Accuracy of 3D volumetric image registration based on CT, MR and PET/CT phantom experiments

Guang Li, Huchen Xie, Holly Ning, Deborah Citrin, Jacek Capala, Roberto Maass-Moreno, Peter Guion, Barbara Arora, Norman Coleman, Kevin Camphausen, Robert W. Miller

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Registration is critical for image-based treatment planning and image-guided treatment delivery. Although automatic registration is available, manual, visual-based image fusion using three orthogonal planar views (3P) is always employed clinically to verify and adjust an automatic registration result. However, the 3P fusion can be time consuming, observer dependent, as well as prone to errors, owing to the incomplete 3-dimensional (3D) volumetric image representations. It is also limited to single-pixel precision (the screen resolution). The 3D volumetric image registration (3DVIR) technique was developed to overcome these shortcomings. This technique introduces a 4th dimension in the registration criteria beyond the image volume, offering both visual and quantitative correlation of corresponding anatomic landmarks within the two registration images, facilitating a volumetric image alignment, and minimizing potential registration errors. The 3DVIR combines image classification in real-time to select and visualize a reliable anatomic landmark, rather than using all voxels for alignment. To determine the detection limit of the visual and quantitative 3DVIR criteria, slightly misaligned images were simulated and presented to eight clinical personnel for interpretation. Both of the criteria produce a detection limit of 0.1 mm and 0.1o. To determine the accuracy of the 3DVIR method, three imaging modalities (CT, MR and PET/CT) were used to acquire multiple phantom images with known spatial shifts. Lateral shifts were applied to these phantoms with displacement intervals of 5.0±0.1 mm. The accuracy of the 3DVIR technique was determined by comparing the image shifts determined through registration to the physical shifts made experimentally. The registration accuracy, together with precision, was found to be: 0.02±0.09 mm for CT/CT images, 0.03±0.07 mm for MR/MR images, and 0.03±0.35 mm for PET/CT images. This accuracy is consistent with the detection limit, suggesting an absence of detectable systematic error. This 3DVIR technique provides a superior alternative to the 3P fusion method for clinical applications.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)17-36
Number of pages20
JournalJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
Volume9
Issue number4
StatePublished - 2008
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Image registration
Anatomic Landmarks
Limit of Detection
Experiments
Image fusion
Image classification
Systematic errors
landmarks
fusion
shift
Pixels
Personnel
Imaging techniques
Planning
alignment
image classification
personnel

Keywords

  • 3D volumetric image registration
  • Accuracy
  • Image visualization
  • Image-guided radiation therapy (IGRT)
  • Multi-modality imaging
  • Radiation treatment planning

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging
  • Radiation
  • Instrumentation

Cite this

Li, G., Xie, H., Ning, H., Citrin, D., Capala, J., Maass-Moreno, R., ... Miller, R. W. (2008). Accuracy of 3D volumetric image registration based on CT, MR and PET/CT phantom experiments. Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 9(4), 17-36.

Accuracy of 3D volumetric image registration based on CT, MR and PET/CT phantom experiments. / Li, Guang; Xie, Huchen; Ning, Holly; Citrin, Deborah; Capala, Jacek; Maass-Moreno, Roberto; Guion, Peter; Arora, Barbara; Coleman, Norman; Camphausen, Kevin; Miller, Robert W.

In: Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, Vol. 9, No. 4, 2008, p. 17-36.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Li, G, Xie, H, Ning, H, Citrin, D, Capala, J, Maass-Moreno, R, Guion, P, Arora, B, Coleman, N, Camphausen, K & Miller, RW 2008, 'Accuracy of 3D volumetric image registration based on CT, MR and PET/CT phantom experiments', Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 17-36.
Li, Guang ; Xie, Huchen ; Ning, Holly ; Citrin, Deborah ; Capala, Jacek ; Maass-Moreno, Roberto ; Guion, Peter ; Arora, Barbara ; Coleman, Norman ; Camphausen, Kevin ; Miller, Robert W. / Accuracy of 3D volumetric image registration based on CT, MR and PET/CT phantom experiments. In: Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics. 2008 ; Vol. 9, No. 4. pp. 17-36.
@article{268356bbe4d740e091679fdcf0990205,
title = "Accuracy of 3D volumetric image registration based on CT, MR and PET/CT phantom experiments",
abstract = "Registration is critical for image-based treatment planning and image-guided treatment delivery. Although automatic registration is available, manual, visual-based image fusion using three orthogonal planar views (3P) is always employed clinically to verify and adjust an automatic registration result. However, the 3P fusion can be time consuming, observer dependent, as well as prone to errors, owing to the incomplete 3-dimensional (3D) volumetric image representations. It is also limited to single-pixel precision (the screen resolution). The 3D volumetric image registration (3DVIR) technique was developed to overcome these shortcomings. This technique introduces a 4th dimension in the registration criteria beyond the image volume, offering both visual and quantitative correlation of corresponding anatomic landmarks within the two registration images, facilitating a volumetric image alignment, and minimizing potential registration errors. The 3DVIR combines image classification in real-time to select and visualize a reliable anatomic landmark, rather than using all voxels for alignment. To determine the detection limit of the visual and quantitative 3DVIR criteria, slightly misaligned images were simulated and presented to eight clinical personnel for interpretation. Both of the criteria produce a detection limit of 0.1 mm and 0.1o. To determine the accuracy of the 3DVIR method, three imaging modalities (CT, MR and PET/CT) were used to acquire multiple phantom images with known spatial shifts. Lateral shifts were applied to these phantoms with displacement intervals of 5.0±0.1 mm. The accuracy of the 3DVIR technique was determined by comparing the image shifts determined through registration to the physical shifts made experimentally. The registration accuracy, together with precision, was found to be: 0.02±0.09 mm for CT/CT images, 0.03±0.07 mm for MR/MR images, and 0.03±0.35 mm for PET/CT images. This accuracy is consistent with the detection limit, suggesting an absence of detectable systematic error. This 3DVIR technique provides a superior alternative to the 3P fusion method for clinical applications.",
keywords = "3D volumetric image registration, Accuracy, Image visualization, Image-guided radiation therapy (IGRT), Multi-modality imaging, Radiation treatment planning",
author = "Guang Li and Huchen Xie and Holly Ning and Deborah Citrin and Jacek Capala and Roberto Maass-Moreno and Peter Guion and Barbara Arora and Norman Coleman and Kevin Camphausen and Miller, {Robert W.}",
year = "2008",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "9",
pages = "17--36",
journal = "Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics",
issn = "1526-9914",
publisher = "American Institute of Physics Publising LLC",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Accuracy of 3D volumetric image registration based on CT, MR and PET/CT phantom experiments

AU - Li, Guang

AU - Xie, Huchen

AU - Ning, Holly

AU - Citrin, Deborah

AU - Capala, Jacek

AU - Maass-Moreno, Roberto

AU - Guion, Peter

AU - Arora, Barbara

AU - Coleman, Norman

AU - Camphausen, Kevin

AU - Miller, Robert W.

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - Registration is critical for image-based treatment planning and image-guided treatment delivery. Although automatic registration is available, manual, visual-based image fusion using three orthogonal planar views (3P) is always employed clinically to verify and adjust an automatic registration result. However, the 3P fusion can be time consuming, observer dependent, as well as prone to errors, owing to the incomplete 3-dimensional (3D) volumetric image representations. It is also limited to single-pixel precision (the screen resolution). The 3D volumetric image registration (3DVIR) technique was developed to overcome these shortcomings. This technique introduces a 4th dimension in the registration criteria beyond the image volume, offering both visual and quantitative correlation of corresponding anatomic landmarks within the two registration images, facilitating a volumetric image alignment, and minimizing potential registration errors. The 3DVIR combines image classification in real-time to select and visualize a reliable anatomic landmark, rather than using all voxels for alignment. To determine the detection limit of the visual and quantitative 3DVIR criteria, slightly misaligned images were simulated and presented to eight clinical personnel for interpretation. Both of the criteria produce a detection limit of 0.1 mm and 0.1o. To determine the accuracy of the 3DVIR method, three imaging modalities (CT, MR and PET/CT) were used to acquire multiple phantom images with known spatial shifts. Lateral shifts were applied to these phantoms with displacement intervals of 5.0±0.1 mm. The accuracy of the 3DVIR technique was determined by comparing the image shifts determined through registration to the physical shifts made experimentally. The registration accuracy, together with precision, was found to be: 0.02±0.09 mm for CT/CT images, 0.03±0.07 mm for MR/MR images, and 0.03±0.35 mm for PET/CT images. This accuracy is consistent with the detection limit, suggesting an absence of detectable systematic error. This 3DVIR technique provides a superior alternative to the 3P fusion method for clinical applications.

AB - Registration is critical for image-based treatment planning and image-guided treatment delivery. Although automatic registration is available, manual, visual-based image fusion using three orthogonal planar views (3P) is always employed clinically to verify and adjust an automatic registration result. However, the 3P fusion can be time consuming, observer dependent, as well as prone to errors, owing to the incomplete 3-dimensional (3D) volumetric image representations. It is also limited to single-pixel precision (the screen resolution). The 3D volumetric image registration (3DVIR) technique was developed to overcome these shortcomings. This technique introduces a 4th dimension in the registration criteria beyond the image volume, offering both visual and quantitative correlation of corresponding anatomic landmarks within the two registration images, facilitating a volumetric image alignment, and minimizing potential registration errors. The 3DVIR combines image classification in real-time to select and visualize a reliable anatomic landmark, rather than using all voxels for alignment. To determine the detection limit of the visual and quantitative 3DVIR criteria, slightly misaligned images were simulated and presented to eight clinical personnel for interpretation. Both of the criteria produce a detection limit of 0.1 mm and 0.1o. To determine the accuracy of the 3DVIR method, three imaging modalities (CT, MR and PET/CT) were used to acquire multiple phantom images with known spatial shifts. Lateral shifts were applied to these phantoms with displacement intervals of 5.0±0.1 mm. The accuracy of the 3DVIR technique was determined by comparing the image shifts determined through registration to the physical shifts made experimentally. The registration accuracy, together with precision, was found to be: 0.02±0.09 mm for CT/CT images, 0.03±0.07 mm for MR/MR images, and 0.03±0.35 mm for PET/CT images. This accuracy is consistent with the detection limit, suggesting an absence of detectable systematic error. This 3DVIR technique provides a superior alternative to the 3P fusion method for clinical applications.

KW - 3D volumetric image registration

KW - Accuracy

KW - Image visualization

KW - Image-guided radiation therapy (IGRT)

KW - Multi-modality imaging

KW - Radiation treatment planning

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=70049118687&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=70049118687&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:70049118687

VL - 9

SP - 17

EP - 36

JO - Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics

JF - Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics

SN - 1526-9914

IS - 4

ER -