded areas of survival were marked by 2 blinded academic facial plastic surgeons and calculated for approximate survival. Hematoxylin-eosin-stained, paraffin-embedded 5-μm slides were evaluated for overall survival rate, rate of cartilage necrosis, and mean vessel density per high-power field. In both cases, observers were blinded as to the study group. Results: Visual assessments of the 5 female rabbits showed significant agreement between surgeons and consistency, with a Spearman coefficient of 0.84 and an intraclass correlation of 0.98. Group D (skin and cartilage separation) was visually graded to have significantly decreased mean survival (45.4%; 95% CI, 23.3%-67.4%) compared with group A (mean survival, 97.4%; 95% CI, 94.8%-99.9%; P <.001), group B (mean survival, 87.6%; 95% CI, 69.9%-100%; P =.004), and group C (mean survival, 82.1%; 95% CI, 66.0%-98.1%; P =.008). Histopathologic assessment revealed that group D again showed significantly inferior overall survival, increased cartilage necrosis, and decreased mean vessel density compared with group A. Group C additionally showed significantly decreased cartilage survival compared with group A (65% vs 0%; P <.001) and group B (65% vs 35%; P =.02). Conclusions and Relevance: These results represent preliminary evidence that the attachment of skin to perichondrium in a composite graft plays an important role for graft survival. Clinicians performing nasal reconstruction with chondrocutaneous composite grafts should consider preserving attachments at this junction to improve graft survival. Levels of Evidence: NA.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)44-49
Number of pages6
JournalJAMA Facial Plastic Surgery
Volume21
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Cartilage
Rabbits
Transplants
Skin
Graft Survival
Nose
Necrosis
New England
Laboratory Animals
Hematoxylin
Eosine Yellowish-(YS)
Paraffin
Arm
Observation
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)
Research

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Association of Skin and Cartilage Variables with Composite Graft Healing in a Rabbit Model. / Lu, Guanning; Tawfik, Ossama; Sykes, Kevin; Kriet, J. David; Durham, Dianne; Humphrey, Clinton D.

In: JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, Vol. 21, No. 1, 01.01.2019, p. 44-49.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lu, Guanning ; Tawfik, Ossama ; Sykes, Kevin ; Kriet, J. David ; Durham, Dianne ; Humphrey, Clinton D. / Association of Skin and Cartilage Variables with Composite Graft Healing in a Rabbit Model. In: JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery. 2019 ; Vol. 21, No. 1. pp. 44-49.
@article{9c057a8d1c764f808f7142e691869e7c,
title = "Association of Skin and Cartilage Variables with Composite Graft Healing in a Rabbit Model",
abstract = "Importance: Composite grafting in nasal reconstruction involves transplanting auricular chondrocutaneous grafts, but the optimal design of these grafts is unknown. Objectives: To investigate the ideal ratio of skin to cartilage as well as study the importance of the perichondrial attachment for graft survival. Design, Setting, and Participants: A New England white rabbit model was used in this study, performed at the Laboratory for Animal Research at University of Kansas Medical Center from January 25 to March 18, 2016. Four varying designs of chondrocutaneous auricular grafts were transplanted to dorsal back defects, with a total of 10 grafts per treatment arm completed. The following 4 chondrocutaneous circular grafts were designed: group A, 1.5-cm diameter graft of equal skin to cartilage ratio; group B, 2.0-cm diameter skin and 1.5-cm diameter cartilage; group C, 1.5-cm diameter skin and 2.0-cm diameter cartilage; and group D, 1.5-cm diameter skin and cartilage separated and placed back together in a layered fashion. Grafts were observed until postoperative day 21, harvested, and evaluated with visual observation as well as histopathologic assessment. Main Outcomes and Measures: Visually graded areas of survival were marked by 2 blinded academic facial plastic surgeons and calculated for approximate survival. Hematoxylin-eosin-stained, paraffin-embedded 5-μm slides were evaluated for overall survival rate, rate of cartilage necrosis, and mean vessel density per high-power field. In both cases, observers were blinded as to the study group. Results: Visual assessments of the 5 female rabbits showed significant agreement between surgeons and consistency, with a Spearman coefficient of 0.84 and an intraclass correlation of 0.98. Group D (skin and cartilage separation) was visually graded to have significantly decreased mean survival (45.4{\%}; 95{\%} CI, 23.3{\%}-67.4{\%}) compared with group A (mean survival, 97.4{\%}; 95{\%} CI, 94.8{\%}-99.9{\%}; P <.001), group B (mean survival, 87.6{\%}; 95{\%} CI, 69.9{\%}-100{\%}; P =.004), and group C (mean survival, 82.1{\%}; 95{\%} CI, 66.0{\%}-98.1{\%}; P =.008). Histopathologic assessment revealed that group D again showed significantly inferior overall survival, increased cartilage necrosis, and decreased mean vessel density compared with group A. Group C additionally showed significantly decreased cartilage survival compared with group A (65{\%} vs 0{\%}; P <.001) and group B (65{\%} vs 35{\%}; P =.02). Conclusions and Relevance: These results represent preliminary evidence that the attachment of skin to perichondrium in a composite graft plays an important role for graft survival. Clinicians performing nasal reconstruction with chondrocutaneous composite grafts should consider preserving attachments at this junction to improve graft survival. Levels of Evidence: NA.",
author = "Guanning Lu and Ossama Tawfik and Kevin Sykes and Kriet, {J. David} and Dianne Durham and Humphrey, {Clinton D.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1001/jamafacial.2018.1044",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "21",
pages = "44--49",
journal = "JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery",
issn = "2168-6076",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Association of Skin and Cartilage Variables with Composite Graft Healing in a Rabbit Model

AU - Lu, Guanning

AU - Tawfik, Ossama

AU - Sykes, Kevin

AU - Kriet, J. David

AU - Durham, Dianne

AU - Humphrey, Clinton D.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Importance: Composite grafting in nasal reconstruction involves transplanting auricular chondrocutaneous grafts, but the optimal design of these grafts is unknown. Objectives: To investigate the ideal ratio of skin to cartilage as well as study the importance of the perichondrial attachment for graft survival. Design, Setting, and Participants: A New England white rabbit model was used in this study, performed at the Laboratory for Animal Research at University of Kansas Medical Center from January 25 to March 18, 2016. Four varying designs of chondrocutaneous auricular grafts were transplanted to dorsal back defects, with a total of 10 grafts per treatment arm completed. The following 4 chondrocutaneous circular grafts were designed: group A, 1.5-cm diameter graft of equal skin to cartilage ratio; group B, 2.0-cm diameter skin and 1.5-cm diameter cartilage; group C, 1.5-cm diameter skin and 2.0-cm diameter cartilage; and group D, 1.5-cm diameter skin and cartilage separated and placed back together in a layered fashion. Grafts were observed until postoperative day 21, harvested, and evaluated with visual observation as well as histopathologic assessment. Main Outcomes and Measures: Visually graded areas of survival were marked by 2 blinded academic facial plastic surgeons and calculated for approximate survival. Hematoxylin-eosin-stained, paraffin-embedded 5-μm slides were evaluated for overall survival rate, rate of cartilage necrosis, and mean vessel density per high-power field. In both cases, observers were blinded as to the study group. Results: Visual assessments of the 5 female rabbits showed significant agreement between surgeons and consistency, with a Spearman coefficient of 0.84 and an intraclass correlation of 0.98. Group D (skin and cartilage separation) was visually graded to have significantly decreased mean survival (45.4%; 95% CI, 23.3%-67.4%) compared with group A (mean survival, 97.4%; 95% CI, 94.8%-99.9%; P <.001), group B (mean survival, 87.6%; 95% CI, 69.9%-100%; P =.004), and group C (mean survival, 82.1%; 95% CI, 66.0%-98.1%; P =.008). Histopathologic assessment revealed that group D again showed significantly inferior overall survival, increased cartilage necrosis, and decreased mean vessel density compared with group A. Group C additionally showed significantly decreased cartilage survival compared with group A (65% vs 0%; P <.001) and group B (65% vs 35%; P =.02). Conclusions and Relevance: These results represent preliminary evidence that the attachment of skin to perichondrium in a composite graft plays an important role for graft survival. Clinicians performing nasal reconstruction with chondrocutaneous composite grafts should consider preserving attachments at this junction to improve graft survival. Levels of Evidence: NA.

AB - Importance: Composite grafting in nasal reconstruction involves transplanting auricular chondrocutaneous grafts, but the optimal design of these grafts is unknown. Objectives: To investigate the ideal ratio of skin to cartilage as well as study the importance of the perichondrial attachment for graft survival. Design, Setting, and Participants: A New England white rabbit model was used in this study, performed at the Laboratory for Animal Research at University of Kansas Medical Center from January 25 to March 18, 2016. Four varying designs of chondrocutaneous auricular grafts were transplanted to dorsal back defects, with a total of 10 grafts per treatment arm completed. The following 4 chondrocutaneous circular grafts were designed: group A, 1.5-cm diameter graft of equal skin to cartilage ratio; group B, 2.0-cm diameter skin and 1.5-cm diameter cartilage; group C, 1.5-cm diameter skin and 2.0-cm diameter cartilage; and group D, 1.5-cm diameter skin and cartilage separated and placed back together in a layered fashion. Grafts were observed until postoperative day 21, harvested, and evaluated with visual observation as well as histopathologic assessment. Main Outcomes and Measures: Visually graded areas of survival were marked by 2 blinded academic facial plastic surgeons and calculated for approximate survival. Hematoxylin-eosin-stained, paraffin-embedded 5-μm slides were evaluated for overall survival rate, rate of cartilage necrosis, and mean vessel density per high-power field. In both cases, observers were blinded as to the study group. Results: Visual assessments of the 5 female rabbits showed significant agreement between surgeons and consistency, with a Spearman coefficient of 0.84 and an intraclass correlation of 0.98. Group D (skin and cartilage separation) was visually graded to have significantly decreased mean survival (45.4%; 95% CI, 23.3%-67.4%) compared with group A (mean survival, 97.4%; 95% CI, 94.8%-99.9%; P <.001), group B (mean survival, 87.6%; 95% CI, 69.9%-100%; P =.004), and group C (mean survival, 82.1%; 95% CI, 66.0%-98.1%; P =.008). Histopathologic assessment revealed that group D again showed significantly inferior overall survival, increased cartilage necrosis, and decreased mean vessel density compared with group A. Group C additionally showed significantly decreased cartilage survival compared with group A (65% vs 0%; P <.001) and group B (65% vs 35%; P =.02). Conclusions and Relevance: These results represent preliminary evidence that the attachment of skin to perichondrium in a composite graft plays an important role for graft survival. Clinicians performing nasal reconstruction with chondrocutaneous composite grafts should consider preserving attachments at this junction to improve graft survival. Levels of Evidence: NA.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85054173640&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85054173640&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1001/jamafacial.2018.1044

DO - 10.1001/jamafacial.2018.1044

M3 - Article

C2 - 30267065

AN - SCOPUS:85054173640

VL - 21

SP - 44

EP - 49

JO - JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery

JF - JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery

SN - 2168-6076

IS - 1

ER -