A biomechanical analysis of tibial ACL reconstruction with graft length mismatch

Evan B. Gaines, Diana Lau, Qais Naziri, Westley Hayes, Julio J. Jauregui, Bhaveen H. Kapadia, William P. Urban, Bashir Zikria

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Introduction: The incidence of graft length mismatch (GLM) during anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is reported to be up to 13%, with a rate of 20% when using bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) allografts. Multiple techniques have been described to accommodate for the longer BPTB graft. As no study has compared the biomechanical properties of these methods (with cyclic loading), we evaluated the strength of four different surgical techniques used to accommodate for GLM during ACL reconstruction. Methods: A total of 32 fresh-frozen bovine tibiae and patellar tendons were divided into four groups based on the method of tibial graft fixation: (1) sutures tied over a post, (2) bone staples, (3) screws and washers, and (4) soft-tissue conversion with interference screw. Biomechanical testing was performed comparing the tensile properties of graft fixation techniques under cyclic loading. Ability to withstand 1500 cycles of load, the maximum tensile strength at load-to-failure, and the mode-of-failure were evaluated. Results: Only group 4 had all grafts intact after 1500 loading cycles, while the other groups had one graft failure at 338 (group 1), 240 (group 2), and 309 (group 3) cycles. The highest mean load-to-failure was observed in group 3 at 762 ± 173 N, which was found to be significantly higher than the other groups. The mean loads to failure in groups 1-4 were 453 ± 86 N, 485 ± 246 N, 762 ± 173 N, and 458 ± 128 N. Conclusion: While there are multiple viable techniques for fixation of a BPTB graft in the case of GLM, this study demonstrated that direct screw fixation offers the strongest construct.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery
Volume25
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2017

Fingerprint

Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction
Transplants
Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone Grafts
Patellar Ligament
Bone and Bones
Tensile Strength
Tibia
Sutures
Allografts
Incidence

Keywords

  • ACL
  • Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction
  • Biomechanical testing
  • Cyclic loading
  • Graft length mismatch

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

A biomechanical analysis of tibial ACL reconstruction with graft length mismatch. / Gaines, Evan B.; Lau, Diana; Naziri, Qais; Hayes, Westley; Jauregui, Julio J.; Kapadia, Bhaveen H.; Urban, William P.; Zikria, Bashir.

In: Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery, Vol. 25, No. 1, 01.01.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gaines, Evan B. ; Lau, Diana ; Naziri, Qais ; Hayes, Westley ; Jauregui, Julio J. ; Kapadia, Bhaveen H. ; Urban, William P. ; Zikria, Bashir. / A biomechanical analysis of tibial ACL reconstruction with graft length mismatch. In: Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery. 2017 ; Vol. 25, No. 1.
@article{0224f58f0a1a465aac15d2635be11ea6,
title = "A biomechanical analysis of tibial ACL reconstruction with graft length mismatch",
abstract = "Introduction: The incidence of graft length mismatch (GLM) during anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is reported to be up to 13{\%}, with a rate of 20{\%} when using bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) allografts. Multiple techniques have been described to accommodate for the longer BPTB graft. As no study has compared the biomechanical properties of these methods (with cyclic loading), we evaluated the strength of four different surgical techniques used to accommodate for GLM during ACL reconstruction. Methods: A total of 32 fresh-frozen bovine tibiae and patellar tendons were divided into four groups based on the method of tibial graft fixation: (1) sutures tied over a post, (2) bone staples, (3) screws and washers, and (4) soft-tissue conversion with interference screw. Biomechanical testing was performed comparing the tensile properties of graft fixation techniques under cyclic loading. Ability to withstand 1500 cycles of load, the maximum tensile strength at load-to-failure, and the mode-of-failure were evaluated. Results: Only group 4 had all grafts intact after 1500 loading cycles, while the other groups had one graft failure at 338 (group 1), 240 (group 2), and 309 (group 3) cycles. The highest mean load-to-failure was observed in group 3 at 762 ± 173 N, which was found to be significantly higher than the other groups. The mean loads to failure in groups 1-4 were 453 ± 86 N, 485 ± 246 N, 762 ± 173 N, and 458 ± 128 N. Conclusion: While there are multiple viable techniques for fixation of a BPTB graft in the case of GLM, this study demonstrated that direct screw fixation offers the strongest construct.",
keywords = "ACL, Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, Biomechanical testing, Cyclic loading, Graft length mismatch",
author = "Gaines, {Evan B.} and Diana Lau and Qais Naziri and Westley Hayes and Jauregui, {Julio J.} and Kapadia, {Bhaveen H.} and Urban, {William P.} and Bashir Zikria",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/2309499017690983",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "25",
journal = "Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery",
issn = "1022-5536",
publisher = "Hong Kong Academy of Medicine Press",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A biomechanical analysis of tibial ACL reconstruction with graft length mismatch

AU - Gaines, Evan B.

AU - Lau, Diana

AU - Naziri, Qais

AU - Hayes, Westley

AU - Jauregui, Julio J.

AU - Kapadia, Bhaveen H.

AU - Urban, William P.

AU - Zikria, Bashir

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Introduction: The incidence of graft length mismatch (GLM) during anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is reported to be up to 13%, with a rate of 20% when using bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) allografts. Multiple techniques have been described to accommodate for the longer BPTB graft. As no study has compared the biomechanical properties of these methods (with cyclic loading), we evaluated the strength of four different surgical techniques used to accommodate for GLM during ACL reconstruction. Methods: A total of 32 fresh-frozen bovine tibiae and patellar tendons were divided into four groups based on the method of tibial graft fixation: (1) sutures tied over a post, (2) bone staples, (3) screws and washers, and (4) soft-tissue conversion with interference screw. Biomechanical testing was performed comparing the tensile properties of graft fixation techniques under cyclic loading. Ability to withstand 1500 cycles of load, the maximum tensile strength at load-to-failure, and the mode-of-failure were evaluated. Results: Only group 4 had all grafts intact after 1500 loading cycles, while the other groups had one graft failure at 338 (group 1), 240 (group 2), and 309 (group 3) cycles. The highest mean load-to-failure was observed in group 3 at 762 ± 173 N, which was found to be significantly higher than the other groups. The mean loads to failure in groups 1-4 were 453 ± 86 N, 485 ± 246 N, 762 ± 173 N, and 458 ± 128 N. Conclusion: While there are multiple viable techniques for fixation of a BPTB graft in the case of GLM, this study demonstrated that direct screw fixation offers the strongest construct.

AB - Introduction: The incidence of graft length mismatch (GLM) during anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is reported to be up to 13%, with a rate of 20% when using bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) allografts. Multiple techniques have been described to accommodate for the longer BPTB graft. As no study has compared the biomechanical properties of these methods (with cyclic loading), we evaluated the strength of four different surgical techniques used to accommodate for GLM during ACL reconstruction. Methods: A total of 32 fresh-frozen bovine tibiae and patellar tendons were divided into four groups based on the method of tibial graft fixation: (1) sutures tied over a post, (2) bone staples, (3) screws and washers, and (4) soft-tissue conversion with interference screw. Biomechanical testing was performed comparing the tensile properties of graft fixation techniques under cyclic loading. Ability to withstand 1500 cycles of load, the maximum tensile strength at load-to-failure, and the mode-of-failure were evaluated. Results: Only group 4 had all grafts intact after 1500 loading cycles, while the other groups had one graft failure at 338 (group 1), 240 (group 2), and 309 (group 3) cycles. The highest mean load-to-failure was observed in group 3 at 762 ± 173 N, which was found to be significantly higher than the other groups. The mean loads to failure in groups 1-4 were 453 ± 86 N, 485 ± 246 N, 762 ± 173 N, and 458 ± 128 N. Conclusion: While there are multiple viable techniques for fixation of a BPTB graft in the case of GLM, this study demonstrated that direct screw fixation offers the strongest construct.

KW - ACL

KW - Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

KW - Biomechanical testing

KW - Cyclic loading

KW - Graft length mismatch

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85033451803&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85033451803&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/2309499017690983

DO - 10.1177/2309499017690983

M3 - Article

VL - 25

JO - Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery

JF - Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery

SN - 1022-5536

IS - 1

ER -