A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems

Derrick Parkhurst, Ernst Niebur

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Level of detail (LOD) rendering techniques reduce the geometric complexity of 3D models, sacrificing visual rendering quality in order to increase frame rendering rates. Perceptually adaptive LOD rendering techniques take into account the characteristics of the human visual system to minimize visible artifacts attributable to the reduced LOD. While these techniques have been previously examined in the context of high-performance rendering systems, it is not clear whether the benefits will necessarily overcome the behavioral costs associated with a reduced LOD on ordinary desktop systems. To answer this question, two perceptually adaptive rendering techniques, one velocity-dependent and one gaze-contingent, were implemented in the Unreal™ rendering engine on a standard desktop computer and monitor. These techniques were evaluated in separate experiments where participants were required to perform a virtual search for a target object among distractor objects in a perceptually rendered virtual home interior using a mouse to rotate the viewport. In the first experiment, objects moving across the observer's field of view were rendered in less detail than stationary objects, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity to the details of moving objects is substantially reduced. Reaction times to detect the target remained constant with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. In a second experiment, an eye tracker was used to render objects at the point of gaze in more detail than objects in the periphery, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity is greatest at that location. Reaction times to detect the target increased with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. The results from these experiments suggest that a reduced LOD can impede target identification, however, the resultant increase in frame rates facilitates virtual interaction. Overall, the behavioral costs associated with perceptually adaptive LOD techniques can be offset by the behavioral performance gains on desktop systems. However, we show that the nature of the task is important in determining the exact cost-benefit trade-off.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationProceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004
EditorsS.N. Spencer
Pages49-56
Number of pages8
StatePublished - 2004
EventProceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004 - Los Angeles, CA, United States
Duration: Aug 7 2004Aug 8 2004

Other

OtherProceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004
CountryUnited States
CityLos Angeles, CA
Period8/7/048/8/04

Fingerprint

Experiments
Costs
Personal computers
Engines

Keywords

  • Gaze-Contingent
  • Velocity-dependent
  • Visual Search

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Engineering(all)

Cite this

Parkhurst, D., & Niebur, E. (2004). A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems. In S. N. Spencer (Ed.), Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004 (pp. 49-56)

A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems. / Parkhurst, Derrick; Niebur, Ernst.

Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004. ed. / S.N. Spencer. 2004. p. 49-56.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Parkhurst, D & Niebur, E 2004, A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems. in SN Spencer (ed.), Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004. pp. 49-56, Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004, Los Angeles, CA, United States, 8/7/04.
Parkhurst D, Niebur E. A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems. In Spencer SN, editor, Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004. 2004. p. 49-56
Parkhurst, Derrick ; Niebur, Ernst. / A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems. Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004. editor / S.N. Spencer. 2004. pp. 49-56
@inproceedings{6ddc410caba34126907826ea3680db2d,
title = "A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems",
abstract = "Level of detail (LOD) rendering techniques reduce the geometric complexity of 3D models, sacrificing visual rendering quality in order to increase frame rendering rates. Perceptually adaptive LOD rendering techniques take into account the characteristics of the human visual system to minimize visible artifacts attributable to the reduced LOD. While these techniques have been previously examined in the context of high-performance rendering systems, it is not clear whether the benefits will necessarily overcome the behavioral costs associated with a reduced LOD on ordinary desktop systems. To answer this question, two perceptually adaptive rendering techniques, one velocity-dependent and one gaze-contingent, were implemented in the Unreal™ rendering engine on a standard desktop computer and monitor. These techniques were evaluated in separate experiments where participants were required to perform a virtual search for a target object among distractor objects in a perceptually rendered virtual home interior using a mouse to rotate the viewport. In the first experiment, objects moving across the observer's field of view were rendered in less detail than stationary objects, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity to the details of moving objects is substantially reduced. Reaction times to detect the target remained constant with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. In a second experiment, an eye tracker was used to render objects at the point of gaze in more detail than objects in the periphery, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity is greatest at that location. Reaction times to detect the target increased with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. The results from these experiments suggest that a reduced LOD can impede target identification, however, the resultant increase in frame rates facilitates virtual interaction. Overall, the behavioral costs associated with perceptually adaptive LOD techniques can be offset by the behavioral performance gains on desktop systems. However, we show that the nature of the task is important in determining the exact cost-benefit trade-off.",
keywords = "Gaze-Contingent, Velocity-dependent, Visual Search",
author = "Derrick Parkhurst and Ernst Niebur",
year = "2004",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "1581139144",
pages = "49--56",
editor = "S.N. Spencer",
booktitle = "Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - A feasibility test for perceptually adaptive level of detail rendering on desktop systems

AU - Parkhurst, Derrick

AU - Niebur, Ernst

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - Level of detail (LOD) rendering techniques reduce the geometric complexity of 3D models, sacrificing visual rendering quality in order to increase frame rendering rates. Perceptually adaptive LOD rendering techniques take into account the characteristics of the human visual system to minimize visible artifacts attributable to the reduced LOD. While these techniques have been previously examined in the context of high-performance rendering systems, it is not clear whether the benefits will necessarily overcome the behavioral costs associated with a reduced LOD on ordinary desktop systems. To answer this question, two perceptually adaptive rendering techniques, one velocity-dependent and one gaze-contingent, were implemented in the Unreal™ rendering engine on a standard desktop computer and monitor. These techniques were evaluated in separate experiments where participants were required to perform a virtual search for a target object among distractor objects in a perceptually rendered virtual home interior using a mouse to rotate the viewport. In the first experiment, objects moving across the observer's field of view were rendered in less detail than stationary objects, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity to the details of moving objects is substantially reduced. Reaction times to detect the target remained constant with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. In a second experiment, an eye tracker was used to render objects at the point of gaze in more detail than objects in the periphery, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity is greatest at that location. Reaction times to detect the target increased with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. The results from these experiments suggest that a reduced LOD can impede target identification, however, the resultant increase in frame rates facilitates virtual interaction. Overall, the behavioral costs associated with perceptually adaptive LOD techniques can be offset by the behavioral performance gains on desktop systems. However, we show that the nature of the task is important in determining the exact cost-benefit trade-off.

AB - Level of detail (LOD) rendering techniques reduce the geometric complexity of 3D models, sacrificing visual rendering quality in order to increase frame rendering rates. Perceptually adaptive LOD rendering techniques take into account the characteristics of the human visual system to minimize visible artifacts attributable to the reduced LOD. While these techniques have been previously examined in the context of high-performance rendering systems, it is not clear whether the benefits will necessarily overcome the behavioral costs associated with a reduced LOD on ordinary desktop systems. To answer this question, two perceptually adaptive rendering techniques, one velocity-dependent and one gaze-contingent, were implemented in the Unreal™ rendering engine on a standard desktop computer and monitor. These techniques were evaluated in separate experiments where participants were required to perform a virtual search for a target object among distractor objects in a perceptually rendered virtual home interior using a mouse to rotate the viewport. In the first experiment, objects moving across the observer's field of view were rendered in less detail than stationary objects, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity to the details of moving objects is substantially reduced. Reaction times to detect the target remained constant with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. In a second experiment, an eye tracker was used to render objects at the point of gaze in more detail than objects in the periphery, taking advantage of the fact that visual sensitivity is greatest at that location. Reaction times to detect the target increased with decreasing detail, whereas reaction times to localize a target decreased. The results from these experiments suggest that a reduced LOD can impede target identification, however, the resultant increase in frame rates facilitates virtual interaction. Overall, the behavioral costs associated with perceptually adaptive LOD techniques can be offset by the behavioral performance gains on desktop systems. However, we show that the nature of the task is important in determining the exact cost-benefit trade-off.

KW - Gaze-Contingent

KW - Velocity-dependent

KW - Visual Search

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=14344251406&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=14344251406&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:14344251406

SN - 1581139144

SN - 9781581139143

SP - 49

EP - 56

BT - Proceedings - 1st Symposium on Applied Perception in Graphics and Visualization, APGV 2004

A2 - Spencer, S.N.

ER -