An assessment of the limits of detection, sensitivity and specificity of three devices for public health-based drug checking of fentanyl in street-acquired samples

Traci C. Green, Ju Nyeong Park, Michael Gilbert, Michelle McKenzie, Eric Struth, Rachel Lucas, William Clarke, Susan G. Sherman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Fentanyl has caused rapid increases in US and Canadian overdose deaths, yet its presence in illicit drugs is often unknown to consumers. This study examined the validity in identifying the presence of fentanyl of three portable devices that could be used in providing drug checking services and drug supply surveillance: fentanyl test strips, a hand-held Raman Spectrometer, and a desktop Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectrometer. Methods: In Fall 2017, we first undertook an assessment of the limits of detection for fentanyl, then tested the three devices’ sensitivity and specificity in distinguishing fentanyl in street-acquired drug samples. Utilizing test replicates of standard fentanyl reference material over a range of increasingly lower concentrations, we determined the lowest concentration reliably detected. To establish the sensitivity and specificity for fentanyl, 210 samples (106 fentanyl-positive, 104 fentanyl-negative) previously submitted by law enforcement entities to forensic laboratories in Baltimore, Maryland, and Providence, Rhode Island, were tested using the devices. All sample testing followed parallel and standardized protocols in the two labs. Results: The lowest limit of detection (0.100 mcg/mL), false negative (3.7%), and false positive rate (9.6%) was found for fentanyl test strips, which also correctly detected two fentanyl analogs (acetyl fentanyl and furanyl fentanyl) alone or in the presence of another drug, in both powder and pill forms. While less sensitive and specific for fentanyl, the other devices conveyed additional relevant information including the percentage of fentanyl and presence of cutting agents and other drugs. Conclusion: Devices for fentanyl drug checking are available and valid. Drug checking services and drug supply surveillance should be considered and researched as part of public health responses to the opioid overdose crisis.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number102661
JournalInternational Journal of Drug Policy
Volume77
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 2020

Fingerprint

Fentanyl
Limit of Detection
Public Health
Sensitivity and Specificity
Equipment and Supplies
Pharmaceutical Preparations
Street Drugs
Law Enforcement
Baltimore
Fourier Analysis
Powders
Opioid Analgesics

Keywords

  • Drug checking
  • Fentanyl
  • Harm reduction
  • Overdose
  • Public health
  • Surveillance

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine (miscellaneous)
  • Health Policy

Cite this

An assessment of the limits of detection, sensitivity and specificity of three devices for public health-based drug checking of fentanyl in street-acquired samples. / Green, Traci C.; Park, Ju Nyeong; Gilbert, Michael; McKenzie, Michelle; Struth, Eric; Lucas, Rachel; Clarke, William; Sherman, Susan G.

In: International Journal of Drug Policy, Vol. 77, 102661, 03.2020.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Green, Traci C. ; Park, Ju Nyeong ; Gilbert, Michael ; McKenzie, Michelle ; Struth, Eric ; Lucas, Rachel ; Clarke, William ; Sherman, Susan G. / An assessment of the limits of detection, sensitivity and specificity of three devices for public health-based drug checking of fentanyl in street-acquired samples. In: International Journal of Drug Policy. 2020 ; Vol. 77.
@article{559b4197958a4ec597e8ed3e828f559b,
title = "An assessment of the limits of detection, sensitivity and specificity of three devices for public health-based drug checking of fentanyl in street-acquired samples",
abstract = "Background: Fentanyl has caused rapid increases in US and Canadian overdose deaths, yet its presence in illicit drugs is often unknown to consumers. This study examined the validity in identifying the presence of fentanyl of three portable devices that could be used in providing drug checking services and drug supply surveillance: fentanyl test strips, a hand-held Raman Spectrometer, and a desktop Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectrometer. Methods: In Fall 2017, we first undertook an assessment of the limits of detection for fentanyl, then tested the three devices’ sensitivity and specificity in distinguishing fentanyl in street-acquired drug samples. Utilizing test replicates of standard fentanyl reference material over a range of increasingly lower concentrations, we determined the lowest concentration reliably detected. To establish the sensitivity and specificity for fentanyl, 210 samples (106 fentanyl-positive, 104 fentanyl-negative) previously submitted by law enforcement entities to forensic laboratories in Baltimore, Maryland, and Providence, Rhode Island, were tested using the devices. All sample testing followed parallel and standardized protocols in the two labs. Results: The lowest limit of detection (0.100 mcg/mL), false negative (3.7{\%}), and false positive rate (9.6{\%}) was found for fentanyl test strips, which also correctly detected two fentanyl analogs (acetyl fentanyl and furanyl fentanyl) alone or in the presence of another drug, in both powder and pill forms. While less sensitive and specific for fentanyl, the other devices conveyed additional relevant information including the percentage of fentanyl and presence of cutting agents and other drugs. Conclusion: Devices for fentanyl drug checking are available and valid. Drug checking services and drug supply surveillance should be considered and researched as part of public health responses to the opioid overdose crisis.",
keywords = "Drug checking, Fentanyl, Harm reduction, Overdose, Public health, Surveillance",
author = "Green, {Traci C.} and Park, {Ju Nyeong} and Michael Gilbert and Michelle McKenzie and Eric Struth and Rachel Lucas and William Clarke and Sherman, {Susan G.}",
year = "2020",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1016/j.drugpo.2020.102661",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "77",
journal = "International Journal of Drug Policy",
issn = "0955-3959",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - An assessment of the limits of detection, sensitivity and specificity of three devices for public health-based drug checking of fentanyl in street-acquired samples

AU - Green, Traci C.

AU - Park, Ju Nyeong

AU - Gilbert, Michael

AU - McKenzie, Michelle

AU - Struth, Eric

AU - Lucas, Rachel

AU - Clarke, William

AU - Sherman, Susan G.

PY - 2020/3

Y1 - 2020/3

N2 - Background: Fentanyl has caused rapid increases in US and Canadian overdose deaths, yet its presence in illicit drugs is often unknown to consumers. This study examined the validity in identifying the presence of fentanyl of three portable devices that could be used in providing drug checking services and drug supply surveillance: fentanyl test strips, a hand-held Raman Spectrometer, and a desktop Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectrometer. Methods: In Fall 2017, we first undertook an assessment of the limits of detection for fentanyl, then tested the three devices’ sensitivity and specificity in distinguishing fentanyl in street-acquired drug samples. Utilizing test replicates of standard fentanyl reference material over a range of increasingly lower concentrations, we determined the lowest concentration reliably detected. To establish the sensitivity and specificity for fentanyl, 210 samples (106 fentanyl-positive, 104 fentanyl-negative) previously submitted by law enforcement entities to forensic laboratories in Baltimore, Maryland, and Providence, Rhode Island, were tested using the devices. All sample testing followed parallel and standardized protocols in the two labs. Results: The lowest limit of detection (0.100 mcg/mL), false negative (3.7%), and false positive rate (9.6%) was found for fentanyl test strips, which also correctly detected two fentanyl analogs (acetyl fentanyl and furanyl fentanyl) alone or in the presence of another drug, in both powder and pill forms. While less sensitive and specific for fentanyl, the other devices conveyed additional relevant information including the percentage of fentanyl and presence of cutting agents and other drugs. Conclusion: Devices for fentanyl drug checking are available and valid. Drug checking services and drug supply surveillance should be considered and researched as part of public health responses to the opioid overdose crisis.

AB - Background: Fentanyl has caused rapid increases in US and Canadian overdose deaths, yet its presence in illicit drugs is often unknown to consumers. This study examined the validity in identifying the presence of fentanyl of three portable devices that could be used in providing drug checking services and drug supply surveillance: fentanyl test strips, a hand-held Raman Spectrometer, and a desktop Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectrometer. Methods: In Fall 2017, we first undertook an assessment of the limits of detection for fentanyl, then tested the three devices’ sensitivity and specificity in distinguishing fentanyl in street-acquired drug samples. Utilizing test replicates of standard fentanyl reference material over a range of increasingly lower concentrations, we determined the lowest concentration reliably detected. To establish the sensitivity and specificity for fentanyl, 210 samples (106 fentanyl-positive, 104 fentanyl-negative) previously submitted by law enforcement entities to forensic laboratories in Baltimore, Maryland, and Providence, Rhode Island, were tested using the devices. All sample testing followed parallel and standardized protocols in the two labs. Results: The lowest limit of detection (0.100 mcg/mL), false negative (3.7%), and false positive rate (9.6%) was found for fentanyl test strips, which also correctly detected two fentanyl analogs (acetyl fentanyl and furanyl fentanyl) alone or in the presence of another drug, in both powder and pill forms. While less sensitive and specific for fentanyl, the other devices conveyed additional relevant information including the percentage of fentanyl and presence of cutting agents and other drugs. Conclusion: Devices for fentanyl drug checking are available and valid. Drug checking services and drug supply surveillance should be considered and researched as part of public health responses to the opioid overdose crisis.

KW - Drug checking

KW - Fentanyl

KW - Harm reduction

KW - Overdose

KW - Public health

KW - Surveillance

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85077790543&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85077790543&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.drugpo.2020.102661

DO - 10.1016/j.drugpo.2020.102661

M3 - Article

C2 - 31951925

AN - SCOPUS:85077790543

VL - 77

JO - International Journal of Drug Policy

JF - International Journal of Drug Policy

SN - 0955-3959

M1 - 102661

ER -