A projection image database to investigate factors affecting image quality in weight-based dosing: Application to pediatric renal SPECT

Ye Li, Shannon O'Reilly, Donika Plyku, S. Ted Treves, Yong Du, Frederic Fahey, Xinhua Cao, Abhinav Kumar Jha, George Sgouros, Wesley E. Bolch, Eric Frey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Balancing the tradeoff between radiation dose, acquisition duration and diagnostic image quality is essential for medical imaging modalities involving ionizing radiation. Lower administered activities to the patient can reduce absorbed dose, but can result in reduced diagnostic image quality or require longer acquisition durations. In pediatric nuclear medicine, it is desirable to use the lowest amount of administered radiopharmaceutical activity and the shortest acquisition duration that gives sufficient image quality for clinical diagnosis. However, diagnostic image quality is a complex function of patient factors including body morphometry. In this study, we present a digital population of 90 computational anatomic phantoms that model realistic variations in body morphometry and internal anatomy. These phantoms were used to generate a large database of projection images modeling pediatric SPECT imaging using a 99mTc-DMSA tracer. We used an analytic projection code that models attenuation, spatially varying collimator-detector response, and object-dependent scatter to generate the projections. The projections for each organ were generated separately and can be subsequently scaled by parameters extracted from a pharmacokinetics model to simulate realistic tracer biodistribution, including variations in uptake, inside each relevant organ or tissue structure for a given tracer. Noise-free projection images can be obtained by summing these individual organ projections and scaling by the system sensitivity and acquisition duration. We applied this database in the context of 99mTc-DMSA renal SPECT, the most common nuclear medicine imaging procedure in pediatric patients. Organ uptake fractions based on literature values and patient studies were used. Patient SPECT images were used to verify that the sum of counts in the simulated projection images was clinically realistic. For each phantom, 384 uptake realizations, modeling random variations in the uptakes of organs of interest, were generated, producing 34 560 noise-free projection datasets (384 uptake realizations times 90 phantoms). Noisy images modeling various count levels (corresponding to different products of acquisition duration and administered activity) were generated by appropriately scaling these images and simulating Poisson noise. Acquisition duration was fixed; six count levels were simulated corresponding to projection images acquired using 25%, 50%, 75%, 100%, 125%, and 150% of the original weight-based administrated activity as computed using the North American Guidelines (Gelfand et al 2011 J. Nucl. Med. 52 318-22). Combined, a total number of 207 360 noisy projection images were generated, creating a realistic projection database for use in renal pediatric SPECT imaging research. The phantoms and projection datasets were used to calculate three surrogate indices for factors affecting image quality: renal count density, average radius of rotation, and scatter-to-primary ratio. Differences in these indices were seen across the phantoms for dosing based on current guidelines, and especially for the phantom modeling the newborn. We also performed an image quality study using an anthropomorphic model observer that demonstrates that the weight-based dose scaling does not equalize image quality as measured by the area under the receiver-operating characteristics curve. These studies suggest that a dosing procedure beyond weight-based scaling of administered activities is required to equalize image quality in pediatric renal SPECT.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number145004
JournalPhysics in Medicine and Biology
Volume63
Issue number14
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 9 2018

Fingerprint

Single-Photon Emission-Computed Tomography
Databases
Pediatrics
Kidney
Weights and Measures
Technetium Tc 99m Dimercaptosuccinic Acid
Noise
Nuclear Medicine
Guidelines
Anatomic Models
Radiopharmaceuticals
Diagnostic Imaging
Ionizing Radiation
ROC Curve
Anatomy
Pharmacokinetics
Newborn Infant
Radiation
Research
Population

Keywords

  • DMSA
  • dose reduction/optimization
  • dosing guidelines
  • pediatric imaging
  • SPECT
  • task-based image quality

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiological and Ultrasound Technology
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

A projection image database to investigate factors affecting image quality in weight-based dosing : Application to pediatric renal SPECT. / Li, Ye; O'Reilly, Shannon; Plyku, Donika; Treves, S. Ted; Du, Yong; Fahey, Frederic; Cao, Xinhua; Jha, Abhinav Kumar; Sgouros, George; Bolch, Wesley E.; Frey, Eric.

In: Physics in Medicine and Biology, Vol. 63, No. 14, 145004, 09.07.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Li, Ye ; O'Reilly, Shannon ; Plyku, Donika ; Treves, S. Ted ; Du, Yong ; Fahey, Frederic ; Cao, Xinhua ; Jha, Abhinav Kumar ; Sgouros, George ; Bolch, Wesley E. ; Frey, Eric. / A projection image database to investigate factors affecting image quality in weight-based dosing : Application to pediatric renal SPECT. In: Physics in Medicine and Biology. 2018 ; Vol. 63, No. 14.
@article{d6a9df4cbe8048658a9a10e17dd12ac1,
title = "A projection image database to investigate factors affecting image quality in weight-based dosing: Application to pediatric renal SPECT",
abstract = "Balancing the tradeoff between radiation dose, acquisition duration and diagnostic image quality is essential for medical imaging modalities involving ionizing radiation. Lower administered activities to the patient can reduce absorbed dose, but can result in reduced diagnostic image quality or require longer acquisition durations. In pediatric nuclear medicine, it is desirable to use the lowest amount of administered radiopharmaceutical activity and the shortest acquisition duration that gives sufficient image quality for clinical diagnosis. However, diagnostic image quality is a complex function of patient factors including body morphometry. In this study, we present a digital population of 90 computational anatomic phantoms that model realistic variations in body morphometry and internal anatomy. These phantoms were used to generate a large database of projection images modeling pediatric SPECT imaging using a 99mTc-DMSA tracer. We used an analytic projection code that models attenuation, spatially varying collimator-detector response, and object-dependent scatter to generate the projections. The projections for each organ were generated separately and can be subsequently scaled by parameters extracted from a pharmacokinetics model to simulate realistic tracer biodistribution, including variations in uptake, inside each relevant organ or tissue structure for a given tracer. Noise-free projection images can be obtained by summing these individual organ projections and scaling by the system sensitivity and acquisition duration. We applied this database in the context of 99mTc-DMSA renal SPECT, the most common nuclear medicine imaging procedure in pediatric patients. Organ uptake fractions based on literature values and patient studies were used. Patient SPECT images were used to verify that the sum of counts in the simulated projection images was clinically realistic. For each phantom, 384 uptake realizations, modeling random variations in the uptakes of organs of interest, were generated, producing 34 560 noise-free projection datasets (384 uptake realizations times 90 phantoms). Noisy images modeling various count levels (corresponding to different products of acquisition duration and administered activity) were generated by appropriately scaling these images and simulating Poisson noise. Acquisition duration was fixed; six count levels were simulated corresponding to projection images acquired using 25{\%}, 50{\%}, 75{\%}, 100{\%}, 125{\%}, and 150{\%} of the original weight-based administrated activity as computed using the North American Guidelines (Gelfand et al 2011 J. Nucl. Med. 52 318-22). Combined, a total number of 207 360 noisy projection images were generated, creating a realistic projection database for use in renal pediatric SPECT imaging research. The phantoms and projection datasets were used to calculate three surrogate indices for factors affecting image quality: renal count density, average radius of rotation, and scatter-to-primary ratio. Differences in these indices were seen across the phantoms for dosing based on current guidelines, and especially for the phantom modeling the newborn. We also performed an image quality study using an anthropomorphic model observer that demonstrates that the weight-based dose scaling does not equalize image quality as measured by the area under the receiver-operating characteristics curve. These studies suggest that a dosing procedure beyond weight-based scaling of administered activities is required to equalize image quality in pediatric renal SPECT.",
keywords = "DMSA, dose reduction/optimization, dosing guidelines, pediatric imaging, SPECT, task-based image quality",
author = "Ye Li and Shannon O'Reilly and Donika Plyku and Treves, {S. Ted} and Yong Du and Frederic Fahey and Xinhua Cao and Jha, {Abhinav Kumar} and George Sgouros and Bolch, {Wesley E.} and Eric Frey",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
day = "9",
doi = "10.1088/1361-6560/aacbf0",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "63",
journal = "Physics in Medicine and Biology",
issn = "0031-9155",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "14",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A projection image database to investigate factors affecting image quality in weight-based dosing

T2 - Application to pediatric renal SPECT

AU - Li, Ye

AU - O'Reilly, Shannon

AU - Plyku, Donika

AU - Treves, S. Ted

AU - Du, Yong

AU - Fahey, Frederic

AU - Cao, Xinhua

AU - Jha, Abhinav Kumar

AU - Sgouros, George

AU - Bolch, Wesley E.

AU - Frey, Eric

PY - 2018/7/9

Y1 - 2018/7/9

N2 - Balancing the tradeoff between radiation dose, acquisition duration and diagnostic image quality is essential for medical imaging modalities involving ionizing radiation. Lower administered activities to the patient can reduce absorbed dose, but can result in reduced diagnostic image quality or require longer acquisition durations. In pediatric nuclear medicine, it is desirable to use the lowest amount of administered radiopharmaceutical activity and the shortest acquisition duration that gives sufficient image quality for clinical diagnosis. However, diagnostic image quality is a complex function of patient factors including body morphometry. In this study, we present a digital population of 90 computational anatomic phantoms that model realistic variations in body morphometry and internal anatomy. These phantoms were used to generate a large database of projection images modeling pediatric SPECT imaging using a 99mTc-DMSA tracer. We used an analytic projection code that models attenuation, spatially varying collimator-detector response, and object-dependent scatter to generate the projections. The projections for each organ were generated separately and can be subsequently scaled by parameters extracted from a pharmacokinetics model to simulate realistic tracer biodistribution, including variations in uptake, inside each relevant organ or tissue structure for a given tracer. Noise-free projection images can be obtained by summing these individual organ projections and scaling by the system sensitivity and acquisition duration. We applied this database in the context of 99mTc-DMSA renal SPECT, the most common nuclear medicine imaging procedure in pediatric patients. Organ uptake fractions based on literature values and patient studies were used. Patient SPECT images were used to verify that the sum of counts in the simulated projection images was clinically realistic. For each phantom, 384 uptake realizations, modeling random variations in the uptakes of organs of interest, were generated, producing 34 560 noise-free projection datasets (384 uptake realizations times 90 phantoms). Noisy images modeling various count levels (corresponding to different products of acquisition duration and administered activity) were generated by appropriately scaling these images and simulating Poisson noise. Acquisition duration was fixed; six count levels were simulated corresponding to projection images acquired using 25%, 50%, 75%, 100%, 125%, and 150% of the original weight-based administrated activity as computed using the North American Guidelines (Gelfand et al 2011 J. Nucl. Med. 52 318-22). Combined, a total number of 207 360 noisy projection images were generated, creating a realistic projection database for use in renal pediatric SPECT imaging research. The phantoms and projection datasets were used to calculate three surrogate indices for factors affecting image quality: renal count density, average radius of rotation, and scatter-to-primary ratio. Differences in these indices were seen across the phantoms for dosing based on current guidelines, and especially for the phantom modeling the newborn. We also performed an image quality study using an anthropomorphic model observer that demonstrates that the weight-based dose scaling does not equalize image quality as measured by the area under the receiver-operating characteristics curve. These studies suggest that a dosing procedure beyond weight-based scaling of administered activities is required to equalize image quality in pediatric renal SPECT.

AB - Balancing the tradeoff between radiation dose, acquisition duration and diagnostic image quality is essential for medical imaging modalities involving ionizing radiation. Lower administered activities to the patient can reduce absorbed dose, but can result in reduced diagnostic image quality or require longer acquisition durations. In pediatric nuclear medicine, it is desirable to use the lowest amount of administered radiopharmaceutical activity and the shortest acquisition duration that gives sufficient image quality for clinical diagnosis. However, diagnostic image quality is a complex function of patient factors including body morphometry. In this study, we present a digital population of 90 computational anatomic phantoms that model realistic variations in body morphometry and internal anatomy. These phantoms were used to generate a large database of projection images modeling pediatric SPECT imaging using a 99mTc-DMSA tracer. We used an analytic projection code that models attenuation, spatially varying collimator-detector response, and object-dependent scatter to generate the projections. The projections for each organ were generated separately and can be subsequently scaled by parameters extracted from a pharmacokinetics model to simulate realistic tracer biodistribution, including variations in uptake, inside each relevant organ or tissue structure for a given tracer. Noise-free projection images can be obtained by summing these individual organ projections and scaling by the system sensitivity and acquisition duration. We applied this database in the context of 99mTc-DMSA renal SPECT, the most common nuclear medicine imaging procedure in pediatric patients. Organ uptake fractions based on literature values and patient studies were used. Patient SPECT images were used to verify that the sum of counts in the simulated projection images was clinically realistic. For each phantom, 384 uptake realizations, modeling random variations in the uptakes of organs of interest, were generated, producing 34 560 noise-free projection datasets (384 uptake realizations times 90 phantoms). Noisy images modeling various count levels (corresponding to different products of acquisition duration and administered activity) were generated by appropriately scaling these images and simulating Poisson noise. Acquisition duration was fixed; six count levels were simulated corresponding to projection images acquired using 25%, 50%, 75%, 100%, 125%, and 150% of the original weight-based administrated activity as computed using the North American Guidelines (Gelfand et al 2011 J. Nucl. Med. 52 318-22). Combined, a total number of 207 360 noisy projection images were generated, creating a realistic projection database for use in renal pediatric SPECT imaging research. The phantoms and projection datasets were used to calculate three surrogate indices for factors affecting image quality: renal count density, average radius of rotation, and scatter-to-primary ratio. Differences in these indices were seen across the phantoms for dosing based on current guidelines, and especially for the phantom modeling the newborn. We also performed an image quality study using an anthropomorphic model observer that demonstrates that the weight-based dose scaling does not equalize image quality as measured by the area under the receiver-operating characteristics curve. These studies suggest that a dosing procedure beyond weight-based scaling of administered activities is required to equalize image quality in pediatric renal SPECT.

KW - DMSA

KW - dose reduction/optimization

KW - dosing guidelines

KW - pediatric imaging

KW - SPECT

KW - task-based image quality

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85050775272&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85050775272&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1088/1361-6560/aacbf0

DO - 10.1088/1361-6560/aacbf0

M3 - Article

C2 - 29893291

AN - SCOPUS:85050775272

VL - 63

JO - Physics in Medicine and Biology

JF - Physics in Medicine and Biology

SN - 0031-9155

IS - 14

M1 - 145004

ER -